Last week I wrote about the Steelers’ failures in the red zone over the past several years, which became a hot topic after some high-profile, mistake-prone games in the playoffs. That post chronicled the Steelers’ struggles in the red zone over the past decade.
This week I decided to take a look at some the specific problems that faced the offense in the red zone this season. And after the poor showing in playoff games against the Patriots and Chiefs what better way to dig into the issues than by breaking down every red-zone play from the postseason?
Below all 30 red-zone plays against the Dolphins, Chiefs and Patriots are broken down blow by blow.
You’ll notice how the personnel packages changed as the Steelers went deeper in the playoffs. Fullback Roosevelt Nix was a big part of the Steelers’ wild-card victory over the Dolphins, but he did not play a snap in the red zone over the final two playoff games against the Chiefs and Patriots.
Red-zone efficiency can turn games. It’s interesting to note that the Steelers scored a touchdown when Nix was used when the Steelers had first-and-goal from inside the 1 early in the wild-card game against the Dolphins. When the Steelers faced the exact same situation against the Patriots they failed to score on three consecutive plays before settling for a field goal. It was arguably the turning point in the game.
The Steelers went to a lot of three receiver, one tight end packages against the Chiefs and Patriots. That, of course, is when they struggled most, scoring just one touchdown in 22 snaps in the red zone in those two games. That’s such an unbelievably poor statistic that I wonder if that’s ever been done by a team in the postseason.
All told, the Steelers scored three touchdowns in those 30 red-zone snaps, saved by a better, though not flawless performance, against the Dolphins.
The blame can be spread around. In addition to some questionable personnel packages the Steelers had their fair of physical and mental mistakes. In short, they picked the absolute worst time for some bad execution in the red zone.
Wild card game vs. Miami
Plays in the red zone: 8
Results: 2 touchdowns and 1 field goal.
First red-zone drive
First-and-goal from inside the 1. Personnel: extra tackle, two tight ends and a fullback. Fullback Roosevelt Nix leads right behind right guard David DeCastro, but penetration from the left side plus an aggressive safety stop Le’Veon Bell short of the goal line after he attempts to cut back against the grain. This is on Bell for cutting back on a play that’s designed to be quick-hitting. If Bell had followed Nix he could have walked into the end zone. One other tipoff that Bell should followed Nix: left guard Ramon Foster’s only concern is not allowing penetration. The Dolphins 1-technique (inside shade on Foster) stems to a 3-technique (outside shade) on the back side of the play at the snap, and Foster completely misses him. That’s OK if Bell puts his head down and follows his fullback. It’s not OK if he tries to cut back. Foster’s man helps make the play.
Second-and-goal from the 1. Personnel: extra tackle, two tight ends and fullback. The Steelers pull DeCastro, who first helps left tackle Alejandro Villanueva secure his man that is threatening to disrupt the play before peeling off to block the linebacker. Bell reads the play perfectly and follows DeCastro to the goal line for a touchdown.
Second red-zone drive
First-and-goal at the 6. Personnel: Three receivers and a tight end. Ben Roethlisberger tries a quick screen to Antonio Brown that goes for a loss of one yard after the corner comes up to make the tackle.
Second-and-goal from the 7. Personnel: Three receivers and a tight end. Bell takes a handoff for a play designed over right guard. He has a cutback lane, but decides to try to bounce it outside and is stopped for no gain. A quicker decision by Bell to cut it back would have resulted in positive yardage.
Third-and-goal from the 7. Personnel: Two receivers, two tight ends. Roethlisberger drops back to pass, but his pass protection quickly breaks down. Both Dolphins outside rushers collapse the pocket with effectives rushes against Villanueva and Marcus Gilbert, forcing Roethlisberger to step up in the pocket. Dolphins lineman Ndamukong Suh’s bull rush pushes DeCastro back into the lap of Roethlisberger and he is credited the sack. All receivers were well-covered, but if Roethlisberger had time he had tight end Xavier Grimble with one-on-one coverage as he ran toward the back pylon.
