One day, Jim Rutherford talks as if he won’t trade Marc-Andre Fleury. “I’ve said all along since training camp my preference is to keep him, to have that depth in goal. We have 16 games in March. I believe we’re going to have to have two goalies playing. The danger of playing one goalie down the stretch is he will get burned out and not be ready for the playoffs.”

The next day, Rutherford sounds as if a Fleury trade is imminent, telling SportsNet Canada over the weekend: “I think the key thing in this situation is how long can Fleury go and be patient. He’s a guy who’s used to playing. He told me he wants to play. He is a very good goalie and a very good pro. He can help Pittsburgh or any team he may play on. I would expect by the time Monday or Tuesday comes, he may be more direct about exactly what he wants. We’ll work with him as to what makes the most sense for him and the Penguins.”

I have no idea what’s going to happen before the NHL trade deadline Wednesday, but I do have a preference:

I hope the Penguins keep Fleury because I believe they will need him to win a second consecutive Stanley Cup.

Advertise with us

I keep thinking back to something iconic hockey coach Scotty Bowman told Pittsburgh Post-Gazette columnist Gene Collier earlier this month:

“I think Pittsburgh wants to keep Fleury. That’s not a position you can take a gamble on. It’s the most important position on the team.”

The Penguins needed three goaltenders last season to get to the playoffs and win the Cup. Fleury was huge during the regular season and Matt Murray was terrific in the postseason. But many forget the team needed Jeff Zatkoff to start and win the first game of the first playoff series against the New York Rangers.

The Penguins went into this season believing Murray and Fleury could be successful by mostly alternating starts. Their plan failed. Neither goaltender played well in a platoon situation. Each is at his best when he knows he’s the man. Mike Sullivan picked Murray, who has started 15 of the past 18 games and followed his strong postseason run as a rookie last spring with a big regular season. It was the right call. Murray, 22, is the present and the future, not Fleury, 32.

But that doesn’t mean Fleury won’t provide valuable insurance if he stays. He’s not just capable of winning playoff games. He’s still capable of winning the Cup.

Advertise with us

“If we end up keeping [Fleury], I’ll be more than happy with that,” Rutherford said. “You never have enough depth at any position.”

Rutherford acknowledged the market for goaltenders is limited, if existent at all. Sunday, the Tampa Bay Lightning traded veteran Ben Bishop, who will be an unrestricted free agent after the season, to the Los Angeles Kings for a minimal return. The problem in moving Fleury is his salary — $5.75 million a year through the 2018-19 season. That’s tough for any team to take on under the salary cap. Even if one could, it’s hard to imagine that team giving Rutherford the quality defenseman he would want in return. The Penguins also would need a veteran backup goaltender in that or another deal because they don’t believe Wilkes-Barre/Scranton’s Tristan Jarry is ready for a heavy postseason load.

That’s why it makes sense for the Penguins to keep Fleury.

Here’s another reason:

“Chemistry factors in a lot,” Rutherford said. “Championship teams don’t win unless you have good chemistry. You can have all of the great players you want, but you have to have that chemistry because there are a lot of ups and downs in a season and in a playoff run. The more character and leadership you have in there, the better chance you’re going to have.”

Advertise with us

Teammates adore Fleury. The only player I’ve seen as popular and as impactful in a locker room was Jerome Bettis. I know players quickly will grow to like any new addition as long as he shows he can help the team win. But I’m thinking there would be a unanimous vote to keep Fleury in the Penguins’ room. That can’t be the ultimate factor in Rutherford’s decision, but it’s something he has to consider.

After practice Monday, Fleury declined to talk about his discussions with Rutherford and wouldn’t say if he has asked to be traded. He could have said, “I like it here and want to finish the season here.” That he didn’t makes you think he wouldn’t mind being moved to a team on which he could be the No. 1 goaltender. If Fleury feels that way, fine. But the Penguins can’t trade him just because he might want out. No one questions that he has been a great teammate, even as Murray has passed him by. He’s won 372 career games and led the team to the Cup in 2009. But Rutherford has to do what’s right for the organization, not what’s right for Fleury.

Keeping Fleury is what’s best for the Penguins.

Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com and Twitter@RonCookPG. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Poni” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.