Steel City Meltdown: Why have our last several drafts been so poor? What or who is responsible for this sad sack bunch other than Tomlin? Surly we can do better than this.

Ed Bouchette: So are you saying Le'Veon Bell and Markus Wheaton, for example, were poor picks? David DeCastro? Kelvin Beachum? Maurkice Pouncey? Antonio Brown? You don't hit home runs with everyone. I'm not defending their picks, just that I don't agree they have had poor drafts. You want to see poor drafts? Go look at some they made in the 1980s.

Styx: Did you ask Mike T why they didn't play Renegade at the last game?

Ed Bouchette: That was first on my list.

Advertise with us

Anthony: If McLendon cannot play, who will start at NT? Will McCullers play?

Ed Bouchette: I would think Cam Thomas would start at nose tackle and Brett Keisel would make his first start at defensive end this season.

Pitt: Ed. Is this a defense that is composed of poor talent and "old" guys or just a unit taking some time to mesh together?

Ed Bouchette: I think it's a combination -- old guys who maybe should have hung it up, and young guys who have not yet proven themselves. As I wrote this morning in the Post-Gazette, they better hope it's not an overall lack of talent.

Toni: this is your #1 female fan Mr Ed, at what point does the team join the 21st century and draft replacments for stars currently on the roster? Seems like they have a policy of letting their stars play until they become grandaparents and then addressing the position in the draft. Why not draft a TE a year ago for the eventual Heath Miller slowdown that we are now seeing

Advertise with us

Ed Bouchette: They have drafted tight ends, just not high in the draft. For every position they draft high, fans want to know why they did not draft another position -- cornerback, wide receiver, safety, etc.

J&L Mike: This team is not making any progress. If anything I think its worse than last year. How long can we keep putting a sorry looking team on the field and still keep Tomlin?

Ed Bouchette: I know Steelers fans are spoiled and expectations are high but they have not yet had a losing season, they should have made the playoffs last year and this while they flush out veterans from those great teams and try to replace them. It's the way the NFL works and, yes, sometimes it happens in Pittsburgh.

Rick: Ed, It appears the Steelers have gone to a drafting strategy of speed cures all and has had the same results as the Raiders. Is Tomlin the main proponent?

Ed Bouchette: It's not just speed and Tomlin has been very emphatic about that. Chuck Noll also came in and said he wanted more athletes and that helped turn a franchise around.

Advertise with us

Sunny: Ed, can we expect Bill Cowher to return at the end of the season?

Ed Bouchette: I think he will, yes. He's happy with CBS and they are happy with him.

kjacksonpgh: Ed, is it possible that the Marcus Gilbert contract was premature? He got plowed over in the Ravens game and seems to be struggling in pass protection.

Ed Bouchette: It is possible they made a mistake, yes. It's also possible he will get better. It's not like they were brimming with talent at tackle, same thing at cornerback where they signed Cortez Allen.

Ed Bouchette: Not the head coach or GM, if that's what you mean.

Advertise with us

kjacksonpgh: Ed, Do you believe the solution to the Steelers run defense will cure itself with more reps as the season goes on?

Ed Bouchette: They weren't any good at it last year and they have gotten worse this year against two opponents, each of whom was without its top back. So, no, I don't.

Guest: Will McCullers be activated this week? We need to play him now along with Tuitt.

Ed Bouchette: Daniel McCullers is not the guy who is going to save this run defense.

dave: They went from not wanting Keisel to signing him to a 2 year contract. Was this another panic signing based on what they had at the position?

Advertise with us

Ed Bouchette: Actually, they wanted Keisel to come back but were put off when they learned he would not play for the veteran minimum. They gave him a little more than that, ultimately.

Anthony: Do you think that the team regrets not keeping some of the younger DEs that were producing in the preseason?

Ed Bouchette: No, but I think they might regret not bringing Larry Foote back and working Ryan Shazier into the scheme more slowly.

Sunny: Ed, You may have misunderstood my question. Will Cowher be back as head coach?

Ed Bouchette: Not in PIttsburgh, and I really don't think you will see him coach again. I think he's happy what he's doing.

Advertise with us

Guest: Do you think we'll see Martavis Bryant much Sunday night?

Ed Bouchette: No, I do not, especially since Lance Moore seems ready to suit up for his first game at wide receiver.

MR. Ken: Smash mouth football is dead. I can watch arena football for a fraction of what a NFL game costs. How long till NFL falls ?

Ed Bouchette: As long as they keep setting TV ratings records, they must be doing something right.

Same old Steelers.: I have been following the Steelers since the early sixties and can't remember any worse defense than this. I'm sure their must have been some but this group is as bad against the run as I can remember. Very sad to see the once mighty Steelers degrade to this level.

Advertise with us

Ed Bouchette: If you've been following them since the '60s and cannot remember a worse defense, then you should see a doctor because your memory seems to be fading. Also, I will offer you up the 1988 defense. Go look at those stats!

Rob: Ultimately it would seem the defensive problem lies in having average linebackers. Would you agree n the 3-4 iwithout pressure everything else suffers?

Ed Bouchette: Indeed, if they cannot get pressure on quarterbacks (not to mention not stop the run), the defense is really doomed. It was a concern I raised before the season because their top two pass rushers really haven't done it for any appreciable period.

Sunni: Tomlin rode what Cowher left until the tank ran dry, now we are left with the legacy of Limas Sweed and Ziggy Hood. If the Rooney's paid Cowher $10 million a year to come back it wouldn't bother me one bit

Ed Bouchette: You do know they were saying the same things about Bill Cowher during his ugly three-season stretch of 7-9 in 1998, 6-10 in 1999 and 9-7 and no playoffs in 2000. Some people have short memories, but then maybe you weren't born by then and did not know it.

Advertise with us

Rich: Is it time for the Steelers to give a few guys a bus ticket out of town? Seems to me a starter getting cut might send the right message.

Ed Bouchette: Have any sugestions? And if so, who do you replace him/them with?

Ed Bouchette: I don't think their running game is the problem.

Ed Bouchette: Thanks for another great chat. See you next Tuesday.