Third red-zone drive
First-and-10 at the 13. Personnel: extra tackle, two tight ends and a fullback. A stemming Dolphins line causes some hesitation for center Maurkice Pouncey, who is late to block the inside linebacker. Bell is tackled for a 2-yard gain. If Pouncey could have gotten a better piece of the linebacker Bell might score.
Second-and-8 at the 11. Personnel: extra tackle, two tight ends, two receivers. Bell runs right and gains three yards.
Third-and-5 from the 8. Personnel: three receivers, one tight end. The Steelers go back to their bread and butter – DeCastro pulling from right to left. The end man on the line of scrimmages crashes and DeCastro perfectly seals him to the inside. Bell follows the block and waltzes into the end zone untouched. Not to be overlooked on the play were the blocks of tight end David Johnson and Villanueva, who got to the second level quickly and stuck on their blocks on the linebackers.
Divisional round game vs. Chiefs
Plays in the red zone: 9
Results: 3 field goals and 1 interception
First red-zone drive
First-and-10 on the 13. Personnel: Three receivers and a tight end. Textbook interior blocking nets Bell eight yards. Two perfectly executed double teams to the second level and Bell’s decision to hit it quickly helped this play be successful.
Second-and-2 from the 5. Personnel: Three receivers and a tight end. With the linemen mauling people on the first drive, it appears offensive coordinator Todd Haley calls for another run. But with the Chiefs crowding eight men near the line of scrimmage Roethlisberger audibles to a pass play. Strangely, he opts to throw to the short side of the field where it was 3-on-2 in favor of the Chiefs instead of throwing to the wide side of the field where two receivers, Darrius Heyward-Bey and Eli Rogers, had single coverage. This is the type of play from Roethlisberger that makes one scratch his head and is one hint as to why the Steelers had some struggles scoring. If you are going to audible out of a running play when your line is playing great you had better get your offense into the right play. On this occasion, Roethlisberger did not do that.
Third-and-2 from the 5. Personnel: three receivers, tight end (empty). A quick pass to Rogers gains only a yard and the Steelers are forced to kick a field goal. If Roethlisberger had waited an extra second he had Cobi Hamilton breaking open in the end zone, but it’s clear the play was designed to go to Rogers, who simply did not run his route with the proper depth.
Second red-zone drive
First-and-10 at the 17. Personnel: Three receivers and a tight end. Roethlisberger finds Antonio Brown in single coverage against Marcus Peters and throws a well-placed pass. Brown has it momentarily before Peterson knocks it from his hands. It was a good play by Peterson to keep the Steelers out of the end zone.
Second-and-10 from the 17. Personnel: three receivers and a tight end. The Steelers pull Gilbert from right to left, but the timing of the play is disrupted when Villanueva is pushed into the backfield, forcing Gilbert and Bell to adjust their routes. The play loses one yard.
Third-and-11 from the 18. Personnel: three receivers and a tight end. Roethlisberger steps up in the pocket when he feels a bit of pressure. His pass to Rogers is incomplete. Even if Roethlisberger had stood tall in the pocket no receivers were breaking open.
Third red-zone drive
First-and-goal at the 5. Personnel: three receivers and a tight end. After a 26-yard pass to Jesse James that set the Steelers up at the 5 Roethlisberger hurried the offense to the line. He did not account for the end man of the line of scrimmage, who tipped his pass high into the air. Chiefs safety Eric Berry came down with the interception in the end zone. For some reason Villanueva blocks down and double teams an interior lineman, leaving his man free to tip the pass. It was obviously a missed assignment or a miscommunication because they hurried to the line. Regardless of whether it was Villanueva or Roethlisberger’s fault it’s the type of mistake that can loses games for teams.
Fourth red-zone drive
Second-and-8 on the 19. Personnel: three receivers and a tight end. Rogers gets single coverage down the hash and gets open in the end zone. Roethlisberger’s pass is slightly behind Rogers, who gets his hands on the ball but is unable to come down with it. A better pass (there was no safety patrolling the middle of the field) would have likely resulted in an easy touchdown.
