The A.J. Burnett who first took the mound Saturday night was not the 38-year-old veteran of 17 seasons making the 430th and final regular-season start of his career. It was A.J. Jr., Burnett’s 14-year-old son, who with his brother Ashton, 11, threw out the first pitch.
Andrew McCutchen and Neil Walker crouched at the plate to catch. The four of them posed for a picture, then it was Burnett’s turn.
The fans behind the Pirates dugout stood, waiting for him to emerge. One young fan, bundled in a stocking cap against the cold, windy night, positioned himself right above the dugout steps and waved a Batman flag. Five cameramen crouched outside the dugout, shooting away as Burnett climbed the steps for one final start, one final walk to the mound as Marilyn Manson played, one final subtle salute to Francisco Cervelli before he began his warm-up.
This was not a victory lap. The Pirates needed to win to clinch home-field advantage against the Chicago Cubs in the National League wild-card game. Burnett gave them a chance, but their lineup fell short and the Pirates lost, 3-1, to the Cincinnati Reds at PNC Park. The Cubs won Saturday, meaning the Pirates need to win today or hope the Cubs lose to Milwaukee for the wild-card game to be in Pittsburgh. The Cubs hold the tiebreaker if they finish with the same record.
“We’ve got to come out, we’ve got to score some runs and try to get them down early and lock it down,” Walker said.
Burnett might not be done. He could pitch in the National League Division Series if the Pirates advance — the Pirates could use four starters unless they bring someone back on short rest. But he has said he will retire after this season.
Read More
“In my mind, we ain’t done yet,” Burnett said. “We got a horse [Gerrit Cole] going up in a couple days against Chicago, and get me another start.”
Joey Votto tipped his helmet at Burnett in his first at-bat — “Heck yeah, he deserves it,” Votto said. “What a fantastic career. It better be the end of it, I’m tired of facing him and I mean that.” — but the Reds did not treat Burnett kindly. Eugenio Suarez singled in the first and reached third when Burnett’s pick-off throw got away. Votto’s grounder drove home Suarez. Brandon Phillips singled and stole second, scoring on Todd Frazier’s double.
After the first, Burnett settled in. Tucker Barnhart hit a leadoff single in the second before Burnett recorded 13 consecutive outs. Burnett’s strikeout of Jay Bruce looking in the fourth was the 2,508th of his career, moving him past Hall of Famer Christy Mathewson for 31st place on the all-time strikeout list.
“Once I settled down after the first, you saw that I had a little bit left,” he said. “One ball got over the middle late in the game, but to be able to go out there and get some swings and misses and jump up that list again, it’s not going to sink in for a while.”
Burnett’s counterpart, Reds left-hander Brandon Finnegan, 22, was 2 when the New York Mets drafted Burnett in 1995 and 6 on Aug. 17, 1999, when Burnett made his major league debut. Finnegan made his fourth major league start. After allowing a run in the first, he shut out the Pirates for the next five innings.
Adam Duvall homered in the seventh. Fans threw the ball back on the field; Andrew McCutchen picked it up and threw it in the river. After a two-out walk to Jason Bourgeois, manager Clint Hurdle came out to get Burnett. Burnett’s 6⅔ innings of three-run ball kept his ERA this season at 3.18, the lowest of his career. He has 2,513 career strikeouts and a career 3.99 ERA.
Hurdle gave him two taps on the chest before Burnett walked into the dugout, waving at the crowd, tipping his cap to the Reds dugout.
“It was extremely loud, one of the loudest moments I can remember here,” said reliever Jared Hughes, who ran in from the bullpen as Burnett exited. “It was hard not to hear [the crowd chanting] A-J, A-J.”
Burnett came out for a curtain call, blew kisses in the direction of his family in the suites and disappeared.
“Going back out there, you can ask me a million times what it’s like,” Burnett said. “But I can’t tell you, man.”
Bill Brink: bbrink@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrinkPG.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.