Almost no task was too large for Steve Pederson to tackle. In his first tenure as athletic director at Pitt, his work in upgrading the bottom-feeding football and basketball programs prompted Beano Cook to call him the man who ''saved Pitt athletics.'' He convinced his bosses to tear down Pitt Stadium and build the Petersen Events Center. In his second tenure, he built baseball, softball and soccer fields on campus. All of these improvements -- wins, losses, facilities -- played a large role in Pitt gaining admittance to the Atlantic Coast Conference.
But there was one undertaking that was too large for Pederson, one crucial element he could not build -- a bridge of support among alumni and fans.
To the applause of many, and particularly an influential group of football lettermen, Pederson was ousted yesterday by Chancellor Patrick Gallagher. On the job only five months, Gallagher’s first foray into athletics was, tellingly, to fire the man who had been a friend and favorite of his predecessor, Mark Nordenberg.
What prompted Gallagher to act so swiftly and decisively is not easily determined. For its part, Pitt called the decision a mutual one. That’s unlikely. Already there was talk Pederson would not have a primary role in the search to find a successor to football coach Paul Chryst, who last night was named coach at Wisconsin. If that is so, Gallagher understandably would feel if his AD couldn’t lead a coaching search he shouldn’t be AD.
His critics, and they are legion, will point to a plethora of reasons why Pederson was fired. Chief among them would be his urging of Nordenberg and other university leaders to dismantle ramshackle Pitt Stadium and move the football team from Oakland to the North Shore for its games and to the South Side for its headquarters and practices and where it would share facilities with the Steelers.
It is unlikely that entered into Gallagher’s thinking since both the football program and the basketball program, which bloomed at the Petersen Events Center where Pitt Stadium once stood, have grown stronger since the moves.
It was Pederson’s refusal or inability to build support for himself that was his undoing. He was a problem solver -- not a backslapper, not warm and cuddly. And maybe he didn’t have to be with Nordenberg behind him. But with Nordenberg gone, Pederson’s support was stripped. He had few allies.
If there was a specific decision that cost Pederson his job, it was the one he made in December 2010, when he fired football coach Dave Wannstedt. In Wannstedt’s final three years, Pitt won 27 games, more than it had in such a span since the early 1980s.
Pederson thought Pitt could do better. So did many fans who clamored for Wannstedt’s firing. But Pederson had no sound plan to replace Wannstedt. His choice was Michael Haywood, a relative unknown with an ordinary resume. Pederson had made a similar move once before when he hired unknown Ben Howland as basketball coach. Maybe he thought Haywood would be another Howland, who helped elevate Pitt to national prominence.
We’ll never know. Haywood was arrested on a domestic violence charge -- he grabbed his girl friend’s arm -- and was fired by Nordenberg less than a month on the job. Pitt next hired Todd Graham, who left after one season for Arizona State. Next was Chryst, who lasted three years. The process left two recruiting classes were badly damaged and now, with Chryst leaving, a third could be disrupted.
After Wannstedt was fired and the Haywood hiring fell apart, alumni resentment reached new levels and no one was more vocal than all-time great offensive tackle Bill Fralic.
''This is all about Steve Pederson trying to make a mark, and he’s made a black eye,’’ said Fralic in early 2011. ''I would take a long, hard look at how we came to make this decision. I think there’s a lot of of people who have supported that program who are very disillusioned. I just don’t know how we could be so wrong.’’
That’s when it really began to turn against Pederson. Wannstedt, a Pitt football letterman and former assistant coach, was a lifer. Had Pederson stuck with him, Pitt football would be a better place today. So would Pederson.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.