PISCATAWAY, N.J. — Saturday at SHI Stadium brought a matchup nobody would’ve imagined at the beginning of 2025.
It was a showdown between a pair of 5-6 teams in Penn State and Rutgers, with the contest being the difference between qualifying for a bowl game or having the season come to a close.
In a game that had postseason implications on the line, it was the Nittany Lions emerging victorious 40-36.
“It meant a lot for this team,” running back Nick Singleton said. “Just shows the adversity we've been through, and we never stopped fighting.”
There was scoring early and often, as the opening frame concluded with a 14-14 score after 401 yards of total offense between the two sides.
Rutgers cashed in to start via a 19-yard rushing score from tailback Antwan Raymond to open up the scoring, but tight end Andrew Rappleyea hauled in a 53-yard touchdown from quarterback Ethan Grunkemeyer on a 4th-and-1 to answer for Penn State.
Read More
Next, it was Singleton, who scored on an 11-yard run to break Saquon Barkley’s program record for most total touchdowns, as well as rushing scores, with 54 and 44, respectively. Rutgers quarterback Athan Kaliakmanis ran for a 2-yard touchdown to tie it up and conclude the scoring in the first quarter.
Penn State scored on the first play of the second frame, as running back Kaytron Allen trotted in on a 15-yard running score. He eclipsed 4,000 career rushing yards in the first quarter, becoming the first player in program history to do so, as well as notching his 13th game at Penn State with more than 100 yards on the ground.
“We're gonna do this together all the way to the end,” Allen said of his relationship with Singleton. “I'm glad he was here, man, because we both feed off each other. Both learn from each other things like that — on field, off the field. That's my dog.”
Over 14 minutes went by without a score, but then each side added to its tally. Kaliakmanis found wide receiver DT Sheffield for a 21-yard touchdown to knot things up at 21-21, while Penn State regained its lead after marching down the field in 26 seconds, capping it off with a 31-yard field goal from kicker Ryan Barker to take the 24-21 advantage into the halftime break.
Coming out of the locker room, there were four straight scores.
It started with Barker connecting on a 29-yard field goal, which was followed up by Rutgers answering with a 13-yard touchdown reception from wide receiver KJ Duff. Penn State then answered, as a 43-yard run by Allen set up a 1-yard plunge by Singleton, taking a 33-28 lead after an unsuccessful two-point conversion attempt.
Then Rutgers came storming back, as Raymond was uncovered on a wheel route, scoring on a 46-yard grab. The two-point conversion try was successful, as Duff hauled in a pass in the back-left corner of the end zone to give the Scarlet Knights a 36-33 lead.
Rutgers was moving the ball methodically once again after a Penn State punt, but linebacker Amare Campbell recovered a fumble from Kaliakmanis, taking it to the house for a 61-yard touchdown to take the 40-36 lead.
“Ball right there, scoop and score,” Campbell said. “That's all I was thinking. So the ball ended up in my lap. Pick it up, scoop and score, try not to get tackled.”
After Duff made a wild one-handed grab to put Rutgers into Penn State territory, the Nittany Lions forced a turnover on downs to regain possession.
A costly defensive holding call on Rutgers on what would’ve been a 3rd-and-26 gave Penn State a first down, which then resulted in a 50-yard run from Allen.
A pickup from Rappleyea on 4th-and-2 iced the game, giving Penn State a 40-36 win and to make it bowl eligible.
“We ended it on our terms, so that was fantastic,” interim coach Terry Smith said.
By the numbers
Singleton and Allen continued their historical senior years with a dominant showing in what could be their final time lacing up for the Blue and White.
In a game when Singleton broke a trio of Barkley’s records and Allen became the program’s first 4,000-yard rusher, the duo combined for 312 yards and three touchdowns.
“One of them could have transferred. One of them could have went somewhere and been the guy,” Smith said. “For them to stay with us speaks volumes about Penn State in itself. Just super proud of those guys.”
Quotable
This was Smith’s last game as interim coach.
Who knows what’s in store for his future at Penn State? Whether he’s next the coach or even on staff at all, he was able to reflect on the experience leading the charge.
“It taught me the role of one of the biggest jobs in college football and it taught me that I have a special bond with people and my players,” Smith said. “And that when I go forward in coaching, I have to take advantage of that.”
Up next
Penn State will await its future as to where it plays its next game, with Selection Sunday set for Dec. 6. The Pinstripe Bowl, Las Vegas Bowl and GameAbove Sports Bowl are all options in play.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.