The Pirates hit .500 with their latest roster decisions. They were right not to enter the Russell Martin Sweepstakes. They struck out by bringing back A.J. Burnett.

Martin is one of baseball’s good guys, a true pro whose energy, enthusiasm and clubhouse leadership helped the Pirates reach success they hadn’t achieved in more than two decades. He was worth every penny of the $17 million the team gave him for two seasons as its highest-paid free agent. He always should be remembered well here. Good for him getting a five-year, $82 million contract a week ago from the Toronto Blue Jays. In a sense, he is going home. He is a Canadian native from Montreal.

But there’s no way Martin will live up to that big deal. The Blue Jays, who always feel the pressure of trying to compete with the New York Yankees, Boston Red Sox and Baltimore Orioles in the American League East Division, badly overpaid to get him. Martin is an aging catcher — he will be 32 Feb. 15 — and is entering the time when his body should start to break down. He has offered to play another, less-grueling position later in his career and, now that he’s in the American League, could be a designated hitter at some point. But Martin’s best value is as a catcher. He is terrific at the defensive side of the game, calling and framing pitches and throwing out would-be base-stealers. A team can do a lot better than him at every other position.

Martin will be missed, of course. Who will forget his home run in September to beat the Milwaukee Brewers at PNC Park? Or his home run off Cincinnati’s Johnny Cueto in the 2013 wild-card game at PNC Park? My favorite Martin memory came on the September night in 2013 in Chicago when the Pirates clinched their first playoff spot in 21 years. He tagged out Cubs outfielder Nate Schierholtz at the plate to end a 2-1 win, jumped up, screamed with joy and fired the ball off the ivy-covered left-field wall at Wrigley Field. It was an unforgettable moment.

Advertise with us

There was another in September in the ninth inning of the Pirates’ 8-0 loss to the San Francisco Giants in the wild-card game at PNC Park. The appreciative crowd chanted “Re-sign Russ! Re-sign Russ!” as Martin jogged back to the dugout after his final at-bat of the season.

“That was pretty special,” Martin said afterward. “That was definitely one of the coolest moments I think I’ve had in baseball.”

Many will blame Pirates owner Bob Nutting for not stepping up and signing Martin to a new deal. That criticism isn’t justified. Give Pirates management credit for realizing it couldn’t go a fifth year or even a fourth year to keep Martin. The previous ownership, led by Kevin McClatchy, wishes it would have had that same good sense when it gave catcher Jason Kendall a six-year, $60 million deal in 2000 as the team prepared to move into PNC Park. That contract set the franchise back for years.

Pirates general manager Neal Huntington has acknowledged the team will not be as good at catcher without Martin. Francisco Cervelli, acquired in a trade Nov. 12 with the New York Yankees for reliever Justin Wilson, will take over the position. Some scouts are high on Cervelli’s skills, but he hasn’t been able to stay healthy. Wilson is a proven commodity, at least in the sense he is left-handed and can throw the ball almost 100 mph. It’s easy to think the Yankees will get the better end of the trade.

Huntington has promised to use the money saved by not signing Martin to improve the Pirates in other areas, perhaps at first base, certainly the starting rotation if the team loses Francisco Liriano and Edinson Volquez as free agents. His first big move was to bring back Burnett Nov. 14 on a one-year, $8.5 million contract. That is a horrible start to Huntington’s offseason.

Advertise with us

Burnett turns 38 Jan. 3. His career has been in decline. It’s great that he started a National League-high 34 games this past season for the Philadelphia Phillies and pitched 2132⁄3 innings, 21 more than Volquez, the Pirates leader. But what good are innings without results?

Burnett had more losses (18) and gave up more earned runs (109) and more walks (96) than any pitcher in the league. His ERA (4.59) and WHIP (1.41) didn’t rank in the top 40 of the league’s pitchers. Maybe his sports hernia contributed to his ineffectiveness. Maybe some of it was because he pitched in Philadelphia’s hitter-friendly Citizens Bank Park. Or maybe he’s just done as a pitcher.

It’s hard to believe Pirates manager Clint Hurdle and pitching coach Ray Searage wanted Burnett back. Their most recent dealing with him didn’t end well. Burnett threw a temper tantrum when they told him he wouldn’t start Game 5 of a 2013 National League Division Series against the St. Louis Cardinals. Their differences appeared to be irreconcilable. Many tried to justify Burnett’s selfish behavior by saying he’s a competitor. But since when does being a competitor give someone the right to act like a petulant child? A lot of Burnett’s teammates, not to mention Hurdle and Searage, didn’t appreciate it.

Like Martin, Burnett deserves much credit for his role in turning the Pirates from a loser into a winner in 2012 and 2013. But, like Martin, although for very different reasons, his time here should be finished. Bringing him back is subtraction by addition.

Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Poni” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.