I had two thoughts when the surprising news broke Wednesday that the Arizona Cardinals had released terrific safety Tyrann Mathieu. One, he would be a great fit for the Steelers, who have a glaring need at the position after releasing Mike Mitchell and Robert Golden. And two, there is no way they could fit him under their salary cap unless they pulled back their franchise tag on Le’Veon Bell and allowed him to become a free agent.

Then, Mathieu told ESPN he wanted to play for a winner, “to go somewhere where football is important and it matters.” That describes the Steelers, right? I wanted to believe a deal with Mathieu was possible, but I couldn’t get past Bell’s contract.

Then, Mathieu signed a one-year, $7 million deal Friday with the Houston Texans. That is a fortune for those of us in the real world, but it’s a modest contract for a player of Mathieu’s stature and ability. He was cut by the Cardinals, who would have had to pay him $19 million for the next two seasons, after he refused to take a pay cut. The Steelers could have fit his new contract under the cap with relatively minor maneuvering and without reneging on Bell. They, not the Texans, could be celebrating one of the better free-agent signings of the off-season.

Now, I’m thinking Mike Tomlin and Kevin Colbert really blew it.

Advertise with us

Reaching a deal with free-agent linebacker Jon Bostic Sunday didn’t make me feel much better.

The Steelers are built to win now, today, this minute. Mathieu would have made the team’s weak defense significantly better. He is a playmaker. Think Troy Polamalu.

Mathieu accepted a one-year deal from the Texans in order to prove he’s all the way back from three serious injuries. He will be able to strike it rich with a multiyear contract in 2019 if he has a big season. He played all 16 games last season with two interceptions, seven passes defended and 78 tackles. It was the first time he played in every game since entering the NFL in 2013. Knee injuries ended his season in 2013 and 2015, a shoulder injury in 2016.

Mathieu also has a history of drug issues in his distant past. He failed multiple tests before being suspended for his final season at LSU in 2012. That caused him to drop to the third round in the 2013 draft.

But Mathieu has been clean since coming into the NFL. The Steelers need to look no further than Bell to see that players can mature and become solid professionals. When healthy, Mathieu also is one of the league’s top defensive players, a physical safety who can tackle and cover slot receivers. He was first-team All-Pro in 2015 and was a candidate for defensive player of the year when his knee was injured in Week 15.

Advertise with us

Our in-depth Steelers coverage is second to none.

Support quality journalism. Subscribe today.

There’s no doubt the Texans are getting a driven player in Mathieu, not just because he wants that big deal in 2019, but because he wants to prove the Cardinals wrong for asking him to take that cut. I just wish he would be driving the Steelers defense. Their players know how much he would have helped. Cam Heyward, Mike Hilton and Joe Haden were among those who reached out to Mathieu in an attempt to sell him on Pittsburgh. I imagine Haden told him things worked out pretty well for him with the Steelers after the Cleveland Browns released him in August.

Too bad Tomlin and Colbert didn’t make it happen.

It’s hard to believe Bostic will be the answer as Ryan Shazier’s replacement. He has been with four teams — the Chicago Bears, New England Patriots, Detroit Lions and Indianapolis Colts — since coming into the NFL In 2013. The Steelers still are expected to draft an inside linebacker high in the April draft. Unfortunately, they also still have that major need at safety after passing on Mathieu.

Advertise with us

A lot of people will tell you they wish the Steelers had concentrated on improving their defense instead of putting the franchise tag on Bell, who, once he signs it, is guaranteed $14,544,000 next season. But I’m OK with bringing him back to take one more crack at a Super Bowl with Ben Roethlisberger, Antonio Brown and a superb offensive line despite the fact he will avoid training camp and the exhibition season for a second consecutive year. I don’t like allowing a phenomenal talent to leave as a free agent with nothing in return. Bell is too valuable to their offense, a back who is just as good of a receiver and blitz-protector as he is a runner and never has to leave the field, which is a huge plus when the team runs its no-huddle offense. He touched the ball on 39.5 percent of their offensive plays last season and produced 31.4 percent of their yardage. I wouldn’t have pulled back his franchise tag in order to sign Mathieu.

What’s sad is the Steelers didn’t have to pull it. They could have had both players.

Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com and Twitter @RonCookPG. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Poni” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.