UNIVERSITY PARK, PA. — After a grueling loss to No. 1 Ohio State, Penn State attempted to make a stand against Indiana, the No. 2 team in the country and prove there’s still some resemblance of what it once was.
However, despite the numbers being in the Nittany Lion’s favor with an all-time home record of 13-0 versus the Hoosiers, they came up just a few plays short and Indiana walked out of Happy Valley with a 27-24 victory and its first win in Beaver Stadium in program history.
“I'm super proud of the effort that our guys put out there. These guys play hard. I feel awful for them. They do everything we ask of them, and we just keep coming up short,” Interim head coach Terry Smith said. “We have to hit the reset button again tomorrow and continue to figure out how to win a game.”
The opening drive went as well for the Nittany Lions as anybody could ask, limiting the Hoosiers to a three-and-out and getting the ball in their hands just over two minutes into the first quarter. Redshirt freshman Ethan Grunkemeyer connected with Trebor Pena for his first completion of the day and Kaytron Allen powered through contact to secure the first down.
The slow-start label continued to stick with the Nittany Lions though, as Grunkemeyer failed to connect on his next two pass attempts and they were forced to punt.
Penn State’s defense held strong, allowing just a six-play drive behind linebacker Dom DeLuca’s three-yard tackle for loss against running back Kaelon Black and two tackles from linebacker Amare Campbell.
The momentum shifted after Penn State failed to generate any up-field movement on its next drive and Hoosiers quarterback Fernando Mendoza connected with wide receiver Charlie Becker for a 53-yard bomb, then ran it 18 yards into the end zone himself two plays later to put Indiana up 7-0 toward the end of the first.
The junior quarterback numbers didn’t jump off the stat sheet — 218 yards, two total touchdowns and an interception — but Smith praised the Heisman candidate for being the reason Indiana was able to win.
“Their quarterback’s big time,” Smith said of Mendoza. “When you get in games like this, you have to have players that make plays to win games, and he won the game for them. He was amazing. He's tough. He hit him relentlessly the entire game, and he kept getting up. He delivered throws. You could say they were lucky, but he kept doing it time after time.”
It didn’t take long for the Nittany Lions to fire back, scoring a touchdown on the very next drive that started with a 43-yard catch by Pena, the longest reception for Penn State in its past three games. The offense found its groove with running back Nick Singleton rushing for eight yards down the middle and then powering through on the next two plays to score the Nittany Lions’ first touchdown of the day and even things up at 7-7.
The senior running back had his best performance of the year, ending with 93 total yards and three touchdowns.
What started as a defensive battle between the two Big Ten teams quickly transitioned to a high-octane contest of offense as the Hoosiers refused to let Singleton’s touchdown go unanswered.
Mendoza connected with tight end Riley Nowakowski for a short seven-yard pass, and Black continued to find openings in the Nittany Lions’ defensive line.
Defensive end Dani Dennis-Sutton made his presence known, securing a sack for a five-yard loss on Mendoza, his first since Week 2 against Florida International, but a holding call overturned it and resulted in an automatic first down for Indiana.
The Hoosiers continued to methodically move the ball up the field until true freshman Daryus Dixson made up for Dennis-Sutton’s overturned sack with one of his own that resulted in a forced fumble that was recovered by Mendoza and a seven-yard loss.
On the next play, a false start was called on Indiana for a five-yard penalty, but Mendoza connected with wide receiver Omar Cooper Jr. to put his team in ideal field goal range and took the lead 10-7 after a 28-yard kick by Nicolas Radicic.
The tides began to further shift in favor of Indiana after forcing a fumble on Allen at the Nittany Lions’ 23-yard line that was recovered by Jamari Sharpe. Then, on the very first play of the Hoosiers drive, Penn State safety King Mack was called for pass interference, which they capitalized on after Mendoza connected with Becker at the goal line. Black made sure to finish the first half on a high note, punching it in for his first touchdown of the day and giving the Hoosiers a 17-7 lead at the end of the second quarter.
The second half commenced and after an incompletion to Devonte Ross, Grunkemeyer’s pass attempt to Kyron Hudson in tight coverage was deflected and bounced up before being intercepted by Sharpe.
Penn State prevented Indiana from reaching the end zone behind a QB hurry from defensive tackle Zane Durant that forced an incompletion and a quick tackle from corner Zion Tracy on Cooper Jr. but Radicic still hit the field goal from 31 yards to widen the lead 20-7.
The redshirt freshman made sure to stay calm and collected despite his mistake and followed up with two 20-plus yard passes to Pena and true freshman Koby Howard.
“I thought he grew up in the second half,” Smith said of Grunkemeyer. “Obviously coming out of halftime, we threw the interception, but he bounced right back. He started making some good throws. He gave us a chance to win. He led us back. I thought he was big time, and, you know, just looking forward to him, you know, continuing to get better and continuing to develop.”
Grunkemeyer connected with Howard for another six-yard gain but faced pressure from defensive lineman Mikail Kamara on third down, forcing the Nittany Lions to settle for a 36-yard field goal from Ryan Barker that brought them within 10 points.
Penn State managed to hold off Indiana’s passing attack on the next drive that trickled into the start of the fourth quarter, which ended with an incompletion on a deep pass from Mendoza to Becker.
Grunkemeyer connected with Pena on another deep pass down the middle for 20 yards and then Singleton bursted down field for a 59-yard run, his longest of the season, and then into the red zone for his second touchdown of the day.
With the ball confidently in Penn State’s court at this point, it only further drove home the fact that this game was far from over after Mack kicked it into overdrive to intercept Mendoza’s pass intended for Cooper Jr. Allen found his groove and slowly but surely, found holes to penetrate in the Hoosiers defense. Penn State got its first lead of the day behind Singleton’s 19-yard reception that resulted in his third touchdown and Grunkemeyer’s first passing touchdown as a starter.
Invigorated by the electric environment in Beaver Stadium and on the cusp of overcoming the second best team in the nation, the Nittany Lions finally seemed to put everything together.
Dennis-Sutton effortlessly sliced through Indiana’s offensive line to record his first official sack of the game and after a QB hurry by defensive end Zuriah Fisher, the ball was back in their hands on offense.
Allen tried to break through a cornered Indiana defense but it held strong, forcing Penn State to punt after six plays.
Then the Nittany Lions’ defense that forced Mendoza to take a third sack, this time by Durant who powered through the middle.
However, Mendoza proved why he’s one of the best quarterbacks in college football, leading the Hoosiers to a 10 play-80 yard drive that ended in a touchdown to Cooper Jr. in the back of the end zone and inevitably, a win for Indiana after Penn State failed to convert on the hail mary to Ross.
Notable stats
Total yards: Penn State 336, Indiana 326
Time of possession: Penn State 28:47, Indiana 30:37
1st downs: Penn State 17, Indiana 19
3rd downs: Penn State 8-15, Indiana 5-12
Injury report
• Quarterback Drew Allar and linebacker Tony Rojas remain out with season ending injuries.
• Defensive tackle Sam Siafa and defensive end Chaz Coleman are the latest addition to the injury report, listed as out against Indiana.
Notes
• Running back Kaytron Allen is now Penn State’s all time leader in rushing attempts, passing Evan Royster.
• Cornerback A.J Harris and linebacker Campbell led the team in total tackles, with eight a piece
• Safety Mack recorded his first career interception
Up next
The Nittany Lions will head to Spartan Stadium in East Lansing, Mich. to take on Michigan State at 3:30 p.m. next Saturday.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.