Poll Question: Where do you place the blame on the late meltdown against Tampa Bay? Answer #1: Tomlin for calling third down play (19%) Answer #2: Brad Wing for poor punt (6%) Answer #3: Dick LeBeau for allowing 41-yard pass (19%) Answer #4: Players for allowing 41-yard pass (56%) Answer #5: The return of Renegade (0%)
Ray Fittipaldo: Welcome to my weekly Steelers chat. Please post your questions and we'll get started in a few minutes.
steelmann58: HI Ray terrible loss sun i was there heartbreaking but why didnt the coaches let Ben throw the ball on 3rd down to try and get the 1st
Ray Fittipaldo: Tomlin explained that today at his new conference. He said he told Todd Haley which play to call. The play was a run-pass option and the same play produced a 19-yard pass to Heath Miller and 13 and 16-yard runs by Le'Veon Bell earlier in the game. Ben read the defense correctly and called the running play because the Bucs were playing man to man coverage with a free safety in the middle of the field. Tomlin said the play failed because of poor execution. said he did and still feels comfortable with his decision.
steelmann58: HI Ray Wing @9 yard punt should get someone a tryouy any news on Podesh
Ray Fittipaldo: Tomlin did not sound as if he was going to bring another punter in this week. He said this is a great opportunity for the team to find out what Brad Wing is made of. Now if he gets off another 29-yarder at a crucial junction this week in Jacksonville....
Eric: How do you allow a 41 yd pass play there?!
Ray Fittipaldo: Tomlin said today it was a failure on all three levels of the defense. On the defensive line, it was a four-man front and the stunt they ran was slow to develop. On the second level, the linebackers failed to get the proper depth in their pass drops. And in the back end, the safeties took bad angles that allowed the long run after the catch. Any way you slice it, it's unacceptable to happen in that situation.
Miller: Also, it's funny how Justin Brown is many people's scapegoat, but Miller and Antonio Brown also dropped balls. And what of James Harrison playing so much? It's not like Arthur Moats didn't play well the week before.
Ray Fittipaldo: I don't know about other members of the media, but I wrote a story that squarely placed blame on Brown and Roethlisberger for the offense's inability to put the game away. Brown had the big drop on the flea flicker and Roethlisberger overthrew two wide open receivers. I don't know why Lance Moore isn't playing over Justin Brown, but it sure seems like the coaches have confidence in Brown more than Moore at this point.
Mac: Hi Ray, what exactly do the coaching staff see in Cortez Allen to give him an extension? He seems to struggle in zone coverage with reads and can't matchup with bigger receivers in man. He is average at best. What is your take on Allen?
Ray Fittipaldo: My opinion is they feared going into next season with Antwon Blake and William Gay as the starting corners. I think they faced a similar scenario with Marcus Gilbert at right tackle. They looked at what was behind him (Mike Adams) and figured they had better sign Gilbert because at least he was serviceable and had the potential to get better. I think they feel the same way about Allen. Dick LeBeau has said Allen has been up and down, and he hopes at some point he can put it all together. Obviously, that has not happened yet. He continues to struggle.
Miller: All of these "failures" as Tomlin mentioned... reminds me of the OT game-loser against Tim Tebow and the Broncos. I understand there's a lack of playmakers on this defense and has been for several years, but knowing that and not adjusting your defense to incorporate new players (via free agency) or young players (through the draft) is a sign of the Steelers' superiority complex that has flown in the face of Mr. Rooney's request to develop young players faster and also smacks of "we're smarter than them, we're the Steelers." Your thoughts?
Ray Fittipaldo: I think it has more to do with this defense being complicated and the coaches and front office types not wanting to dip into free agency to replace players with guys who are not familiar with their system. It's why they re-sign guys like William Gay when no one else wants them.
Miguel: Hi Ray, I think the Steelers D problems are because they doesnt adress the NT position. They need Casey Hampton sucesor. Your Thoughts?. Best Regards. The México steelers nation.
Ray Fittipaldo: They certainly miss Casey Hampton, but they have many more issues beside Steve McLendon. Their defensive end play has been below the line as has been the play of the outside linebackers through the first four games.
Chris: It seems like opposing teams always score on their first possession after halftime. Any reason for that?
Ray Fittipaldo: Tomlin was asked today about why teams have had so much success against the Steelers in the second halves of games. He basically said four games is not enough time for a trend to develop. I'm not sure I agree. That's what I'm writing about for tomorrow's paper.
Adrian: Ray, thanks for the chat! I like everyone else am not happy about the loss, but based off what you see at the facility does this team not focus on the details in practice? Seems to me like the work put in isn't working!!! Say lack of discipline in practice!
Ray Fittipaldo: A lot of these penalties are dumb ones for celebrating too much, or for taunting or for arguing with officials. There is no way you'd notice anything in practice in regards to that. Tomlin said today he would like to see Antonio Brown stop celebrating after touchdowns. We'll see if Brown listens to him.
Eric: Tomlin seems to "bristle" a lot when people come down on him, but it's deserved in my opinion because preparation is his main job and that team didn't look prepared at all for that game, would you agree?
Ray Fittipaldo: It was not a good start, but they did come back with 17 unanswered points to make it 17-10 at halftime. They were up by seven and had a chance to put the game away if Antonio Brown catches a routine deep ball from Roethlisberger. I'm not making excuses for the Steelers, who deserve to be harshly criticized for losing to Tampa Bay. But I don't think it was because they came out flat or anything like that. I just think they failed to make the big plays they needed to make to win the game. And the galling thing for them has to be that someone named Mike Glennon, Louis Murphy and a cast of other nobodies were able to make the plays when Roethlisberger, Brown and Bell could not.
