“You can’t take the ball out of Trace McSorley’s hands in that situation.”

That was the canned criticism parroted far and wide after Penn State’s disastrous fourth-and-5 play that ruined its comeback bid Sept. 29 against Ohio State.

A fundamental misunderstanding of the way the Nittany Lions’ offense works surfaced in different forms as what was once college football’s highest-scoring unit has sputtered over the past month.

For example, James Franklin was asked at his weekly news conference Tuesday if McSorley was getting more carries — 18 per game in the last four games — because defenses are “keying” on running back Miles Sanders. The coach responded with a point that should be obvious nearly three years into Penn State’s heavy use of run/pass options, or RPOs, and zone-read running plays engineered by former coordinator and current Mississippi State head coach Joe Moorhead.

Advertise with us

“I think sometimes there's a misconception that we are running Trace more or that we are using Tommy [Stevens] as a decoy or things like that. We really don't do that. If Tommy is in the game he's part of the read, and the defense will determine whether he gets the ball or not.

“Most of Trace's runs are going to come from one of two things. It's either a scramble off of a normal pass play or it's some type of read where it's a zone read or some type of RPO. It's not necessarily that we go into the game saying Trace is going to run the ball this many times or we're going to throw the ball to this guy. Our offense doesn't really run like that.”

Let’s repeat some words for emphasis here. Run/pass options. Zone reads. These are play calls on which McSorley makes a decision about where the ball goes based on how the defenders set up and/or react at the snap.

A large chunk of the offense is based on these plays, so it’s rare that coordinator Ricky Rahne is calling things “for” individuals in the traditional sense. There may be a preference for where the ball ends up, but Andrew Breiner, Moorhead’s passing game coordinator in Starkville and former protege in the Fordham incubator where the offense was hatched, explained things pretty clinically in an oral history of the system published by Sports Illustrated last year.

“It’s a pretty simplistic scheme. We have our six in the box (five O-Linemen and the tight end) are gonna block your six and then we’re going to tag a run-pass option to it, so if you’re trying to add the seventh or eighth defender to the box, we’re essentially going to make you wrong with a throw. And, because we have run it so much our kids are really confident in it.”

The same logic applies to straight run calls, where McSorley often reads a defender’s reaction at the snap to determine whether he hands the ball off to a back or keeps it himself.

This is a long way of saying that McSorley was in charge of that play against Ohio State. The ball went to Sanders not because that outcome was predetermined, but because McSorley thought that was the correct read based on the defense.

This is a short way of saying that McSorley’s surge in carries is symptomatic of some larger problems that have surfaced over the last few weeks.

Advertise with us

The biggest: receivers frequently aren’t open, and Penn State is not making defenses wrong with the throw. Just two Penn State receivers have more than 20 receptions, with K.J. Hamler leading the way at just 22. Often, this forces McSorley to improvise with his feet.

He’s pretty good at it. His 554 rushing yards through seven games already shatters his career high of 491 set last season. Against Ohio State, it led to him amassing an obscene 461 scrimmage yards.

It also led to Penn State’s worst scoring effort of the season, before that honor went to the Michigan State loss two weeks later. As Franklin pointed out in his answer to the same question, there’s a reason it hasn’t been enough.

“Yeah, I think in general my concern right now is Trace is carrying too much of the load on offense. That's something that we need to do a better job of. We need more players having a bigger impact on the game on offense. So that's probably my biggest concern.”

More specifically, the receivers aren’t allowing the offense to work as designed. Even when they do get open, they’re dropping a ton of passes. (Pro Football Focus noted after the Michigan State game, McSorley has the highest drop rate of any Power Five conference quarterback.)

It’s only because McSorley is such a dynamic player that Penn State has almost overcome those struggles anyway. And even when he salvages plays with his feet, it can sometimes play into what the defense wants.  They know Penn State wants to beat them with the throw, so stopping the Nittany Lions is a matter of forcing McSorley to consistently choose the option that’s less painful, often scrambling underneath.

Advertise with us

This is where some of the blame falls on Rahne, too. He can’t make his receivers catch the ball, but if he’s too predictable, defenses can force McSorley into selecting secondary options and live to fight another down.

It happened all night against Ohio State and especially against Michigan State. Penn State hit some big plays and even outgained the Buckeyes, but it was clear McSorley was being boxed into choosing the lesser evils frequently.

He isn’t at his best when he’s settling, so no, those 18 carries per game probably aren’t part of the plan. Neither is a situation where he needs to make the right read on fourth-and-5 to keep a game-winning drive going against Ohio State.

Penn State’s problem isn’t that it’s calling plays for the wrong guys. It’s that its quarterback needs better options. If he had them, that game may not have come down to fourth-and-5 in the first place.

Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @fugimaster24.