Consecutive plays in the 16-10 loss to the New York Jets Dec. 22 might not have defined the Steelers season, but they certainly went a long way toward explaining why the team finished 8-8 and missed the playoffs for the second consecutive season.

On the first play, late in the third quarter, Maurkice Pouncey was forced to leave with a left knee injury and was done for the season. It was another tough loss for the offense. Pouncey isn’t just an eight-time Pro Bowl center, he is, in Mike Tomlin’s words, the team’s “unquestioned leader.”

On the second play, Pouncey’s replacement, B.J. Finney, snapped the ball to Mason Rudolph and accidentally tripped Rudolph as he was backpedaling to hand off to Benny Snell Jr. Rudolph, who was playing well in relief of Duck Hodges, landed hard on his left shoulder and was squashed like a bug by cornerback Maurice Canady. It was a freakish injury. Rudolph was done for the season at the end of the series.

It was that kind of year.

Advertise with us

I’m guessing you are disappointed, maybe even angry, that the Steelers collapsed for the second season in a row. They were 8-5 after their 23-17 win Dec. 8 at Arizona and headed toward the playoffs. Even after their 17-10 home loss to Buffalo the next week, they needed only to win their final two games to qualify. But that loss to the Jets was a killer. It made the 28-10 road loss to a bunch of the Baltimore Ravens reserves Sunday irrelevant.

But this collapse wasn’t like the one last season when the Steelers were basically healthy and went 2-4 down the stretch with losses to Denver and Oakland. I can’t be mad at this season’s team. That would be unfair to the overmatched Hodges and his young, inexperienced running backs and wide receivers who clearly weren’t ready for a playoff push. All things considered, an 8-8 record seems just about right. Staying in playoff contention until the final week was an unexpected bonus that happened only because the defense was surprisingly good.

The season was virtually lost at halftime of the second game, a 28-26 home loss to Seattle. That’s when Ben Roethlisberger left with a throwing elbow injury that required surgery. Rudolph struggled as his replacement and eventually was replaced by Hodges, who, to his credit, somehow went 3-3 as the starting quarterback. Unfortunately for the team, he was 0-3 in the final three games, throwing six interceptions and then losing a critical fumble against the Ravens.

“We’ve ridden a really good helicopter for a long, long time,” Ramon Foster said of Roethlisberger after the Jets game. “Now we all see the significance of that position.”

“You don’t really appreciate something until it’s gone and he’s not there every single day throwing touchdown passes,” Pouncey said. “Don’t get me wrong. I’m not taking anything away from the other quarterbacks. It’s just that Ben was that comfort blanket for all of us. He always seemed to make things right. Just having him gone you have a whole new appreciation of what someone like that brings to the game. When you’re around that type of special player, you have to cherish him and enjoy every moment and realize this is why things have been so good.”

Advertise with us

“People that complain about our guy, whenever he’s in, stop,” Foster added about Roethlisberger. “We realize what it is now, OK?”

Without Roethlisberger, the Steelers offense was impotent. It ranked 30th overall in the NFL and was 29th in rushing and 31st in passing. It scored just one touchdown in eight of the final nine games.

“You hate being a part of a unit like that,” David DeCastro said. “We’re not even doing the bare minimum.”

Tomlin had counted on Roethlisberger when he talked of big expectations before the season. He called the departures of Le’Veon Bell and Antonio Brown a “cleansing” and predicted the team would be just fine because it still had a couple of Pro Bowlers in James Conner and JuJu Smith-Schuster.

But Conner always seemed to be hurt, per usual for him. He missed six games and parts of three others. That left Snell, a rookie, to do much of the heavy lifting.

Advertise with us

Smith-Schuster also battled injuries much of the season and missed four games. When he did play, he wasn’t effective, forcing rookie Diontae Johnson to be the team’s top receiver. Whether it was not having Roethlisberger throw him the ball or not having Brown opposite him, Smith-Schuster had a rotten year. He might have been the team’s biggest offensive underachiever if it wasn’t for Vance McDonald.

The Steelers shouldn’t give Conner or Smith-Schuster a contract extension before they play out the final year of their rookie deals next season. It’s too hard to count on them.

“There’s been a lot of disappointments this season,” Tomlin said Sunday night of the Steelers injuries and poor performances, which left his team out of the playoffs again and assured it will remain stuck on three postseason wins since 2010.

The Steelers defense wasn’t quite good enough to compensate for the offense’s many flaws and inadequacies. It’s a shame because T.J. Watt emerged as a Defensive Player of the Year candidate, Bud Dupree put himself in position to make millions as a free agent, Minkah Fitzpatrick justified giving up a No. 1 pick to get him and Cam Heyward was virtually unblockable. The defense finally broke under the strain of carrying the offense all season against the Ravens.

Now, all eyes turn to Roethlisberger.

Advertise with us

Roethlisberger refuted a national report last week that there were serious questions he will be able to return in 2020. He tweeted on Christmas Day that he is “working hard and am more determined than ever to come back stronger and better than ever next year!” A week earlier, he had told me he is “ahead of schedule” with his rehab.

The Steelers are counting on Roethlisberger again. They have no choice but to count on him.

“The hourglass is getting smaller and smaller for a lot of guys,” Heyward said.

More than anything, the team needs its franchise quarterback.

Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette and Twitter@RonCookPG. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Joe” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.