It wasn’t exactly like the firing of James Franklin, but Penn State’s new interim football coach knows what it’s like to be pushed out of a job.
Penn State named Terry Smith interim coach Sunday, putting in charge a man who was once a standout player in the WPIAL and cut his coaching teeth at Gateway in Monroeville. Smith, promoted from Penn State’s associate head coach, was Gateway’s coach for 11 seasons from 2002-12. He enjoyed huge success, bringing glory back to a once-prominent program that had begun a downward slide. Smith was 101-30 in his 11 seasons, won seven conference titles and made it to a WPIAL title game four times.
Smith was also Gateway’s athletic director, and in the summer of 2012, the Gateway school board made the athletic director job a part-time position and slashed Smith’s contract in half. Then the board passed a resolution that an administrator could not have a supplemental contract, which meant Smith couldn’t be AD and coach. If the board didn’t pass such a resolution, Smith probably wouldn’t be Penn State’s coach today.
Smith never made the decision between AD and coach at Gateway because in January 2013, he accepted an assistant coaching job at Temple. If he didn’t leave for Temple, Franklin might have never hired him at Penn State as an assistant coach after only one season in Philadelphia.
“I understand the politics and how it works,” Smith told the Post-Gazette in 2013 after taking the Temple job. “I grew up in Monroeville. ... They pushed me out of the nest, and now my wings are open and I realize there is a bigger world and far greater opportunities ahead for me. I never applied to Temple. They came to me. This is something I always wanted to do, but I didn't know if I would ever get the opportunity to do it."
Now Smith gets the opportunity to take over the team at his collegiate alma mater, where he played as a receiver and once set a single-season record for receptions, then became the defensive backs coach and an ace recruiter in Western Pennsylvania. It is certainly not an easy situation Smith inherits, with Penn State going 3-3 after such high expectations at the start of the season.
Read More
This was to be bittersweet for Smith. He and Franklin were close. Over the years, Franklin would make recruiting trips to WPIAL games on Friday nights, arriving at stadiums by helicopter to watch games involving players Penn State was recruiting. Smith was also on the helicopter and would watch the game from the field by Franklin’s side.

Justin King is Smith’s son and starred for his dad at Gateway. King went on play defensive back at Penn State under Joe Paterno, then in the NFL. King spent a few years as Penn State’s recruiting coordinator and spoke with Smith on Sunday.
“He’s getting his footing. It’s kind of like being thrust into the presidency,” King said. “I can’t speak for him, but I think any opportunity as a coach in a highly competitive profession, where you get a change at a school like Penn State that is your alma mater, there is natural excitement. Obviously, the guy that gave you a chance to go back to your alma mater getting fired does stink. But as a player or coach, you’ve got to make the best move and the next move. I’m sure that’s [Smith’s] message to the team — and himself.”
Cam Saddler was a standout player for Smith at Gateway, making the 2007 Post-Gazette Fabulous 22 before going on to play at Pitt. Saddler was only 5-foot-7, similar in size to Smith, who was a 5-foot-9 senior at Gateway when he played quarterback and defensive back. Saddler still stays in touch with Smith at times.
“I don’t know what’s going to happen at Penn State, but one thing I know about coach T is that the players will be on his side,” Saddler said. “I don’t know if he’ll change the offensive play caller or what. But I know his kids will show up Saturday because he will put enough gasoline on them during the week that they will come out on fire and play hard.
“That’s what he does and always did — get the best out of guys. He’s almost the perfect person for this type of situation.”
Smith the player
Smith was involved in two of the greatest championship games in WPIAL history — as a player and a coach. In 1986, playing for legendary coach Pete Antimarino, Smith was the quarterback of a Gateway team that played North Hills for the Class 4A championship in a game that drew what has to be one of the largest crowds — if not the largest crowd — in WPIAL history. Both teams were undefeated and tied in the WPIAL title game the year before. USA Today moved North Hills to No. 1 in the national rankings the week before the championship.
A crowd estimated at more than 20,000 filled the entire lower bowl at Three Rivers Stadium. The game was scoreless until Smith scored on a 1-yard run with 6:15 left in the game and Bill Truschel kicked the extra point. North Hills scored a touchdown with two seconds remaining. Back then, there was no overtime in high school games. North Hills wanted to finish the season ranked No. 1 in the country, so the Indians tried for a two-point conversion. But a pass was intercepted, Gateway won 7-6 and finished ranked No. 3 in the country.
Smith made the Fabulous 22 and was selected to play in the prestigious Big 33 All-Star game. Despite his size, his speed and playmaking ability attracted some major colleges, which wanted to switch him to receiver. Smith chose Penn State, but Pitt and West Virginia were also among his finalists.
Smith had an excellent career at receiver for Penn State, catching a school-record 55 passes one season.
The Washington Redskins selected Smith in the 11th round of the 1992 NFL draft, but he went on to play three seasons in the Canadian Football League.
Smith also was a standout basketball player at Gateway, averaging 17 points per game, and was selected to play in the preliminary game of the prestigious Dapper Dan Roundball Classic. He was selected to the WPIAL Hall of Fame in 2018.
Smith the coach
Smith was an assistant at Hempfield for one season and then spent a few years on Greg Gattuso’s staff at Duquesne. Gattuso is a senior defensive analyst currently on Penn State’s staff.
Smith made a name for himself as Gateway’s coach. The Gators had a 19-31 record in the five years before Smith took over, but Smith took the Gators to the WPIAL playoffs in all 11 of his seasons. The Gators just couldn’t win a WPIAL title.
Under Smith, Gateway became known as a place that produced major-college players. In his tenure, Smith sent 23 players to NCAA Division I-A (now FBS) colleges and 17 more to 1-AA (now FCS). In 2007, Smith was Gateway’s coach in a terrific WPIAL final that went to overtime before Gateway lost to Central Catholic 35-34. Gateway tied the game at the end of regulation with a touchdown on the final play when Smith used a play he called “Our Father” instead of “Hail Mary.” It was a hook-and-ladder play that went for a touchdown.
Smith has coached defensive backs at Penn State for a number of years, and some of those Nittany Lions have made the NFL.
“He had a system where he was an individualist type of coach,” said King, who played running back and defensive back at Gateway. “He wanted you to make plays and for you to dominate. He tailored everything to the players. ... When he got to Gateway, winning championships was on the docket, but his approach was more to get kids to colleges. He wanted to highlight individuals. He felt you win on the backs of individuals.
“I’m not saying he didn’t coach the team. But he made individuals realize you have to bring your individual best to the table. Individuals make a team. That’s different than a lot of coaches, but I think that’s what made him such a great recruiter for college.
“I think he’s always been the type of guy to be where your feet are. While at Gateway, his goal was to make Gateway a powerhouse but also to get kids to college. As a college recruiter, I don’t think he was a car salesman type of recruiter, but I think he sold a dream. ... I played for some Hall of Fame coaches, like Joe Paterno. I’ve seen the gamut, but he’s always been one of the best coaches I’ve ever played for in terms of developing the individual.”
Saddler said, “When I was in high school, I walked around like I was the best. That’s something that Terry put in me. He told me to be braggadocious. He instilled this confidence in me and got the best out of me. I think that’s what he’ll do now with these guys [at Penn State}.”
Mike White: mwhite@post-gazette.com and @mwhiteburgh on X.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.