Welcome to Joe Starkey’s mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life, Lonnie Smith and everything in between. If you want to ask Joe a question, tweet him @JoeStarkey1 or email him at jstarkey@post-gazette.com. On to the questions …

Armand Posipanka, @Posipanka: Have Sid and Geno won all the Cups they’re going to?

Starkey: The odds of them winning even one more aren’t great, Armand. Sid turns 32 in August, Geno 33 in July. Superstars don’t usually win Cups as they advance into their 30s. Mario Lemieux and Wayne Gretzky, for example, won their last Cups at age 27.

It is a young man’s game, my friend, and always has been.

Advertise with us

I went back and looked at the 1982-83 New York Islanders the other day — they seemed ancient at the time, battling their way to a fourth straight Cup — and was stunned to learn that most of their better players were not yet 30. Mike Bossy and Bryan Trottier were 26! Denis Potvin was 29. Clark Gilles was 28. They would never win again, at least not together. (Trottier would come here and win a few as a role player.)

Patrick Kane and Jonathan Toews were 26 when the Chicago Blackhawks won their third Cup in six years. Will they ever win again?

On the other hand, the Washington Capitals won it all last season with a bunch of significant 30-somethings (Alex Ovechkin was 32, Nicklas Backstrom 30, T.J. Oshie 31, etc.), so it can be done. Geno was 30 when the Penguins won it in 2017. And it’s not like these guys are decrepit. Just last season, Malkin had 98 points. Just this season, Sid had 100 and played a superb all-around game.

The key, moving forward, is how the Penguins build around those two. Having younger talent such as Jake Guentzel (24), Jared McCann (22) and Matt Murray (24) sure helps.

To answer your question specifically, I’m going to say the Sid-Geno Penguins win one more Cup. Can’t tell you precisely when — but it better be soon.

Advertise with us

Dutch Van Loon, @DutchIsClutch: Which Pittsburgh coach is the last man standing? Mike Tomlin, Mike Sullivan or Clint Hurdle?

Starkey: What a question! Let’s look at each situation individually:

• Tomlin. The big question here is, will he get his customary extension with two years left on his deal? If not, this will be a prove-it season for Tomlin — and he could be gone no matter how it goes. A bad season might mean the Steelers move on. A great season might mean Tomlin moves on.

On the other hand, it’s the Steelers. I would expect an extension this summer.

• Hurdle. Lots of security here, as Hurdle is signed through the 2021 season — and you know Bob Nutting won’t be paying somebody to not work. Plus, Hurdle’s club is off to a good start this season and is suddenly rife with promise for the near future. My guess is Hurdle sees that contract through.

Advertise with us

• Sullivan. He has won two championships in the past four years but has just one year left on his deal and wasn’t able to get through to his team for much of this season. Notably in the playoffs. If Sullivan deserved credit when he got here for getting his stars to buy in — and he surely did — then he must share a big part of the blame when they go astray. And I’m mostly talking about 71 and 58 there.

I’ve often said Sullivan is the best coach in the NHL. This year’s ending probably knocked him down a peg or two, but he’s very good. The questions are how he wants his team to play and whether he can get all his best players to go with the plan. I think Sully still has staying power, but of the three men in this discussion, I think he’s gone first.

unknownlincoln, @unknownlincoln: Could you hit a golf ball across the Mon River in Palmer, PA?

Starkey: I don’t know if I could hit one across my toilet, Mr. Unknown. I hate golf, largely because I am terrible at it (but also because it takes too much time and costs too much money).

Ben Sutton, @bpatricksutton: Will JB Shuck report for catchers and pitchers next season?

Advertise with us

Starkey: Next season? If the Pirates blow another late lead, I’d have him out there Wednesday night. The man cracked 90 mph on the gun last night, didn’t he?

Mike Moore, @MichaelMooreNB: Who do you think the Steelers should pick No. 1? Would you try to move up for anyone?

Starkey: I would try to move up to take one of the Devins, yes I would, Mr. Moore. I believe in quality over quantity. And I believe the Steelers will do just that and draft Devin Bush — who got quite the recommendation the other day from ESPN analyst Louis Riddick.

“You know what, I would say this, and this is going to catch some people by surprise,” Riddick said on “The Dan Patrick Show.” “The best player in this draft — some people will say Quinnen Williams, some people are going to say Nick Bosa, I’ll tell you this — for my money, pound for pound, the best player in this draft is Devin Bush from Michigan, inside linebacker.

“If you can tell me exactly what his weakness is, I can send you a play that shows you it’s not a weakness. I played with his father in Atlanta … his father was a safety from Florida State. This kid has all of his father’s tenacity, speed, striking ability. He has better football instincts. His football smarts are off the charts.”

Advertise with us

PixBurghKid, @tuitepgh: Who wins in a game of HORSE — Larry Legend or Pistol Pete?

Starkey: With all due respect to Larry Legend, watch this:

Yeah, I’ll go with Pistol Pete.

Cuddly Porcupine, @PorpcupineCuddly: Joe, are you a wooer? Say it ain't so, Joe! #punchawooer

Starkey: No, Mr. Cuddly Porcupine, I am not a wooer. I do not like wooers. I do not like wooers a lot. They absolutely ruin games — both in-person and on television — and should have their tickets revoked forever.

Thank you, kiddies. Send me questions (tweet @JoeStarkey1 or email at jstarkey@post-gazette.com).