MORGANTOWN, W.Va.
For a long time Saturday, they had some party here. No couch-burning or rioting, just good, clean fun. The West Virginia defense was dominating the best offense in college football. The West Virginia offense, despite three first-half turnovers, had built a lead that stretched to 13 points midway through the third quarter. It looked as if West Virginia was going to beat No. 10 TCU and take a big step toward the Big 12 Conference championship. The fans at Milan Puskar Stadium even got to revel in Pitt's continuing misfortune. The vulgar chant they like to direct at Pitt broke out after the big scoreboard showed Duke's winning touchdown in double overtime earlier in the day.
It really was some day.
But the night?
That couldn't have been more rotten.
Two more turnovers in the second half doomed West Virginia. Some cautious play-calling by normally all-out, all-the-time coach Dana Holgorsen didn't help as his offense went three-and-out on its final three possessions. Jaden Oberkrom kicked a 37-yard field goal as the game ended to give TCU a 31-30 win.
There will be no Big 12 title for West Virginia, only agonizing regret about a big one that got away.
"I take responsibility for what happened offensively," Holgorsen said, sounding as if he couldn't believe what he had just watched. "It was bad. It's not acceptable. It's not going to win football games."
The defense saved the Mountaineers in the first half after a fumble by running back Rushel Shell, an interception by quarterback Clint Trickett and a fumble by running back Wendell Smallwood gave TCU the ball at the West Virginia 43, 21 and 23. The TCU offense, which had put up 82 points a week earlier against Texas Tech and was averaging a major college-best 50.4 points per game, couldn't turn any of the big breaks into points. West Virginia led, 13-7, at halftime.
"I thought our defense played well enough to win the game," Holgorsen said.
The defense forced two more three-and-outs to open the second half. It even scored a touchdown when cornerback Terrell Chestnut stripped the ball from wide receiver Josh Doctson and returned the fumble 35 yards for a 27-14 lead with 6:36 to go in the third quarter.
The defense did a fabulous job against TCU quarterback Trevone Boykin, who threw for seven touchdowns against Texas Tech and came in averaging 329.4 passing yards and 53.4 rushing yards per game. West Virginia held him to 166 passing yards and 49 rushing yards.
But Trickett kept turning over the ball. He failed to handle a low shotgun snap early in the third quarter, giving TCU possession at the Mountaineers 27. This time, a touchdown quickly followed. An even worse mistake by Trickett led to a touchdown that pulled TCU back in the game at 27-21. Under pressure, he appeared to try to throw the ball out of bounds, but his pass was intercepted by linebacker Paul Dawson at the West Virginia 29.
Trickett had his worst game, throwing for just 162 yards. He had thrown for more than 300 in seven of the first eight games. Trickett had problems connecting with star wide receiver Kevin White for a second consecutive week. White had three catches for 28 yards after getting three catches for 27 yards and a touchdown in a win a week earlier at Oklahoma State.
Initially, Holgorsen blamed West Virginia's running backs for the offense's weak 4.5-yards-per-play average. "We didn't run the ball very good. I thought our running backs were extremely average." That seemed a bit harsh because the Mountaineers' top four backs -- Smallwood, Shell, Dreamius Smith and Andrew Buie combined to run for 211 yards. But Holgorsen's criticism of Trickett was right on. "Clint was incredibly uncomfortable. He was uneasy in the pocket. He got spooked."
That explains why Holgorsen was so conservative late in the game after his defense stopped TCU on downs at the West Virginia 43. He called three consecutive running plays for Buie that lost 2 yards, giving the ball back to TCU at its 24 after a punt with 2:07 left. The crowd, which long had forgotten about Pitt's problems, booed.
"If we sat there and just tried to throw the ball, it wouldn't have turned out very good," Holgorsen said.
It turned out badly, anyway, after Boykin led the winning field-goal drive, the big play a 40-yard pass to wide receiver Kolby Listenbee. There were no boos after Oberkrom's kick, just stunned silence.
This really was a hurtful loss for West Virginia. It had a chance to take over second place in the conference, pending Kansas State's game against Oklahoma State Saturday night. Kansas State plays here Nov. 16. The Mountaineers would have had a real shot at winning the powerful league. Too bad for them they fumbled and threw it all away.
Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com. Ron Cook can be heard on the "Cook and Poni" show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.