Although Neal Huntington won’t rule out trading anyone before the July 31 deadline, he has said he really isn’t interested in moving Andrew McCutchen and/or Gerrit Cole because he believes they will give the Pirates a better chance to succeed next season. I’m right there with Huntington on that. I’m already thinking about 2018 because I don’t have a lot of faith in these Pirates rebounding from their poor first half. They will take a 42-47 record into their home game Friday night against the St. Louis Cardinals and trail first-place Milwaukee by 7 games.

But I really wish the Pirates had traded for Chicago White Sox left-hander Jose Quintana Thursday instead of watching him move on to the division rival Chicago Cubs.

I can dream, right?

Everyone knows Huntington is loath to give up top prospects because of his belief that he has to keep young players flowing through the organizational pipeline for the Pirates to be successful for the long term. The only real exception he has made is when he wanted to dump Francisco Liriano’s heavy contract last season. He coaxed the Toronto Blue Jays into taking Liriano by adding prospects Reese McGuire and Harold Ramirez to the trade.

Advertise with us

That’s why it wasn’t the least bit surprising in the offseason when the Pirates couldn’t finalize a deal for Quintana despite, according to all reports, having serious trade talks with the White Sox. Huntington said the team’s fans would have been shocked and even outraged if he had met the White Sox’s asking price. It is believed he wouldn’t give up Austin Meadows and Tyler Glasnow in any deal. Meadows is the Pirates’ top hitting prospect and likely long-term replacement for McCutchen in center field despite a bad start to this season and what appears to be a chronic hamstring problem. Glasnow was the team’s top pitching prospect before the season but failed miserably with the Pirates before being sent back to the minors in June.

The Cubs, who had a lousy first half after winning the World Series last season, didn’t hesitate Thursday to give up their best hitting prospect and best pitching prospect to get Quintana. They sent outfielder Eloy Jiminez (ranked as baseball’s No. 5 overall prospect by Baseball America) and pitcher Dylan Cease (No. 83) — both Class A players — to the White Sox, rightfully thinking Quintana greatly enhances their chances of catching the Milwaukee Brewers and running away from the Cardinals and Pirates in the lame National League Central Division.

It’s too bad Huntington wasn’t more aggressive in trying to get Quintana — for next season and beyond as much as for this season. I would have started with a package of Meadows (still ranked No. 22 by Baseball America) and pitcher Mitch Keller (No. 15) and gone from there. Why not? There are no guarantees Meadows and/or Keller are going to be successful big-league players. See Meadows and Glasnow so far. Quintana proved himself on Chicago’s South Side. There’s not a lot of risk with him.

I get that Huntington doesn’t have the same built-in advantages that the Cubs do. The Cubs can afford to be wrong about Quintana’s effectiveness if he happens to fail on Chicago’s North Side. They can throw money at any problem. They certainly don’t need to hang on to their top prospects as much as the Pirates do. They can go out and buy top players every year.

But including Meadows and Keller in a package for Quintana wouldn’t have been totally mortgaging the Pirates’ future. It’s not as if Quintana is a rental player. He is under contract through the 2020 season. He also wouldn’t bust the penurious budget given to Huntington by Bob Nutting. Quintana makes $7 million this season and is due to get $8.85 million in 2018 and $10.5 million in each of the 2019 and 2020 seasons. That is a bargain for a quality pitcher in today’s game. The Pirates were willing to pay Liriano $13 million a year until he pitched badly for them last season.

Advertise with us

It’s pretty easy to think Quintana will help the Cubs win another World Series. Maybe not this season but in the next three years. It’s a little harder to think the baseball world will hear about big things from Jiminez and Cease, although the White Sox might not need one or both to be stars to be a great team soon. The White Sox now have the game’s Nos. 1, 5, 20, 45, 59, 75 and 83 top prospects, according to Baseball America.

The Cubs made themselves a lot better Thursday. The Pirates’ task of catching them anytime soon is much harder.

It’s a shame Huntington couldn’t or wouldn’t do a deal for Quintana.

Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com and Twitter @RonCookPG. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Poni” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.