BLOOMINGTON, Ind. — Penn State coach James Franklin knew going into the season that there were some significant uncertainties about his team.

How the Nittany Lions would replace the eight starters who were gone from their defense in 2017, for example.

It seems unlikely, though, that Blake Gillikin’s punting or the reliability of Penn State’s veteran receivers were on the list. But, after the Nittany Lions’ 33-28 victory Saturday at Indiana, Franklin expressed his unhappiness with both.

“We’re not punting the ball very well right now,” he said. “That was something that, coming into the season, we thought was going to be a real strength for us, and it has not been, up to this point.”

Advertise with us

Gillikin punted six times for 241 yards, an average of 40.2, against the Hoosiers. For the season, he has 35 punts, for an average of 42.4 yards.

It was a bit of a surprise that Franklin singled out Gillikin for criticism. Gillikin might not be performing to the lofty standard he set in the previous two seasons, but punting hasn’t been one of the most glaring problem areas for Penn State (5-2) in its first seven games.

Certainly, it hasn’t been as conspicuous as the receivers’ frequent inability to hold onto quarterback Trace McSorley’s passes. They had at least five more drops Saturday, and are averaging between three and four per game.

Juwan Johnson and DeAndre Thompkins, Penn State’s most experienced receivers, have been responsible for the bulk of those, which might explain why freshmen Justin Shorter, Daniel George and Jahan Dotson were on the travel squad for the Indiana game.

Dotson and George actually played against the Hoosiers, and Dotson picked up 10 yards on his first career reception.

Advertise with us

“It’s nice to see some of those other guys go in and do a pretty good job for us,” Franklin said.

It won’t be a shock if they get more chances to do that in the near future; Franklin said such decisions are made weekly, based on evaluations of game videos and practice performances.

Regardless of who is filling those roles, there’s no question Penn State’s offense tends to sputter when the receivers are unable to hold onto passes that hit them in the hands.

“When we catch the ball, we’re in rhythm and we make plays and we move the ball down the field, pretty much on anybody,” Franklin said. “When we’re inconsistent catching the ball, we have a hard time getting into a rhythm and moving the ball consistently.”

Whether Johnson will be involved against the Iowa Hawkeyes isn’t clear. He did not play after a 59-yard catch-and-run in the first half at Indiana.

Advertise with us

Franklin suggested that Johnson wasn’t his only player to be injured, to some degree, Saturday — “In my five years, since I’ve been here, we haven’t had that many guys knocked out of the game, whether it’s ankles or hamstrings or whatever it might be” — but didn’t offer any specifics.

Safety Garrett Taylor isn’t injured but will sit out the first two quarters of the Iowa game after being penalized Saturday for targeting. Jonathan Sutherland replaced him at Indiana, and figures to do so again Saturday.

Sutherland forced a fumble against the Hoosiers, one of Penn State’s three takeaways.

“To get those turnovers was huge for our confidence, huge for getting the ball back in our offense’s hands,” cornerback Amani Oruwariye said.

Penn State transformed those takeaways into 10 points, more than its margin of victory.

Advertise with us

And despite the issues that arose — or resurfaced — Saturday, the bottom line for the Nittany Lions was that pulling out of a two-game losing skid did wonders for their psyches.

“It was great for our morale, confidence, everything like that,” safety Nick Scott said. “We’re going to use this to fuel us for the last half of the season.”

Dave Molinari: Dmolinari@Post-Gazette.com and Twitter @MolinariPG.