On a beautiful holiday afternoon when I expected to see meaningful September baseball at PNC Park against the Pirates’ biggest rival, I wound up in a record book searching for the franchise’s greatest collapses.

There was the 19-43 finish in 2011 after the team started 53-47. There also was the 16-36 finish in 2012 after the club seemed certain to end 19 years of losing when it was 63-47 through Aug. 8.

Now, here comes the monumental meltdown of 2016.

It might be the hardest collapse to watch because so much more was expected from these Pirates after the 98-, 88- and 94-win seasons in the three previous years made them one of just three teams to make the playoffs each season. It is obvious even their most loyal — if spoiled — fans are mighty disgusted.

Advertise with us

The losing streak reached seven games Monday when the Pirates, a day after an embarrassing 10-0 home loss to the Milwaukee Brewers, lost, 12-6, to the St. Louis Cardinals in a game that started on Labor Day and was so dull and tedious that it seemed to end on …

It’s Halloween today, right?

It’s hard to believe the Pirates were 67-61 on Aug. 28 after sweeping the Brewers in a four-game series in Milwaukee and trailed the Cardinals by just a half-game for the National League’s second wild card. Today, they are 67-68 and 4½ games behind the Cardinals for that wild-card slot and 3½ behind the New York Mets. The Pirates have 27 games remaining. Unless there’s a dramatic turnaround by a club that’s mediocre by definition of its record, the finish line can’t get here soon enough.

Clint Hurdle is as baffled as you are frustrated. He can’t believe his team has lost nine of its past 10 games at PNC Park. He also has a hard time explaining how, during the losing streak, his underachieving hitters managed their most runs off starters when they faced the Cardinals’ Adam Wainwright Monday and the Chicago Cubs’ Jake Arrieta Aug. 29. “That just throws another monkey wrench in thinking you’ve got things figured out,” Hurdle said.

It’s interesting that Hurdle mentioned Arrieta and that game against the Cubs. That was the night the Pirates’ season turned in a 15-or-so-minute span. The Cardinals trailed Milwaukee before scoring two runs in the eighth and one in the ninth to win, 6-5. At virtually the same time, the Pirates’ Neftali Feliz and Tony Watson were blowing a 6-3 lead after seven innings in what become an 8-7 loss in 13. Instead of taking control of the wild card, the Pirates fell 1½ games behind St. Louis. They have not recovered.

Advertise with us

“Sometimes, you just don’t play as well as you need to play to win a game,” Hurdle said. “We’re always going to take the field and represent the jersey …

“You show up the next day and play another game. There’s no guarantee up here that you’re going to win. You’ve got to fight every day for success.”

I’m guessing many fans don’t want to hear that. The boos came early Monday from an angry crowd, most directed at Jeff Locke who needed 74 pitches to get through innings 3-5 after starter Chad Kuhl threw 58 equally wearisome pitches in the first two innings. The Pirates trailed, 10-2, by the time Locke’s day was done.

But the boos started long before Monday. Fans have ripped Bob Nutting all season for not spending more on his payroll, seldom giving him any pass for getting so little for the big money he has spent on Andrew McCutchen, the since-departed Francisco Liriano and, to a lesser extent, Gerrit Cole. They have called the talk shows the past few weeks to demand the firing of Neal Huntington for not re-signing J.A. Happ and trading Neil Walker and Hurdle for allowing this team to quit even though Huntington and Hurdle practically walked on water when they built a contending club after the 20 years of losing. They even have booed McCutchen, who finished in the top five of the National League MVP voting in each of the previous four seasons, winning in 2013, and Cole, who won 19 games a year ago and finished fourth in the Cy Young voting.

Going into Monday, Pirates attendance was down 2,369 per game, the seventh-worst slip in baseball. Only Detroit and Baltimore, among playoff contending clubs, have had bigger decreases. It also seems as if a lot of people won’t be happy even if the Pirates get a wild card. To paraphrase what I am hearing: They’ll just lose the one-game playoff, anyway. What’s the point?

Advertise with us

Is that silly thinking or what?

Pirates fans have become a tough crowd.

Yes, a spoiled crowd.

Hurdle insisted the Pirates still have plenty of fight left and promised they will take the PNC Park lawn tonight for another game against the Cardinals, ready, willing and able to meet the challenge.

“I think they’re realistic about it,” he said of his players. “You don’t just blow it off. It’s not just a trend. It’s not just a cycle. You’ve got to fight back and find ways to do things in a better fashion. We’ll put all our focus into playing a better game tomorrow.”

Advertise with us

Just in case it doesn’t work out for the Pirates and they lose again, here’s a public-service reminder:

Pitt and Penn State play Saturday and the Steelers open the NFL season Monday night in Washington.

No need to thank me.

Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com and Twitter@RonCookPG. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Poni” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.