So this is a bit what it feels like to live in Tuscaloosa, Ala.?
Pitt beats No. 3 Clemson on the road. Penn State beats No. 2 Ohio State, wins six games in a row and has a chance to play for the Big Ten Conference championship. West Virginia is 8-1 and will play Oklahoma at home Saturday night, perhaps for the Big 12 title.
That might not make us Tuscaloosa, where Alabama is favored to win its fifth national championship in eight years. But the college football season hasn’t felt this good around here for years. And it soon might get a lot better. Much has to go right, but it’s possible Penn State and West Virginia could make it to the sport’s Final Four and play for the national championship.
Who saw this coming?
Not me, I can assure you.
I wrote a Sept. 30 column on these pages under the headline, “With Pitt, PSU struggling, there’s little sunshine on college football front.” Pitt had followed up an historic win against Penn State with tough losses against Oklahoma State and North Carolina. “Pitt-like losses,” I called them. “Just when you think Pitt is turning the corner and becoming relevant again, it finds ways to lose big games and break the hearts of its fans.” Penn State had just lost, 49-10, at Michigan to fall to 0-7 against Michigan, Ohio State and Michigan State under third-year coach James Franklin. “Penn State is awful … an embarrassment,” I wrote.
Read More
Well, guess who is feeling pretty awful and embarrassed this morning?
Pitt turned around its season by winning Saturday at Clemson as a three-touchdown underdog. Congrats to Pat Narduzzi for having his players ready to play and believing they could win. It wasn’t quite as satisfying as the 13-9 win against West Virginia in 2007 — that was a little later in the season, came against a big rival and denied the Mountaineers of playing for the national championship — but it was close. Clemson still should make the four-team college playoff. If Penn State also makes it, Pitt could say it beat two of the Final Four teams.
The Pitt defense has taken a beating all season — deservedly so — for being weak. Even against Clemson, it was awful at times, giving up an ACC-record 580 passing yards to quarterback Deshaun Watson. But it intercepted three Watson passes, shut out Clemson in the fourth quarter, came up with a big late interception by reserve linebacker Saleem Brightwell and made a fourth-down stop to give Pitt a chance to win. The defense did its part.
The Pitt offense is terrific. I thought the Steelers offense would be the most fun to watch this season, but Pitt’s has trumped it. James Conner has the heart of a champion. Quadree Henderson is worth the price of a ticket. Nathan Peterman gets better each week. Scott Orndoff reminds me of a young Rob Gronkowski. George Ashton. The solid offensive line …
Maybe the offense has been too good, if that’s possible. How will Pitt be able to keep offensive coordinator/genius Matt Canada? He will be a hot name for a head coaching job after the season.
Penn State improved dramatically after linebackers Jason Cabinda and Brandon Bell got healthy. It saved its season by coming back from a 23-20 deficit in the final minute to beat Minnesota, 29-26, in overtime Oct. 1. The 24-21 win against Ohio State Oct. 22 wasn’t quite as good as Pitt’s win at Clemson — it was at home in front of 107,280 — but it was close.
Penn State is in position to play in the Big Ten championship game. It needs to beat Rutgers and Michigan State and have Ohio State beat Michigan to get to the title game. If all of that happens and Penn State wins against Wisconsin, it would deserve to go into the four-team national championship playoff more than Ohio State.
The lesson learned here? You have to give a coach time to build his program. It is wrong to judge him in his second or third year. We should remember that with Narduzzi when Pitt loses a few more games this season or next.
West Virginia began the season with questions about its coach, Dana Holgorsen, but you aren’t hearing many complaints about him these days. West Virginia will win the Big 12 title if it beats Oklahoma, Iowa State and Baylor, and Oklahoma beats Oklahoma State. An 11-1 West Virginia team rightfully could say it deserves a spot in the national championship playoff field, but the lack of a Big 12 title game would hurt its chances.
Regardless, Pitt, West Virginia and especially Penn State appear headed for good bowls. One national prognosticator has Penn State going to the Rose Bowl, West Virginia to the Alamo Bowl and Pitt to the Pinstripe Bowl.
No, we’re not watching Alabama here. But what we are watching is pretty good.
Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com and Twitter @RonCookPG. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Poni” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.