Wednesday night was a litmus test for Robert Morris. The Colonials entered 10-6, winners of four of five, and with arguably its most talented team since joining the Horizon League in 2020. Cleveland State came to Moon with the same record, albeit with two more conference wins and a 10-game winning streak against the Colonials dating back to 2013.
And after an even first half, Robert Morris crumbled. The Colonials allowed Cleveland State to go on a 27-7 run and, while they cut that 20 point lead down to 8, never truly threatened to win. It was an opportunity, and 15th-year Robert Morris coach Andy Toole knew it.
“I was really excited to play this game because I knew what Cleveland State would bring to the court, and I was really eager to see what we would bring,” Toole said. “I’m a little disappointed in what we brought. We’ve got to keep getting better.”
Robert Morris still has a winning record and the talent to turn things around. But after more than half the season, the Colonials are in a familiar place: below .500 in conference play and near the bottom of the Horizon League.
Here’s where they stand with 14 games left before the conference tournament:
Catching up
Robert Morris has been, in a word, streaky. The Colonials started with two road losses then won six in a row, all by multiple possessions. Then came three losses: first to a solid MAC team (Ohio), then to arguably the top two Horizon teams in Youngstown State and Purdue-Fort Wayne. They got rolling with three wins in a row in December, then dropped a clunker to Detroit Mercy, which went 1-31 last year. Winning at Oakland, which went to the NCAA tournament and beat Kentucky last year, was a step up. The loss to Cleveland State was a step back.
Read More
There’s a wide gap in the Horizon League standings this year, with four teams (Youngstown State, Cleveland State, Purdue-Fort Wayne and Milwaukee) well above .500 overall, while four teams (Oakland, Detroit Mercy, IU-Indianapolis and 2-15 Green Bay) are well below even. Robert Morris could threaten that top half but currently sits eighth in the 11-team conference, between Oakland and Detroit Mercy.
The record is somewhat deceiving — Robert Morris played the 11th-easiest non-conference schedule, per KenPom, of the 364 Division I teams. But the Colonials did win their second-hardest non-conference game, beating Cornell on the road in December.

Why this year could be better
Robert Morris overhauled most of its roster in the offseason, bringing in eight players after losing five of its top six players to either the portal or graduation. (The lone returnee, senior guard Justice Williams, has not played this season due to injury.)
Guard Kam Woods has been the top option, coming from N.C. State. He’s largely recaptured the scoring form he had a season prior at N.C. A&T, where he averaged 17.3 points, and has scored in double figures in eight consecutive games. His best game (29 points) came in the win at Oakland.
But it hasn’t been a one-man show, especially as Woods missed five games with injury (all RMU wins). Guard Josh Omojafo has handled the step up from Division II Gannon, scoring in double figures in 12 of 17 games (and adding nine in three of those five). Forward Amarion Dickerson, stepping up from junior college, has had similar scoring success, including 27 points in a triple-overtime win at Northern Kentucky. Guard DJ Smith, a Bowling Green transfer, has shown flashes, especially when Woods was injured.
And Alvaro Folgueiras, the Spanish sophomore returner, has been excellent. He’s doubled his scoring and rebounding and is now averaging a 12.6-point, 10.7-rebound double-double. The rebounding mark is a top-10 average in the country, and his defensive rebounding percentage of 31% is sixth nationally, per KenPom.
When you combine Folgueiras with Dickerson, who is second in the Horizon League with 47 blocks, the Colonials have a solid paint presence to go with some good guard play.
There’s talent there, and the Colonials have plenty of players who can be the top scoring option on any given night. There’s a path to a winning conference record, which hasn’t happened for Robert Morris since it left the Northeast Conference.
Why this year could be more of the same
Even with all the individual successes, it just hasn’t clicked for the Colonials. They have beaten most of the teams they’re expected to beat (with the exception of Detroit Mercy), but haven’t made the step up to play with the top — or even the middle — of the Horizon League.
KenPom shows some of Robert Morris’s issues. The Colonials have the nation’s 275th best offense (out of 364), and in their six conference games, they have the Horizon League’s third-worst offense. They struggle to find effective shots (46.5% effective field goal percentage, 306th nationally), shoot poorly, and make less than 30% of their 3-pointers.

But after the Cleveland State game, Toole was most upset with the defense. Wednesday’s defense, especially during the Vikings’ 27-7 run, was concerning. The Vikings shot 52% in the second half, 48% in the game, and scored 40 of their 80 points in the paint.
“You're supposed to be able to execute your defensive formula as like the price of admission,” Toole said. “That's supposed to be your responsibility.”
Toole was upset with recent efforts, too, calling them “a recipe for not fulfilling our potential as a team.” He pointed to the Cleveland State second half and the Detroit Mercy loss in particular.
“We should have enough understanding of the level that you need to be at and the things that are important to winning at this point in time,” Toole said. “We still fluctuate with that a little bit too much, in my opinion.”
Pointing at effort 17 games into the season is a concern, to say the least. It shows Toole knows his roster has talent.
But it isn’t just effort that he says needs to improve. Toole also included detail and “understanding of execution,” referencing a set play the Colonials ran three times against Cleveland State’s zone defense. Once, it worked for a 3. The other two times, Toole said, Robert Morris missed a player open for a layup.
“Those are some of the things you should know in your sleep,” Toole said.
There’s reason for confidence, but effort and defensive struggles are common threads for a program that’s struggled for the last five years. The Colonials have plenty of work to do.
What comes next
Robert Morris has another test Sunday when it hosts Wright State (9-8, 3-3), the team above it in the conference standings. It then travels to Green Bay, one of the nation’s worst teams. Two wins would give the Colonials momentum and get them back towards the top of the Horizon League, especially going into matchups with Milwaukee (11-6, 4-2) and Youngstown State (11-6, 6-1).
Toole’s goal each season is to compete for a championship, but the Colonials have finished at .500 just once in four full seasons since joining the Horizon League. The team has the potential to do better — but it needs to improve to get there.
“I think we have some of the things, some of the prerequisites, to becoming a good team,” Toole said. “At this point in time, we've got to see them more consistently.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.