So what do you think of the Pirates’ record heading into June? They were 20-27 going into the late game Tuesday night against the Los Angeles Dodgers. Only four teams in the National League were worse. Same Old Bucs, right? Lousy.

I look at it a little differently.

I think the Pirates’ record is amazing.

If you had told me during spring training that the team’s two best offensive players and its purported best starting pitcher would give them so little in the first two months of the season, I would have predicted 10-37.

Advertise with us

I’m talking about Bryan Reynolds, Ke’Bryan Hayes and Mitch Keller.

All have been major disappointments.

Start with Reynolds, the closest thing the Pirates have to a face of the franchise. It was nice he hit a home run in their win against the Dodgers on Monday night — his second in four games — but his highlights have been few and far between this season. His numbers are comparable to his miserable 2020 season and don’t even remotely resemble his stats from 2021, which led to the Pirates signing him to a two-year, $13.5 million contract in April.

Reynolds was hitting .212 with a .693 OPS. He had struck out 25% of the time during his 165 at-bats. He had seven home runs but a ridiculously low 11 RBIs. Speaking of ridiculously low, he was batting .063 — 2 for 32 — with runners in scoring position.

Hayes, who signed an eight-year, $70 million contract in April with a club option for a ninth year, has hit for a much better average than Reynolds, but he hasn’t been nearly good enough, either. He picked a great time for his first home run of the season, beating the San Diego Padres with a three-run shot in the ninth inning Saturday night. But, I repeat, it was his first and only home run. Think about that. He plays third base — supposedly a power position — and has just one home run.

Advertise with us

I’m not as troubled by Hayes’ defense, although that has been pretty bad, as well. His seven errors were tied for the most by a National League third baseman. The guess here is that is something of a fluke. I’ve seen the man play defense. He’s really good.

Keller is not good. At least he hasn’t been good in his first three-plus seasons in the big leagues. He hasn’t even been close to good.

We heard all spring about how Keller was a different pitcher, how his velocity had picked up, how he was challenging hitters. But that didn’t carry over into the season. Keller was 0-5 as a starter with a 6.61 earned-run average before being demoted to the bullpen on May 18 for a couple of outings. He isn’t the only reason Pirates starters had just two wins through Monday night’s games, but he is the biggest. He was 8-22 in his 46 career starts before Derek Shelton went back to him as a starter against the Dodgers on Tuesday night.

Keller has looked a lot like Tyler Glasnow, another highly regarded prospect who turned to be an underachiever with the Pirates before finding success with the Tampa Bay Rays. The Pirates are in real trouble — short term and long term — if Keller doesn’t find his game even though Shelton said it’s “not totally about Mitch Keller.”

I will say it again:

Advertise with us

I can’t believe the Pirates had won 20 games before Tuesday night.

Shelton has praised his team repeatedly for how hard it plays and how it never gives in despite the circumstances of a game. He mentioned the ninth-inning comeback against the Dodgers on Monday night and the ninth-inning comeback against the Padres on Saturday night. The Dodgers and Padres are pennant contenders.

Those were impressive wins.

But how many more wins could there be?

How many more should there be?

Advertise with us

Not surprisingly, Shelton looked for positives about Reynolds, Hayes and Keller.

“I think we’re closer to finding the swing that we all want to see and Bryan wants to see,” Shelton said Tuesday on his weekly radio show on 93.7 The Fan. “Early on, he really struggled with runners in scoring position. But in terms of his actual swing, I think he’s closer to finding it. I think we’re seeing signs of it in stretches. We still need to be more consistent.”

Shelton said he isn’t concerned about Hayes’ lack of power. He pointed out Hayes had three hits against the Dodgers on Monday night. Hayes was 7-for-13 in the three games before Tuesday night to push his average back to .294 and his OPS to .765 after a rough May.

“He continues to take good swings,” Shelton said. “As long as he continues to have really good at-bats and good swings, the power stuff will come.”

Shelton said Keller handled the move to the bullpen “great” but was glad to get another start even against a team as powerful as the Dodgers.

Advertise with us

“He’s in a good frame of mind,” Shelton said. “I think the thought process is to stay in the attack mode and go right at them. This is a good lineup we’re facing. That’s a really obvious statement. But it’s one you have to attack because they do not swing at balls. They are very selective, very patient. For Mitch to be successful, he has to make sure he goes after guys.”

Shelton has been telling Keller that same thing since he took over as his manager.

We’ll see if Keller ever gets the message.

I’m thinking we’ll see the Pirates as a much better team with a much better record if Keller does.

Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com and Twitter@RonCookPG. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Joe” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m.