A Canonsburg couple who built an upscale weekend home that borders Seven Springs Resort is suing the resort and Salt Lick Township to obtain year-round access to the eastern end of Neals Run Road, a one-lane dirt and gravel township road that is closed during the winter because it cuts across the middle of the resort’s North Face slopes and trails.
Gabriel and Gloria Hudock use the western end of Neals Run that begins at Indian Head Road and climbs 3 miles to their home. They pay $2,500 a year to it clear of snow. I drove it last week. It’s not in good shape. If the Hudocks win their lawsuit, it would be a Pyrrhic victory. They could no longer use the adjacent Lost Girl beginner trail that provides easy ski-out, ski-in access to the house they built in 2009 and once listed for $1,800,000. And they, along with everyone else, no longer would be able to use any of the four North Face chairlifts and terrain that provides the resort’s best skiing and snowboarding.
Seven Springs has 280 acres of snow-sliding terrain, 205 of which are on the North Face.
The Hudocks asked Fayette County’s Common Pleas Court for a preliminary injunction Nov. 3 to keep Neals Run Road open during the winter. An 18-page brief filed Nov. 9 on behalf of the resort opposed the injunction request, accused the Hudocks of not acting in good faith and asked for legal fees and costs.
The resort said “hundreds of thousands” of skiers and snowboarders, including approximately 13,000 season passholders, would be harmed if an injunction was granted. It said it had 185,000 skier/snowboarder visits last season. The resort also said an injunction would result in the loss of hundreds of jobs — the resort employs 490 year-round, a total of 1,533 last winter — and almost $4 million in school, state, county and local municipal taxes.
On Nov. 13, Judge Nancy D. Vernon denied the couple’s request.
“The court finds that [the Hudocks have] failed to meet [their] burden of proof of immediate and irreparable harm in light of the fact that [they have] owned the property for a period of seven years under the same conditions in regard to Neals Run Road."
Those conditions include a more than 40-year agreement between the resort and the township in which the resort pays the township an annual fee based on a formula tied to the cost of living index and the township closes the road during the winter. The annual fees now total $497,248.
Attorney Kirk B. Burkley, who represents the Hudocks, said the couple negotiated with the resort for eight months and thought they had an agreement to extend Neals Run Road through their property to the resort’s Southwind development.
Burkley said the proposed agreement required the resort to grant an easement through its property, but the resort declined to do so. The resort said in its brief that it needed more time to work out all the details.
Although the Hudock’s injunction request was denied, Burkley said the lawsuit the couple filed against the resort and township is still active. A negotiated settlement appears to the best way to resolve this dispute.
Open house
The Westmoreland Ski Club will have an open house for potential members from 2-5 p.m. Sunday at its lodge at 2094 County Line Road, 3 miles from Seven Springs. Memberships are $30 for singles and $50 for families. Overnight stays cost $20 per night. Bring your own linens and towels. Information: www.westmorelandskiclub.com.
Larry Walsh writes about recreational snow sports for the Post-Gazette.


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.