T.J. Watt should be NFL Defensive Player of the Year for the second time. He led the league in sacks for the third time in four seasons. He was named first-team All-Pro for the fourth time. Teammates voted him their MVP for the fourth time.
Watt could retire tomorrow and make plans for enshrinement in the Pro Football Hall of Fame.
He is a lock.
It has been an amazing career.
But there is one massive hole on Watt’s resume: His Steelers haven’t won a playoff game, let alone a Super Bowl.
I’m wondering if Watt ever will win one.
Read More
Mike Tomlin spoke optimistically about the Steelers’ future in his season-ending press briefing on Thursday. I don’t believe they are even close to being a legitimate Super Bowl contender. They don’t have a quarterback, for one significant thing. They have holes at wide receiver, in the secondary and on the defensive line, for another.
For those reasons, I don’t think it would be absurd to consider trading Watt.
Really.
I know the Steelers are 70-33-2 when Watt starts, 1-11 when he doesn’t.
But the idea of trading Watt isn’t sacrilegious unless the Steelers really are knocking on the door of greatness.
I repeat: They are not.
Watt is going to be 30 on Oct. 11. He was able to play at a Superman level in all 17 regular-season games this season but had to miss the playoff loss in Buffalo on Monday because of a knee injury. It is fair to wonder how long he will be able to play at that same high level.
You might have heard that getting old in sports — OK, in life in general — stinks.
Then, there is the return Watt could bring the Steelers in a trade. A No. 1 draft choice would be a must, maybe even two No. 1s. Certainly, a No. 1 pick and another high choice would be required in any deal.
That would be a heck of a start for the retooling that the Steelers need.
I look at Watt this way, paraphrasing something long-ago Pirates general manager Branch Rickey said about his future Hall of Fame slugger Ralph Kiner:
“We’re not winning postseason games with you, T.J. We can lose ’em without you.”
It’s a shame the Steelers haven’t been good enough to take advantage of Watt’s greatness. Tomlin talked about his one regret in coaching being that he couldn’t help Maurkice Pouncey become a world champion “because he is one.” I feel the same way about Watt and Cam Heyward. They deserve to be remembered as all-time great Steelers but won’t be with so little postseason success, none in Watt’s case.
Even before this season, at training camp at Saint Vincent College, Watt talked about the importance of ending the team’s playoff “drought.”
“I said I wanted to win a playoff game,” Watt said on Tuesday. “It’s extremely frustrating. It sucks. It’s no fun.”
Tomlin said Watt would have been ready for a playoff game in Baltimore this weekend had the Steelers advanced. Would they have beaten the Bills if Watt had played? My opinion is no, but we’ll never know for sure.
“We weren’t expecting to be in this situation,” Watt said. “No flights were booked in case we lost. You’re always thinking you’re going to win. ...
“If I knew [a solution], we wouldn’t be having this conversation. We’ve got to take a long, hard look at this and figure it out because we keep having the same conversation every year. There’s going to be plenty of things we need to fix.”
It doesn’t appear Watt will win the Defensive Player of the Year award despite having better statistics than the presumptive winner, Cleveland’s Myles Garrett, and the other top candidates, Dallas’ Micah Parsons and Las Vegas’ Maxx Crosby. Watt did win the award in 2021 when he tied the NFL sacks record with 22½. He was second in the voting in 2020 and third in 2019.
Another top-three finish won’t do much to ease Watt’s pain from another early end to the Steelers’ season.
I have no doubt he would trade all his hardware for a Super Bowl ring.
I just don’t think he is going to get that ring with the Steelers.
Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com and Twitter@RonCookPG. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Joe” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.