The Pirates are done with their easy decisions. Now, the hard work begins, the real challenges. It will not be a restful offseason for general manager Neal Huntington, who must deal with even bigger issues than he faced the past two years when he built a club that lost year after year for 20 years into a playoff team.
It made perfect sense this week for the Pirates to make a qualifying offer of $15.3 million for the 2015 season to catcher Russell Martin. There is no way Martin will accept. He will leave as a free agent and sign with another team for more years and more money than the Pirates can and will offer. It will be hard to blame Huntington for not matching a four- or five-year deal for Martin, perhaps from the Chicago Cubs, Los Angeles Dodgers or Detroit Tigers. Martin will be 32 in the spring and is a risk to start breaking down. When Martin leaves, the Pirates will get a high compensatory draft pick from his new team.
It also made sense for the Pirates to make the same qualifying offer to Liriano. The team will get another high draft pick if Liriano leaves, but there is reason to believe he will accept. Teams aren’t going to be so eager to sign him to a big multi-year deal knowing it will cost them the draft choice. The Pirates would love to have Liriano back for just a one-year commitment. They look at him differently than they did A.J. Burnett a year ago.
They didn’t make Burnett a qualifying offer — and didn’t get a draft pick when he left for Philadelphia — because they were afraid he would accept and didn’t think he was worth the money.
They were right; Burnett was a bust with the Phillies.
But the Pirates believe in Liriano. They think he would look good at the top of their rotation with Gerrit Cole. They are right about that, too.
Read More
If only Huntington’s other decisions were so obvious.
The Pirates must find a replacement for Martin. Going into next season with Chris Stewart and Tony Sanchez at catcher hardly seems like enough. Huntington has said the team won’t find a better catcher than Martin in free agency. He probably will have to trade for an adequate one.
The Pirates also must find a replacement for starter Edinson Volquez, who led the team with 13 wins and 1922⁄3 innings this past season.
Volquez probably will leave as a free agent. Huntington has said the Pirates will take the money they save by allowing Martin to leave and use it to strengthen the team in other places, no doubt starting with the rotation. It is wise strategy, but can Huntington pull it off? Can he find another Liriano or another Volquez — a low-priced free agent with a long-ago history of success and current flaws — and turn him over to pitching gurus Ray Searage and Jim Benedict? It is important that he does because starter Charlie Morton and potential starter Jameson Taillon are coming off injuries and might not be ready for the start of next season. The rest of the potential starters after Cole and Vance Worley — Jeff Locke, Brandon Cumpton, Stolmy Pimentel and Casey Sadler — don’t exactly frighten National League hitters.
But the toughest calls for Huntington involve arbitration-eligible players Neil Walker, Pedro Alvarez, Ike Davis, Mark Melancon and Gaby Sanchez. All will get raises, some big raises. Even Alvarez, coming off a miserable season, will get a raise. No wonder players love the arbitration system and owners hate it.
The Pirates must decide if they want to give Alvarez another try at third base, where he couldn’t make a routine throw to first base this past season, or keep him at first base, where he finished his season before a serious foot injury. First base makes the most sense.
Alvarez, who is under team contractual control for two more seasons, is a good bet to bounce back offensively and give the team much-needed power production at the position. He could platoon with Sanchez, making Davis expendable. Josh Harrison could continue to play third base.
Melancon is an interesting case. He’s a really nice closer, but his $2.6 million salary from should jump dramatically. Huntington traded Joel Hanrahan to the Boston Red Sox under similar circumstances after the 2012 season for four players, including, coincidentally, Melancon and Pimentel. Huntington should and almost certainly will consider moving Melancon. Tony Watson can close games.
Then, there is Walker, who made $5.75 million in 2014 and also is under team control for two more years. He is a fine second baseman — offensively and defensively — and deserves a long-term contract. He probably should have gotten one a year or two ago. The holdup is Walker has never seemed to be Huntington’s type of player for no apparent reason other than, maybe, that Walker has had a history of back trouble.
The Pirates should do a one-year deal with Walker and take a run at the playoffs in 2015, then look to trade him after the season if they don’t want to give him a multi-year deal.
Memo to Huntington:
No need to thank me.
Huntington has done a wonderful job the past two seasons, but it will take his best work to get the Pirates to the playoffs for the third consecutive season.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.