Austin Meadows remained with the Pirates Saturday when Starling Marte returned to the active roster. That’s good.
Meadows didn’t start Saturday against the St. Louis Cardinals at PNC Park despite hitting .448 with a 1.345 OPS in his first seven big-league games. That’s bad.
Gregory Polanco started in right field despite suffering through a 3-for-28 slump and playing horrendous defense. That’s bad.
Polanco was dropped from second to seventh in the batting order. That’s something, right? That’s good, I think.
The Pirates lost to the Cardinals, 4-1. That definitely was bad.
I would have liked the Pirates’ chances a little more if Meadows had started instead of Polanco, whose batting average has dropped to .209 and OPS to .748 even though he still leads the team with eight home runs and 27 walks.
Read More
At least Meadows still is here. It would have been easy for the Pirates to send him out instead of Jose Osuna for a couple of reasons. One, it could save the franchise money down the road by keeping Meadows from reaching Super 2 status in salary arbitration. And two, Meadows, barely 23, almost certainly isn’t a finished product and needs to play virtually every day, here or at Class AAA Indianapolis. There is so much video and advanced scouting these days. It’s seems only a matter of time until opposing teams find weaknesses in Meadows’ game. Clint Hurdle talked Saturday about that happening to Polanco in 2014 when Polanco came to the big leagues in June and started his career with an 11-game hitting streak, .365 batting average and .863 OPS before being sent back down in August after a 1-for-30 slump. “The game punches back,” Hurdle said.
But until that happens to Meadows and for as long as he’s here, he needs to play. He’s earned that. His three home runs and five multi-hit games in those first seven games were impressive. “Eye-catching,” Hurdle said.
I get that the Pirates don’t want to give up on Polanco. They can’t give up on him. They owe him more than $27 million in guaranteed money through 2021.
But the Pirates are in the business of winning games — right now. Meadows is better than Polanco — right now. Sitting Polanco for a few games wouldn’t hurt him and actually might help him. Even sending him back briefly to the minor leagues to find his game — he has an option left — wouldn’t be a career-killer. Mickey Mantle was sent down once and somehow found a way to thrive.
No, I’m not suggesting Polanco will be another Mantle. I’m just trying to make the point that many players are better for being sent down.
“I haven’t even crossed that bridge. I wouldn’t even want to get involved in that question right now,” Hurdle said when asked about demoting Polanco.
Polanco is putting in work to get better, Hurdle said, on the field before games and in the video room. I’m not ready to write him off, but there are reasons to wonder if what you see with him is what you’re going to get. He’s no raw kid anymore. He will be 27 in September. This is his fifth season in the big leagues.
Hurdle said there is enough playing time for Marte, Polanco, Corey Dickerson and Meadows. That’s why the team kept Meadows — at least for now.
“I do believe it gave us more depth,” Hurdle said. “It gives us a stronger bench. It’s going to afford us the opportunity to keep the three frontline outfielders in a better physical condition than we ever could have afforded before. We’ll be able to have the opportunity to get everybody playing time and everybody ample rest.”
I’m not sure about that.
Marte is the Pirates’ best player. He crushed a home run in his first at-bat Saturday and made a nice running catch in center field. Dickerson is having the best season. He is hitting .312 with an .845 OPS and leads the team with 31 RBIs despite an 0 for 4 Saturday. Marte and Dickerson have to play almost every day. That leaves Meadows or Polanco to play in right. I’m not the smartest guy in the world, but it seems foolish to me to keep Meadows here and not give him most of the starts. He can’t be the fourth outfielder behind the “three frontline” guys. He would be better off at Indianapolis getting regular at-bats. He bounced out as a pinch-hitter Saturday, a role he hasn’t been asked to play much in his brief pro career.
Hurdle remained steadfast about playing all four outfielders. He said Meadows will get work in right and left field as well as in center. “When Polanco is playing well, everybody likes it. When Marte is playing well, everybody likes it. When Dickerson is playing well, everybody likes it. Nobody wants anybody out of the lineup. But these guys do need time out of the lineup to stay in a good spot.
“We’ll see where we go from here.”
The Pirates and Cardinals are back at it Sunday afternoon with a series win on the line. The Pirates’ best lineup will have Meadows — not Polanco — in right field.
Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com and Twitter@RonCookPG. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Poni” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.