I’m going to be optimistic here today about the Steelers’ chances in Kansas City on Sunday night.

I’m going to do it by going back to the 2005 season.

That was the year the Steelers had to win their final four regular season games just to make the AFC playoff field as the lowest seed. It was the year they became the first team in NFL history to win three road playoff games and the Super Bowl. It was the year they were motivated to send out their Hall of Fame-bound teammate as a winner. It was the year they had to beat a playoff opponent that had smashed them definitively a few weeks earlier on the same field, an opponent that was led by a legendary quarterback.

Do you see any potential similarities between that 2005 team and the 2021 Steelers?

Advertise with us

These Steelers had to beat AFC No. 1 seed Tennessee and division rivals Cleveland and Baltimore in their final four regular season games just to make the playoffs as the seventh and final AFC seed. “I like where we’re at,” Mike Tomlin said last week, fully realizing his team has to win three road games to get to Super Bowl LVI.

These Steelers are led by Ben Roethlisberger, who will retire after the season and be immortalized in Canton five years later. In 2005, he was a second-year quarterback who promised team leader Jerome Bettis that the team would get him a Super Bowl win before Bettis parked the bus for good. Now, it is Roethlisberger’s younger teammates who want to keep extending his final season. “Those are our intentions, certainly,” Tomlin said.

These Steelers will face the Chiefs, who beat them almost beyond recognition, 36-10, on Dec. 26. The Chiefs scored on their first four possessions to take a 23-0 lead at halftime, eventually stretching it to 36-3. The Steelers had three “catastrophic” — Tomlin’s word — turnovers. CBS announcer Jim Nantz ridiculed the Steelers when the score was 30-0, saying they “are sleepwalking through this thing. They’re getting beat every single play. Physically, emotionally, it’s just not there.”

Let me provide a little hope for the rematch Sunday night.

In 2005, the Indianapolis Colts beat the Steelers 26-7 on a Monday night in Indianapolis, seven weeks before they met again in the playoffs. Hall of Famer Peyton Manning threw an 80-yard touchdown pass to Hall of Famer Marvin Harrison on the Colts’ first play. Hall of Famer Edgerrin James ran for 124 yards, the first rusher to gain 100 yards against the Steelers in 23 games. The Colts defense sacked Roethlisberger three times, intercepted him twice and held his offense to 197 yards.

Advertise with us

“We’ll see those guys again,” Steelers defensive end Kimo von Oelhoffen said after that game. “I’m already looking forward to it. We’re all looking forward to it.”

The Steelers won that playoff game in the RCA Dome, 21-18, despite being 8½-point underdogs. Roethlisberger led them on a 10-play, 84-yard scoring drive to open the game and saved it late by tackling cornerback Nick Harper after Harper recovered a Bettis fumble and appeared headed to a game-winning touchdown. Colts kicker Mike Vanderjagt missed wide right on what would have been a tying 46-yard field goal at the end. The Steelers sacked Manning five times, James Farrior getting 2 ½. They went on to beat Denver in the AFC championship game and Seattle in Super Bowl XL.

Roethlisberger, for one, thought the championship was meant to be for Hall of Famer Bettis.

“Once in a blue moon, Jerome fumbles,” he said. “Once in a blue moon, I make a tackle. They just happened to be in the same game.”

A repeat upset win Sunday night seems unlikely — the Steelers are the biggest underdogs in NFL wild card history at 12½ points — but we can dream, right?

Advertise with us

Maybe a healthy Pat Freiermuth will help. He missed that first Chiefs game because of a concussion, although Kansas City’s All-Pro tight end Travis Kelce also missed the game because of COVID-19.

Certainly, a healthy T.J. Watt will help. He played just 38 of 69 snaps in the first Chiefs game because of cracked ribs and had one tackle. Don’t we know that Watt is an absolute game-breaker? His NFL-record 22 ½ sacks this season are the proof.

Watt and the Steelers defense are going to have to get after Patrick Mahomes the way the 2005 defense did with Manning. Mahomes was 23 of 30 for 258 yards, three touchdowns and no interceptions in that first game against the Steelers this season. You don’t want to know his stats in two career games against the Steelers: 46 of 58 for 584 yards, nine touchdowns and no interceptions with a 148.2 passer rating. We’re talking Tom Brady-like talent and production.

Roethlisberger sarcastically gave the Steelers little-to-no chance of winning Sunday night when he met the media last week. “We probably aren’t supposed to be here. ... We’re not as good as that team [in 2005].”

I think that’s what they call reverse psychology.

Advertise with us

But at least one player went von Oelhoffen last week. “I like being in this situation,” Diontae Johnson said. “People are expecting us to go out there and have another tough loss like that. That’s what they expect. They don’t expect us to come back with a better plan. ...

“Once we win, don’t try to hop back on the bandwagon.”

Are you feeling at least a little better about the Steelers’ chances?

Let me try one more thing:

The Chiefs are 0-3 this season against Baltimore and division champs Tennessee and Buffalo. The Steelers went 4-0 against those teams.

Advertise with us

Hey, I took my best shot.

Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com and Twitter@RonCookPG. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Joe” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.