Paisano: Ray, i imagine it is hard for the old vets (Ike, Troy, Keisel, Heath, Ben, Deebo) to see the incompetence of the new players. Would it benefit the Steelers in any way to cut bait with ALL older players and let a new, young team take its lumps and find its own success and its own leadership
Ray Fittipaldo: They would never do that. They have never embraced a total rebuild. They believe it's important to have older veterans in the locker room for leadership. They want to put the best players on the field who they believe can help them win football games. And based on their approach the past few years they believe on most accounts that older players give them a better chance of winning.
Brent: Ray, any chance we will see more practice squad members get a chance to show what they can do? Howard Jones and Richardson perhaps?
Ray Fittipaldo: If they thought Howard Jones was ready they never would have signed James Harrison. They simply would have signed Jones from the practice squad to the active roster. And I don't think they're very high on Richardson at this point. They brought in BW Webb from Dallas and have him on the active roster ahead of Shaq.
dave: Why don't they give Shamarko Thomas more playing time? Troy is not what he used to be.
Ray Fittipaldo: They obviously don't feel like he would be that much of an upgrade. Let's face facts. When they decided to bring Polamalu back and sign Mike Mitchell in free agency, Thomas was not going to be in their plans this year. I think next year is the year for Thomas unless there is an injury this year to either Polamalu or Mitchell.
Guest: Is there one pro bowl player on this defense?
Ray Fittipaldo: At this time, no there is not.
Guest: Can we dismiss the idea that penalties cost the steelers the game. This defense is bad, bad, bad. We're seeing the result of poor drafts on the defense since the Timmons/Woodley draft. The best player they drafted since then now plays for New Orleans. The lack of production from the draft on defense has and will continue to set us back for years.
Ray Fittipaldo: The penalties are bothersome, but I agree with you. It's not the reason they're losing these games. They simply are not a consistent football team right now. They're looking to become more consistent.
steelmann58: HI Ray the Left side of the Line looked bad starting to worry about Beachum as our LT. Also Worilds is a complete dud right now.
Ray Fittipaldo: Beachum had a tough day and so did Cody Wallace, who played for the second week in a row in place of Ramon Foster. Tomlin did not sound concerned about Beachum's performance today when asked about it. He basically said there were some other circumstances involved in some of those sacks and said he is confident Beachum will rebound.
Carlo: The CBs seem to be playing off the WRs by at least 10 yds. I understand that they want to prevent a big play but I think a jam at the line of scrimmage might help with giving our so so pass rush a chance to get to the QB, or at least get some pressure. What do you think?
Ray Fittipaldo: They don't have the types of CBs needed to play press coverage. They have CBs who are suited for this defense, which has never really used bump and run on any kind of consistent basis over the years with LeBeau.
Jerry Mum: I know that it's still early in the season but we need to get a pass rush I don't know what we have to do the fix it but without the pass rush we will be in trouble
Ray Fittipaldo: I agree with you. It's going to be a long season if the pass rush does not improve. I said throughout the spring and summer the pass rush was going to be a big key. It has not come through and you see the results for the defense.
Brandon: Any reason why the Steelers seem to always play down to lower teams? Its rare that they win handily, especially over teams they aren't too good.
Ray Fittipaldo: It's the $100,000 question and if Tomlin doesn't figure it out some day (not this year) it might be a reason he eventually gets fired. Those are the types of losses that leave you on the outside looking in on the playoffs. And if they keep it up this year those types of losses will contribute toward another 8-8, non-playoff season.
Brent: Ray, would you say that this team needing time to gel due to all the personnel changes is an optimistic statement or a foolish one?
Ray Fittipaldo: Isn't that was OTAs, minicamp and training camp are for?
rx170: Hi. Can this D be fixed somehow through the season?
Ray Fittipaldo: Sure it can. But it become a defense that helps the Steelers become a playoff team? I don't know about that.
DSF: is it a lack of consistency on D or lack of talent?
Ray Fittipaldo: Both.
Rags: Its starting to look as if the steelers are allowing their opponents to set the tone for games. Saw in in Baltimore and now with Tampa
Ray Fittipaldo: You saw it in Baltimore, but the Steelers overcame the 10-0 deficit and went ahead 17-10 on the Bucs by halftime. Their problem has been sustaining in the second halves of games.
Jon: I know, in reality, the Rooney's won't be firing tomlin anytime soon but after 3 years of changing player after player with the same results how can this not be seen as a head coaching problem, and therefore place Tomlin on the proverbial "hot seat"?
Ray Fittipaldo: Because the Rooneys are patient and like stability. If Tomlin was the coach in Oakland he would have been fired a long time ago. But the Steelers don't operate like the Davis family. Their approach has worked over the years. Now if the Steelers don't make the playoffs this year I think Tomlin will be on the warm seat, but not now based on how they've done things in the past with Chuck Noll and Bill Cowher when they went through some lean years.
Brandon: I really believe the Steelers have a lot of talent on defense. Is it just a matter of everything coming together? 3 injured starters definitely doesn't help either.
Ray Fittipaldo: You think they have "a lot of talent" on defense. I disagree. They are completely mediocre at several positions and downright below average at others.
Will: Will they please just fire Haley
Ray Fittipaldo: I'm not defending Haley, but the Steelers are top 5 in the NFL in total offense and top 12 in scoring offense. Haley's not perfect, but you shouldn't live by the gospel according to Snoop.
Ray Fittipaldo: OK, that's all the time I have this week. Sorry I couldn't get to all your questions. Ed and I will be back to our normal chat times next week. Mine will be Monday at 1:30 again. Thanks for taking part in the chat.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.