Against great odds, the Pirates have reached Steelers status and Penguins status. No matter how well they do in the regular season, it isn’t good enough if they fail in the postseason. That is a blessing for a franchise that ended an unprecedented run of 20 consecutive losing seasons just a few years ago. But it also is a curse. Ask the Steelers. Ask the Penguins.
The Steelers go to training camp each summer with a Super Bowl-or-bust mentality that is shared by their fan base. You might imagine the angst of team and fans after the 23-20 home overtime loss Thursday night to the Baltimore Ravens. The Steelers are 2-2 and looking at a troubled future without Ben Roethlisberger, probably until November. The Super Bowl isn’t on their schedule.
The Penguins will have a Stanley Cup-or-bust attitude when they open the season Thursday night in Dallas. Since 2009, it’s been all bust despite some remarkable regular-season accomplishments. It’s been so bad that stars Sidney Crosby, Evgeni Malkin, Marc-Andre Fleury and Kris Letang are generally regarded as career underachievers.
Now, the Pirates get ready to roll into the playoffs after one of their best regular seasons in franchise history. The team took 96 wins into its weekend series against the Cincinnati Reds. It has provided thrills and chills since mid-May by playing the best ball in the game.
Expectations for the Pirates are soaring. This isn’t like the 2013 team, which made for a feel-good story by ending the two-decade drought, winning 94 games, beating the Reds in the Johnny Cueto wild-card game on one of the great nights in Pittsburgh sports history and pushing the St. Louis Cardinals to the brink in the National League Division Series. It isn’t like the 2014 team, which overcame a long list of injuries to win 88 games before being Bumgarnered in the wild-card game by the San Francisco Giants. This team is much better. Expectations are much greater.
That is the blessing. Any player, coach or club official will tell you it is better to be expected to win than to be given no chance. These Pirates have a big chance of getting to the World Series.
Read More
But everything the Pirates have done will be quickly forgotten if they lose the wild-card game to the Chicago Cubs Wednesday night. Or the NLDS to the Cardinals. Or the National League Championship Series to the New York Mets or Los Angeles Dodgers.
World Series-or-bust?
You bet.
That’s the way the Pirates look at themselves. “I’m picking us to win it all,” Gerrit Cole said last week. That’s the way the rest of us should look at the team.
The Pirates have the best lineup of the five National League playoff teams. They have the best bullpen. They have the best depth. They have the best defense and the best …
OK, forget about defense and base-running.
Can we agree the Pirates have the best lineup, bullpen and depth?
The Pirates’ success will come down to starting pitching, the way it does for all playoff teams. They can hold their own with Cole, Francisco Liriano, J.A. Happ and A.J. Burnett in a five-game series against the Cardinals and a seven-game series against the Mets or Dodgers, although seeing Zack Greinke and Clayton Kershaw in four games against the Dodgers could be problematic. At least the Pirates won’t have to give the ball to Charlie Morton or Jeff Locke and tell him to go get ’em.
The toughest game will be the wild-card game. The Pirates must take blame for being in that spot because, heading into the weekend, they were just 32-41 against National League Central Division opponents with a losing record against each of the four clubs. Credit also must be given to the Cardinals for winning 100 games to take the division title. But, in any case, the Pirates have to beat the Cubs’ Jake Arrieta -- baseball’s hottest pitcher – for the right to move on.
“Everybody already has him penciled in for a shutout,” said Cole, who will get the ball for the Pirates.
There was no jealousy in Cole’s voice. There was no anger. But those close to him say he’s not thrilled about being considered the lesser of the two pitchers by just about everybody. “Oh, yeah, that motivates him,” Pirates pitching coach Ray Searage said.
I’m picking Cole to match pitches with Arrieta in a Pirates’ win that comes down to the bullpens. I’m also predicting a NLDS win against the Cardinals, who are vulnerable because of their ridiculous run of injuries. I’m going to wait for the opponent to be determined in the NLCS before I make that call, but the Pirates are plenty good enough to beat the Mets or the Dodgers.
You know the harsh truth.
Fair or not, right or wrong, anything less than getting to the World Series will mean the Pirates’ season will be remembered as a disappointment.
That is the curse.
Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Poni” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.