Two weeks ago, there was nothing more intriguing in Pittsburgh sports than Mike Tomlin’s future with the Steelers. He is due for a contract extension this summer, but that no longer seems like a sure thing. Not after one of the worst collapses in franchise history last season. Not after the Mr. Big Chest nightmare.
But the drama surrounding Tomlin’s coaching future might be trumped by what could happen to Mike Sullivan. The Penguins went out quietly in four games against the New York Islanders last week, an embarrassing first-round playoff ending for a team that won the second of consecutive Stanley Cups under Sullivan just two years ago. There is reason to believe at least a few star players – Evgeni Malkin, Kris Letang and Phil Kessel – have tuned out their coach if not openly defied him. Sullivan has one year left on his contract. There is no reason to think his job is in immediate jeopardy, but there also is no guarantee he will get an extension before next season.
And if the Penguins get off to a slow start in 2019-20?
I don’t want to think about the possibilities.
All of this is troubling to me because I think Sullivan is one of the top coaches in the NHL. I think he’s the best, actually.
But I know how it is with NHL coaches. No pro sports league treats its coaches with less respect than the NHL. Two-time Cup-winning coach Darryl Sutter was fired by the Los Angeles Kings after the 2016-17 season, just three years after his latest championship. Three-time Cup-winning coach Joel Quenneville was fired by the Chicago Blackhawks in November, three years and change after his latest title.
Read More
I would be foolish and naïve to think it couldn’t happen to Sullivan.
I hope Penguins management does the right thing by giving Sullivan an extension, but I am not holding my breath. The franchise might have the worst track record in sports when it comes to coaches. It has had 22 since its inception in 1967. It took until the 20th – Dan Bylsma – for one to start and finish four consecutive seasons. I guess I shouldn’t be surprised. Mario Lemieux is a living legend and has done more wondrous things for our city than just about anyone, but I’m convinced he never has found a coach he likes or respects. That includes Scotty Bowman, arguably the best coach of all time in any sport. Bowman won five Cups before he replaced the late Bob Johnson with the Penguins after the 1990-91 season and won a Cup with them in 1991-92. He was chased away after the team’s second-round flameout against the Islanders in 1992-93 and won three more Cups with the Detroit Red Wings.
Compare the Penguins’ approach with coaches to the Steelers’ approach. The Steelers have had just three coaches since 1969.
Is that jarring or what?
In many ways, Sullivan is blessed to be the Penguins’ coach. He will tell you that. He has one of the greatest players of all time, Sidney Crosby, and another generational talent in Malkin. He has a terrific goal scorer in Kessel and a wonderfully skilled defenseman in Letang.
A coach couldn’t ask for more, right?
Wrong.
Sullivan also is cursed to be the Penguins coach. Each of his stars has a sizable ego that often is hard to manage. When Sullivan took over for the fired Mike Johnston in December 2015, the team was a mess. The stars were vulnerable, looking for direction and structure at a time when they were earning a reputation – fairly or otherwise – as coach killers.
But then the Penguins won the two Cups. The stars no longer are vulnerable. It is as if they think they are invincible and can play any way they want. Sullivan wants to play a less high-risk game, but Malkin and Letang are high-risk players and have no apparent plans to change. Letang said as much after the season. Sullivan wants good practice habits from his players, but Kessel doesn’t care much for practice. Think Allen Iverson. It’s one reason Kessel drives all of his coaches crazy.
It’s likely Kessel will be traded. The Penguins have looked into moving him after each of the previous two seasons but couldn’t find a taker or suitable compensation. For the first time, Letang doesn’t appear to be untouchable. That’s not so much because of his lousy series against the Islanders but more because of his flippant response to how he played. I still expect him to be back next season. Malkin isn’t going anywhere.
Sullivan isn’t naïve. He knows what he signed on for when he became a hockey coach. He also knows the No. 1 rule of his profession: You can’t fire all of the players, but you certainly can fire the coach.
Sullivan’s ability to reconnect with his stars will determine how long he coaches the Penguins.
I hope it is a very long time.
Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com and Twitter @RonCookPG. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Joe” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.