Riverhounds SC and Steel City FC aren’t in the same league in more ways than one.

Steel City is a USL 2 amateur team that plays in the Great Forest Division while the Riverhounds are the reigning champion in USL Championship.

So, when the two took the pitch at Highmark Stadium in the first round of the Lamar Hunt U.S. Open Cup, it should have been a lopsided affair for the Riverhounds.

“No disrespect to Steel City, but I think if we would have played to our level, it would have been a very comfortable game,” Riverhounds coach Rob Vincent said. “We gave them too much respect on the ball.”

Advertise with us

When it was all said and done, the Riverhounds did what was expected and moved into the Round of 32. But Steel City stuck around a lot longer than the host would have liked.

Midfielder Danny Griffin scored 5:36 into the match and Charles Ahl added a much-needed insurance goal at 65:30 as the Riverhounds escaped their crosstown rivals Wednesday with a 2-1 victory.

“I think this is a million miles away from where we want to be. I’m really at a loss for words,” Vincent said. “I just think, from minute one, there was a lack of intensity. The one thing that we said was that we were going to have to drive the tempo and make it hard from them and we didn’t do any of that.”

It is the first time two Pittsburgh teams met in the Open Cup since the Harmarville Hurricanes defeated Morgan Strasser, 2-1, in the 1957 quarterfinals. It was also the first meeting between the two programs.

“We were excited with the performance and we were disappointed with the result,” Steel City coach Dan Brower said. “We pushed them and we pushed ourselves. They challenged our limits, physically and emotionally, and I think we gave the fans an exciting match.”

Advertise with us

Match flow

For the most part, the Riverhounds had the better of the play throughout.

Even after the Griffin goal, they had several opportunities in the first half, but Steel City goalkeeper Martin Dominguez turned aside most of the chances, including a wide-open left-footed blast from veteran Robbie Mertz, who was making his first start of the season, in the 34th minute.

Steel City had a few decent scoring opportunities in the second half and forced Riverhounds goalkeeper Nico Campuzano to stay alert in the one-goal game. But Ahl took some of the drama out of the match when he scored on a drive just six minutes after he subbed in.

And the Riverhounds needed that goal more than anyone could have imagined.

Steel City attacker Carlos Santamaria picked up a foul in the box from Owen Mikoy, which drew a penalty. Nicholas Graeca took the free kick and buried his shot low to the left of Campuzano to make it a 2-1 match at 75:05.

Advertise with us

Key stats

• The Riverhounds only held a 55-45 edge in possession at the intermission despite the 1-0 lead but had a decided edge in every other metric.

• The Riverhounds had an 8-1 edge in shots at the break, but Dominguez made four saves despite allowing the Griffin goal.

• This was the first official match at Highmark Stadium for the Riverhounds since they defeated Rhode Island FC in last season’s Eastern Conference finals on Nov. 16.

Quotable

“This was a chance to build some momentum at home, score some goals, get used to playing at Highmark again. I just think we missed an opportunity to take a big step forward.” — Vincent.

What it means

With the win the Riverhounds will host Virginia Dream in the next round of the Open Cup at 7 p.m. Tuesday. Prior to that, they will host Sporting Club Jacksonville in their official USL Championship home opener where they will raise both Eastern Conference and USL Championship title banners celebrating their 2025 run.