Loved the message.
Hated the messenger.
That was my reaction to James Harrison telling Fox Sports 1’s “Undisputed” last week that Bill Belichick is a better coach — by far — than Mike Tomlin because Belichick demands discipline and accountability from everyone in the New England Patriots organization. Harrison said Belichick’s coaching staff is more organized and on the same page than Tomlin’s staff. Harrison said Belichick doesn’t play favorites the way Tomlin does and mentioned how he saw Tom Brady running to get to a meeting out of fear he would be late.
The message is mostly spot-on.
Belichick is a better coach than Tomlin and better — by far — than any coach in the NFL. Harrison grudgingly acknowledged Tomlin still is a good coach. Recent rankings by The Sporting News had Tomlin third in the league behind Belichick and Philadelphia Eagles coach Doug Pederson. That seems about right. Tomlin has led the Steelers to double-digit wins in four consecutive seasons, although the home playoff loss to Jacksonville in January was brutal.
Belichick also is much more of a disciplinarian than Tomlin. It’s fair to say Belichick wouldn’t have tolerated some of the distractions Tomlin has faced, from Antonio Brown’s Facebook Live fiasco in Kansas City during the playoffs after the 2016 season to Martavis Bryant demanding a trade last season and dissing teammate JuJu Smith-Schuster to Le’Veon Bell and Mike Mitchell tweeting and talking about a playoffs rematch with the Patriots before they even played Jacksonville to Bell missing a walk-through practice before the Jaguars game. Tomlin did suspend Bryant for one game. He also has himself to blame for his players looking past Jacksonville to New England because he did the same thing in December during an interview with Tony Dungy.
Read More
Belichick also doesn’t play favorites, although I believe that makes him an exception among coaches in all sports and might be starting to hurt him and the Patriots. Many of his former players have said it’s no fun to play for him. Many others were angry when he didn’t play star cornerback Malcolm Butler in the Super Bowl LII loss in February to Philadelphia and never explained his reasons. There also have been reports of an icy relationship with Brady, although Harrison said he never saw any signs of trouble.
Our in-depth Steelers coverage is second to none.
Support quality journalism. Subscribe today.
Harrison suggested Tomlin would be a better coach if he had one set of rules for all players, but that isn’t going to happen. Tomlin has said as much. When I asked him in 2015 about allowing Brown to be a distraction with his touchdown celebrations, he bristled: “Everything he gets, he’s earned. His commitment to this thing is unique. When people have unique commitments, they get unique considerations. That’s the reality of life.”
That attitude doesn’t make Tomlin unique among coaches. I think back to Sparky Anderson’s days managing The Big Red Machine in Cincinnati. He had separate rules for future Hall of Famers Pete Rose, Johnny Bench, Joe Morgan and Tony Perez than he did for the rest of the team. “Those four made their own rules,” Anderson said.
Tomlin treats his players as if they are men. On a few occasions, players have let him down. There is no greater example of that than Harrison.
Tomlin was loyal to Harrison, who was NFL defensive player of the year for him in 2008 and made the greatest play in Super Bowl history with his 100-yard interception return for a touchdown against Arizona in Super Bowl XLIII. In retrospect, Tomlin made a mistake bringing Harrison back last season at 39 and keeping him on the team after it became clear young No. 1 draft picks Bud Dupree and T.J. Watt were going to get the playing time at outside linebacker. Harrison sulked and became a detriment to the team. It’s interesting that he gave rave reviews to the coaches’ meetings in New England. I’m not sure how he could comment on the Steelers’ meetings because he slept through many. He also would leave Heinz Field once he saw he was inactive for a game rather than stay and support his teammates. His behavior — tolerated by Tomlin — made Tomlin look weak and hurt him with the other players more than anything else.
It’s nice to think Tomlin has learned from that and the whole “Team Turmoil” thing last season. He shouldn’t have to be prodded by Harrison’s message.
It’s also nice to think it will be a long time before we hear from Harrison again. I’ve already heard too much.
Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com and Twitter @RonCookPG. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Poni” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.