EVANSTON, Ill. -- Unbeaten, untied and unimpressive.

All three fit the Penn State football team like a pair of Joe Paterno sweat socks.

Spare me the hosannas about the poise quarterback Michael Robinson showed yesterday in the 34-29 victory against Northwestern, leading the Nittany Lions to the winning touchdown in the final minute, overcoming a fourth-and-15 play along the way. He did it against a horrible defense that was lit up for 52 points and 773 yards at Arizona State last week. Penn State never should have been down in the first place.

And while you're at it, spare me the talk about how the great Penn State defense stood tall after a rough start. A rough start? The defense missed its wake-up call and didn't show up at Ryan Field until noon. Unfortunately, the game started at 11 a.m. local time.

Advertise with us

Penn State might get a few big wins before the season is done, but -- sorry -- this clearly wasn't one.

Paterno, who has coached a lot of Penn State teams that would have squashed this kind of weak opponent like a windshield bug, seemed to realize as much. According to Robinson, Paterno walked into his raucous locker room after the game and said to the players, "Why are you celebrating? You should expect to win."

Hey, it's understandable why the Penn State players were excited. A road win is something new to them. They had lost 10 of their previous 11 away games and were 6-20 on the road since 2000.

And this was a nice win in the sense that it beat the heck out of the alternative. A loss could have been devastating and sent Penn State tumbling toward its fifth losing season in the past six years. As it is, the Nittany Lions can go back to work this week and use their 4-0 record as added motivation.

But they have a lot of work to do before they start playing real Big Ten Conference teams, beginning with Minnesota at home Saturday.

Advertise with us

"There's one quote that I live by," Robinson said. " 'There can be no progress without struggle.' "

For much of this day, Robinson was a better philosopher than quarterback. He was careless with the football, throwing three interceptions, losing a fumble inside the Northwestern 10 and nearly losing another when he was sacked on the winning drive. Against any kind of a defense, that would have meant a loss.

But, remember, this was the Northwestern defense.

That's why it wasn't so surprising when Robinson converted the fourth-and-15 play from the Penn State 15. He had all kinds of time -- Northwestern rushed just three players -- and found tight end Isaac Smolko for a 20-yard gain. Robinson's play on the winning touchdown was more impressive. Facing an all-out blitz, he was hit as he threw but still got the ball to freshman wide receiver Derrick Williams for a 36-yard touchdown. Williams, by the way, is the real deal.

This was a first in a long time for Penn State, the offense rising up to bail out the defense.

Advertise with us

The Penn State defense didn't show much.

"I didn't know if we could stop them," Paterno said.

Penn State gave up 427 yards, including 198 on the ground. That's more than four times as much as it allowed on average in its wins against cupcakes South Florida, Cincinnati and Central Michigan.

"That's an incredible system they've got," cornerback Alan Zemaitis said.

Maybe, but that prompts two questions:

Advertise with us

Isn't a great defense supposed to be able to handle any offense?

And is it possible the Penn State defense -- back at full strength yesterday with the return of suspended linebacker Dan Connor -- is a bit overrated?

Northwestern went 80 yards in 16 plays for a touchdown on its first drive. It added a 10-play, 71-yard drive in the second quarter to push its lead to 20-7.

Even late, the Penn State defense barely had enough to win. Protecting a 27-26 lead, it allowed Northwestern to move from its 6 to the Penn State 5. It probably deserved to lose after safety Chris Harrell took a ridiculous personal foul penalty after the Nittany Lions had stopped Northwestern on a third-down play. And it might have lost if Northwestern coach Randy Walker hadn't suddenly turned conservative. His third-and-4 call at the Penn State 5 looked a lot like the infamous Tyler Palko slide for Pitt at Connecticut last season. Northwestern quarterback Brett Basanez ran a keeper to get the ball in front of the goalposts and was tackled for a 3-yard loss.

If you have a solid defense, it makes perfect sense to set up for a field goal and a 29-27 lead with 2:10 left.

Advertise with us

If you have Northwestern's defense, you have to take a shot at the end zone and hope for a 2-point conversion and a seven-point lead.

"If they had to do it over, I think they would probably do a couple things a little different down there," Paterno said.

The old coach looked relieved to escape with this one.

Actually, he looked terrible.

He said it was a bad case of the flu.

I'm thinking it might have been the way Penn State played.