There are pros and cons to every trade in sports.

So it is with the Steelers’ deal Tuesday that sent Chase Claypool to the Chicago Bears for a second-round draft choice.

I see four pros and one significant con:

CON

Advertise with us

The Steelers are trying to develop rookie Kenny Pickett as their franchise quarterback. Taking one of his top targets away from him makes that job harder. The trade is an indication the Steelers already are thinking about next season more than this season. Lesser receivers Miles Boykin and Steven Sims are the candidates to replace Claypool. It’s a shame Calvin Austin III — a shining star during the early part of training camp — will miss the season because of a foot injury. But he should be a big help next season.

PRO

Claypool has underachieved since his rookie year, 2020, when he looked as if he might be one of the best wide receivers out of that draft class even though he was the 11th receiver taken. Remember his seven-catch, 110-yard, three-receiving touchdown, one-rushing touchdown game against the Philadelphia Eagles? Claypool hasn’t come close to matching that performance. He has had a few good moments this season, making three late critical catches from Mitch Trubisky against Tampa Bay in that rarest of rarities, a Steelers win, and running like Earl Campbell after a couple of catches Sunday in Philadelphia. He even threw — that’s right, threw — the pass that resulted in the only touchdown against the Eagles, a 1-yard toss to Derek Watt.

But, for the most part, Claypool’s production hasn’t lined up with his impressive athleticism.

Claypool has the skills to become a star, but he has immaturity issues. We saw it last season when he suggested music at practice to cure the Steelers’ woes after a 41-10 loss at Cincinnati, and when he took up valuable time by signaling first down during a late two-minute drive at Minnesota. He really does need to grow up. That’s why it was laughable before the season when he proclaimed to be a “top-three receiver” and predicted he would have a 1,300-yard, 10-touchdown season. He has 311 receiving yards and one touchdown after eight games.

Advertise with us

PRO

The Steelers no longer have to worry about paying Claypool after this season. They gave Diontae Johnson a two-year, $36.71 million contract extension in August that runs through the 2024 season after his third year in the NFL. Historically, the Steelers pay big money to just one receiver at a time. They chose Hines Ward over Plaxico Burress. More recently, they chose Mike Wallace over Antonio Brown and got lucky when Brown accepted the offer Wallace turned down. Brown became the best receiver in franchise history.

PRO

Rookie George Pickens is the same type of big, tall receiver that Claypool is. Neither is a skedaddler — to use a Mike Tomlin word — the way Johnson is. But Pickens is going to be much better than Claypool. There seems to be little doubt the Steelers will find a way to lock him up after the 2024 season when Johnson’s contract will be expiring.

PRO

Advertise with us

The Steelers have been successful finding receivers in the draft. Pickens, Claypool and JuJu Smith-Schuster were taken in the second round. Johnson was a third-round selection, Austin a fourth-rounder. And the steal of steals, Brown, came in the sixth round.

All things considered, I like the deal.

I like it a lot better now than when it was originally reported.

Albert Breer, senior NFL reporter for The MMQB, tweeted the trade was for the 2023 second-round pick that the Bears acquired Monday from the Baltimore Ravens for linebacker Roquan Smith. Ian Rapoport of the NFL Network quickly corrected the compensation, tweeting the Bears are sending their original second-round pick to the Steelers.

That is a huge difference.

Advertise with us

The Bears are 3-5 and probably will end up with a top-10 choice in each round of the draft. The Ravens are the third-betting choice to make the Super Bowl out of the AFC, which means they likely will be picking in the 25-30 range.

I repeat:

That is a huge difference.

Enough to make me really like the trade.

Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com and Twitter@RonCookPG. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Joe” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.