The Chicago Blackhawks were considered a dynasty when they won the Stanley Cup in 2010, 2013 and 2015. They lost a tough seven-game, first-round playoff series to St. Louis in 2016, were swept by Nashville in the first round in 2017 and missed the playoffs the past two seasons. They fired three-time Cup-winning coach Joel Quenneville in November.
The Los Angeles Kings won the Cup in 2012 and 2014. They haven’t won a postseason series since and missed the playoffs in three of the past five seasons, including this one. They fired two-time Cup-winning coach Darryl Sutter after the 2017 season, replaced him with John Stevens, replaced Stevens with Willie Desjardins and replaced Desjardins last week with Todd McLellan.
It makes you wonder what’s going to happen to the Penguins and Mike Sullivan, doesn’t it?
Are they headed down that same dreaded path?
The Blackhawks and Kings proved how difficult it is to stay on top and get back on top. The Penguins are learning that painful lesson. They lost a tough six-game, second-round series to Washington last spring and went out meekly in four games against the New York Islanders this week, an embarrassing result that left everyone from Jim Rutherford to Evgeni Malkin to Kris Letang questioning their effort and desire. The team should be ashamed.
You know the next question:
Read More
Is the worst yet to come for the Penguins?
The floor is yours, Jim Rutherford.
“The window’s still open,” he said. “I think it should be open for more than just one year also.”
Rutherford was quick to acknowledge the Penguins aren’t good enough “as is.” He made it clear he isn’t happy having unnamed players whom he believes are “content with where they’re at in their careers after winning a couple of Stanley Cups.” And he doesn’t like that the Islanders were the more “determined” team.
“Obviously, there will be changes in our team,” Rutherford said. “Some big decisions will have to be made.”
Tough decisions.
Perhaps the toughest of Rutherford’s career as a three-time Cup-winning, Hall of Fame-bound general manager.
It’s always hard to part with players who have done so much to help you be successful. The Blackhawks, in particular, have struggled with the loyalty thing, resulting in big contracts for players such as Patrick Kane, Jonathan Toews, Duncan Keith, Brent Seabrook and Corey Crawford that have left the team in salary-cap turmoil. Kane and Toews are signed through 2023 with an annual hit of $10.5 million. Management has not been able to provide much of a supporting cast.
It’s not hard to imagine something similar happening to the Penguins if Rutherford can’t move some of the team’s more onerous contracts. I’m not talking about untouchables Sidney Crosby ($8.7 million per year through 2025) and Malkin ($9.5 million through 2022) even though I would look into trading Malkin, who turns 33 July 31 and is coming off, by his admission, a bad year. I’m talking about Phil Kessel, Letang, Patric Hornqvist, Jack Johnson, Nick Bjugstad, Bryan Rust and Olli Maatta. All but Johnson and Bjugstad played on the Penguins’ Cup-winning teams in 2016 and 2017.
“We have a lot of good players, players that have good resumes, players that have won Stanley Cups, players that have contributed big to that,” Rutherford said. “Depending on what changes we decide to make, we have valuable assets to make some of those changes.”
I’m not so sure.
What are the Penguins going to get back for Kessel ($6.8 million through 2022), who has a reputation for wearing out his welcome with his coaches? Letang ($7.25 million through 2022), who has a history of injuries and often negates his extraordinary talent with foolish in-game decisions? Hornqvist ($5.3 million through 2023), who has had multiple concussions and wasn’t the same player this season after returning in mid-January after the most recent one? Johnson ($3.25 million through 2023), who was scratched by Sullivan for Game 1 against the Islanders after playing in all 82 games during the regular season? Bjugstad ($4.1 million through 2021), who was invisible against the Islanders? Rust ($3.5 million through 2022), who was equally invisible? Maatta ($4.08 million through 2022), who was scratched in the final three games?
I’m guessing Rutherford will trade one or two of those players merely to get rid of a bad contract for salary-cap relief. The return won’t be much, probably not nearly enough.
The Penguins didn’t clinch their postseason spot this season until the 81st game. It hardly seems like a guarantee they will make the playoffs for a 14th consecutive season next season.
I’ve written and said many times I never will count out a Crosby-led team.
I still believe that.
I just wonder if they said the same thing in Chicago about Kane and Toews and in Los Angeles about Anze Kopitar and Drew Doughty.
Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com and Twitter@RonCookPG. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Joe” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.