Penguins GM Jim Rutherford elected into the Hockey Hall of Fame
For most owners, managers, coaches and athletes in any sport, election to their Hall of Fame is the final step in a long, glorious journey to the top of their profession.
No one deserved his Hall call more than Rutherford, but he will tell you his work is hardly finished.
My thoughts about how Rutherford is facing his greatest challenge with the Penguins can wait for a few moments. It’s important here to reflect on his work with the team since he was hired as general manager on June 6, 2014. I am embarrassed to admit I remember that day as if it were yesterday.
“Rutherford was pushed aside in Carolina after the Hurricanes failed to make the postseason in each of the past five seasons,” I wrote. “He is 65, deep into the back nine of his long NHL career. This is the Penguins’ idea of a step up? Settling for a discard from one of the league’s worst hockey clubs? It makes no sense.”
I don’t know that I’ve ever been so happy to be so wrong.
Read More
Most people remember how Rutherford’s deals for Phil Kessel, Patric Hornqvist, Carl Hagelin, Nick Bonino and Trevor Daley pushed the Penguins over the top, all the way to the Stanley Cup in 2016 and 2017. I remember how he wasn’t afraid to admit his mistakes and correct them. He put aside his ego and fired Mike Johnston as his coach in December 2015, probably realizing that he, too, would be fired if his next choice, Mike Sullivan, didn’t work out.
Well, it worked out.
“You know you’re going to make mistakes,” Rutherford told the Post-Gazette’s Jason Mackey last year. “But if you don’t do anything at all, you’re going to let some good chances go by, which becomes a bigger mistake. You have to have the nerve to take steps and see where it goes.”
Can we agree Rutherford has some nerve, as well as his three Cups, including the one he generally managed in Carolina in 2006?
Rutherford’s success with the Hurricanes is his greatest work. Raleigh, N.C., isn’t exactly a hockey hotbed. The Penguins team he took over had won the Cup five years earlier. It also had Sidney Crosby, Evgeni Malkin and Kris Letang.
Rutherford, 70 now and still apparently far from putting out on 18, wants a fourth Cup, more than anything. Getting it with these Penguins, who were swept by the New York Islanders in the first round of the playoffs this spring and eliminated by the Washington Capitals in the second round in 2018, will not be easy.
The NHL draft weekend came and went without the Penguins doing anything to help their current team. They figure to be just as quiet in NHL free agency, which starts Monday, because Rutherford doesn’t have the salary-cap room to sign a big player. He is thinking about the cap beyond this season and has said he wants to sign Matt Murray and Justin Schultz to new deals.
Those of us who wanted to see the Penguins make significant changes are waiting patiently.
Trading Olli Maatta for Dominik Kahun doesn’t count, right?
I know the new season doesn’t start until Oct. 3. I also know Rutherford has said there will be a few more changes before training camp. But will those changes be enough to solve what Rutherford admitted was a chemistry issue on the team?
Am I the only one who has doubts?
It’s troubling that Rutherford is saying — at least publicly — that everything will be OK with the team virtually as it is with minor changes.
“We have good enough players to win,” Rutherford told Mackey at the draft.
“We have to be a little careful when we look at this team. Is it on the downside or is it still a good team? I don’t see any players that are on the downside.”
That’s a much different stance from the one Rutherford took after the sweep by the Islanders. He was frustrated — even angry — when he said the Penguins weren’t as determined as the Islanders and that maybe his players were too content with winning the Cup in 2016 and 2017. He even suggested he and Sullivan had lost the team’s room.
I’m not so sure the Penguins aren’t on the downside.
How much does Hornqvist have left? He is 32 with a $5.3 million cap hit through the 2022-23 season. He has a long history of concussions and was invisible for much of last season.
How about Malkin? He turns 33 next month and had the worst season of his career. Maybe it was just a blip and he will be better than ever next season. Or maybe not.
Letang is 32 and also has had his share of injuries. He had a terrific regular season but a miserable playoffs. The Penguins played their best hockey when he was hurt in March and also won the Cup without him in 2017. It’s hard to imagine the team keeping both him and Schultz long term.
Kessel will be 32 in October and has a lot of mileage after playing in 774 consecutive games, 846 if you count the postseason. The Penguins tried to trade him to Minnesota for winger Jason Zucker in May as a part of their plan to “retool” — Rutherford’s word — but Kessel vetoed the deal, a right he had contractually.
“Obviously, it’s frustrating for the team when you feel that the trade we were going to make was the right thing for the Penguins,” Rutherford said. “But, at the same time, Phil didn’t do anything wrong.”
Rutherford said Kessel will be welcomed back, if necessary. He also said it’s “highly unlikely” Letang or Malkin will be traded despite allowing speculation to swirl around the two players the entire offseason. “They’ve been great players. They still are. They’re the kind of guys you win championships with.”
Maybe Rutherford found out during draft weekend that it’s more difficult than he thought to move big players with big contracts. Or maybe he is posturing, laying low now but ready to make a significant move later in the summer. The guess here is Kessel still will be traded. I just don’t see how it would work bringing him back.
There’s no way Rutherford keeps the Penguins virtually intact. If he does, the team will be doomed to another early playoff exit. That’s if it even makes the playoffs for a 14th consecutive season in what will be a significantly improved Metropolitan Division.
Rutherford is too smart for that.
He’s not a Hall of Famer for nothing, you know?
Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com and Twitter@RonCookPG. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Joe” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.