Third-and-8 from the 19. Personnel: three receivers and a tight end. After his receivers fail to get open, Roethlisberger holds the ball too long and is sacked. It’s hard to pin the sack on any offensive lineman, but Villanueva and DeCastro’s defenders combined on the sack.
AFC championship vs. Patriots
Red zone plays: 13
Results: 1 touchdown, 1 field goal and 1 turnover on downs.
First red zone drive
Second-and-1 at the 17. Personnel: three receivers and a tight end. DeAngelo Williams gains four yards over left guard.
First-and-10 at the 14. Personnel: three receivers and a tight end. The receivers are well-covered and Roethlisberger dumps it off to Williams, who gains three yards.
Second-and-7 at the 11. Personnel: three receivers and a tight end. Once again, the receivers fail to come open and Roethlisberger dumps it off to Jesse James in the right flat. James does a nice job of getting positive yards to set up a third-and-1.
Third-and-1 at the 5. Personnel: three receivers and a tight end. Williams takes the hand off finds his way into the end zone for a touchdown. The left side of the line and Pouncey did a nice job of staying on their blocks.
Second red-zone drive
Third-and-9 at the 19. Personnel: three receivers and a tight end. Jesse James does a nice job of getting open on safety Patrick Chung. He appears to score a touchdown, but the call is reversed, setting up first-and-goal from inside the 1.
First-and-goal inside the 1. Personnel: extra tackle, three tight ends. Where was the quarterback sneak? There never was a good explanation from Roethlisberger or coach Mike Tomlin. Instead, they pulled DeCastro on a handoff to Williams. Chris Hubbard, who was the extra tackle, allowed penetration to the inside and that disrupted the play. Williams lost a yard.
Second-and-goal at the 2. Personnel: extra tackle, three tight ends. A linebacker walks up over center Pouncey just before the ball is snapped and that appears to cause some confusion on blocking assignments. The defensive lineman that was lined up over right guard DeCastro tackled Williams for a 3-yard loss, but DeCastro was pulling and going to the second level to blocker another linebacker. Pouncey’s original job likely was to block down on DeCastro’s man, but he blocked the most immediate threat when the linebacker walked up. The bottom line is Roethlisberger probably needed to audible out of that play once the linebacker walked up to the line of scrimmage. Give credit to the Patriots for the scheme to confuse the blocking assignments.
Third-and-goal at the 5. Personnel: three receivers and a tight end. Perhaps the strangest red-zone play of the postseason. It’s quick three-step drop by Roethlisberger who throws sideways to Rogers, who was at the 5-yard line. The pass was incomplete. Antonio Brown was double covered on the back side, meaning Sammie Coates, James and Rogers all had single coverage. The inability of the secondary receivers to win one-on-one battles was one of the biggest reasons the Steelers were mediocre in the red zone, although the biggest failure of this play is simply the call itself. You have to throw the ball in the end zone, or at the very least dial up a play that gives a receiver a chance to come open, when you’re down 17-6 just before halftime in the AFC championship game.
Third red-zone drive
Third-and-2 at the 14. Personnel: three receivers and a tight end. Roethlisberger completes a pass to Cobi Hamilton for a first down.
First-and-goal at the 6. Personnel: three receivers and a tight end. Williams gained one yard up the middle as the nose tackle defeats Pouncey’s block to make the play.
Second-and-goal at the 5. Personnel: three receivers and a tight end. Williams gained three yards to the 2.
Third-and-goal from the 2. Personnel: three receivers and a tight end. Hamilton catches a touchdown, but he stepped out of the end zone before catching it, which is an illegal touching penalty. The penalty is declined, setting up a fourth-and-goal from the 2.
Fourth-and-goal at the 2. Personnel: two tight ends and two receivers. A fade pattern to Hamilton falls incomplete in the end zone.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.