“Speculation,” “rumors,” and “reports” are different words with different meanings. In an ideal college football-media ecosystem, those words and meanings would not be conflated to the point that we get useless repartee like this in news conferences.

That was Penn State’s James Franklin going back and forth during his Big Ten coaches teleconference Tuesday with an individual who illustrates quite perfectly how far we are from living in that world.

Franklin’s name has, in fact, surfaced in prominent speculation about potential successors to Clay Helton at Southern California should he be fired amid the Trojans’ disappointing season.  ESPN’s Adam Rittenberg, Yahoo! Sports’ Pete Thamel and the Athletic’s Bruce Feldman and Stewart Mandel have all thrown Franklin’s name around in writing or on podcasts since USC’s damaging loss to rival UCLA on Saturday.

Those are some heavy hitters whose words you should take seriously. They’re plugged into news sources from coast to coast and not pulling names out of hats when they talk about potential job openings. If they’re all zeroing in on the same guy, it’s a pretty good sign that they’re really not messing around.

Advertise with us

They’re also not reporting anything. Not that Helton will definitely be fired. Not that Franklin has been in contact with the Trojan program. Not even that some fat-cat donor is sending smoke signals about a preference for Franklin from his or her yacht in Newport Harbor.

To put a point on it, there is no news there, which is why it was rather silly that Franklin was so pointedly put on the spot about the possibility of leaving Penn State for a job that isn’t even open yet. Earlier in the day, a beat reporter asked about the speculation more artfully.

“Do you know about how the speculation between you and the USC job got started, and how would you like to address it?”

The answer? Poorly.

It was a response as wishy washy as the one he gave on the teleconference later. An answer that is, in fact, news because it’s nowhere close to the boilerplate denial coaches tend to give to protect their current programs, even if they do have interest in another. It was so bad that he had to clean it up on a third attempt at the answer Wednesday evening.

Advertise with us

“In an attempt yesterday — a failed attempt— to try to keep the focus on Maryland, I got asked a question yesterday about another school,” Franklin said. “I tried to keep the focus on Maryland, like I always do. The next opponent. That didn’t go over very well, so ... I didn’t feel it was appropriate to talk about another school or another person’s job status. That’s why I addressed it the way I did. Obviously, I have all the plans in the world to be here and be here for a long time.”

Fair enough. Let’s take him at his word for now, but let’s also acknowledge that Franklin would be a good fit in the Southland, for plenty of reasons.

The most obvious is his media savvy. In a city with endless entertainment options that’s buzzing about the success of the NFL’s Rams, Franklin could offer the engaging personality necessary to get the Trojans back in the local conversation, let alone the national one.

He’d also probably be a menace on the recruiting trail. Just look at the job he’s done at Penn State, drawing loaded classes to isolated Happy Valley. Imagine how those talents would play in one of the most fertile talent grounds in country. It’s not hard to picture him barnstorming through Los Angeles, Riverside and Orange counties en route to signing top-five classes annually.

And competitively, USC’s Pac-12 Conference South Division is nowhere near the meat grinder that Penn State’s Big Ten East is. Instead of Ohio State, Michigan State and Michigan, Franklin’s biggest threats would be Utah, Colorado and UCLA. There’s no comparison.

Advertise with us

Throw in that lovely Mediterranean climate and the Land of Troy just looks like a more desirable job for a man who’s well suited for it.

That doesn’t mean he’s going anywhere. Athletic director Lynn Swann, the former Steelers great, could have just as many reasons to go in another direction. The biggest might be money. Franklin signed a substantial extension at Penn State last year, and Helton’s pay pales in comparison. Swann may look at the Nittany Lions’ disappointments in big games the past couple years, including a collapse against his Trojans in the Rose Bowl, and decide Franklin isn’t worth the pay he’d likely demand.

For now, though, the dots are there to connect. Some prominent pundits have done it. Take that for what it is: something a little more complicated than a yes-or-no question.

Post-Gazette staff writer Dave Molinari contributed from State College. Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @fugimaster24.