In the digital age, we don’t get much physical reader mail in the Post-Gazette sports department. Sure, we receive your thoughtful emails and polite phone calls, but it’s rare that we’re pulling out our letter openers for feedback.

You can imagine our surprise, then, when we received an envelope a couple of weeks ago containing two pieces of paper.

One was a brief letter. “Can you put this poll in the newspaper? It’s for the NCAA football. From William and John Whitman,” 10 and 8 years old, respectively.  The second paper was a full ranking of the top 25 teams in college football, dubbed the “BW Poll.”

The Week 6 "BW Poll" submitted by the Whitman family of Upper St. Clair.

We needed to know more. Unfortunately, the boys didn’t leave any contact information, and attempts to reach them through reverse phone book listings were unsuccessful.

Advertise with us

Undaunted, the boys reached out again this week with a second poll that added sister Sophia, 11, as a voting member. “This is our second try, and we hope it makes it in the newspaper.”

The Week 7 BW Poll.

Say no more. Armed with a phone number this time, we reached out to the Upper St. Clair family headed by mother, Lisa, and father, Bill. The latter convened a Thursday morning roundtable to answer our questions about the polls. Here’s a summary, with some interjections from the voters:

1. What was the inspiration for your poll?

Bill: “John was very interested in college football polls every week. ... When I was a kid, I did a poll every week for years and named it the BW poll to go up against the Associated Press and UPI polls. I sent it to the Memphis newspaper hoping it would get published. It never did. The kids decided to do the same and hoped they could get it published. They decided to keep the same name — the BW poll.

2. What is your methodology? How do you determine where to rank each team?

Advertise with us

Bill: We wake up early every Sunday morning — way before mom and dad. John looks at both ESPN.com and the Post-Gazette sports page and see how the teams did and drops teams that lose. The three of [them] talk about the teams and we then rank, while watching some cartoons or cooking shows.

Sophia: “Sometimes we keep stuff the same and sometimes we change stuff.”

3. We noticed Sophia was added as a voter in the second poll. How have her views shaped the rankings?

Bill: Sophia wakes up later so she’s not always in the discussion. But, she is a good voter and has great opinions and was one of the reasons Notre Dame got bumped up to No. 3 this past week.

4. Is there a favorite team in the family? Or do the individual voters each have different favorites?

Advertise with us

William: “Notre Dame, of course.” Favorite local team? Penn State.

5. Have to ask you about the local teams. We'll start with Penn State. They were unranked in the first poll we received but jumped to No. 13 in the second poll despite the loss to Michigan State. What was the thinking there?

William: “We forgot about them.”

John: “Penn State had a bye week, so nothing that said Penn State was on NCAA football, so I completely forget them. We realized it after we had finished, but the poll was in pen and it would have been too much work to do over.”

Sophia: “Why do you do it in pen? You should do it in pencil.”

Advertise with us

6. Was Pitt ever in consideration for inclusion in the poll?

Bill: No. (Bill follow-up question: Even after Pitt should have beaten Notre Dame? William: “No. They still lost. A loss is a loss.”)

7. We noticed you still have Georgia ahead of LSU despite the Tigers' head-to-head victory over the Bulldogs last weekend. What was the thinking there?

William: “We still think Georgia is good. Georgia lost to a better team.”

John: “LSU already lost to Florida and we think Georgia is really good, and played one bad game.” (That said, from Bill: John looked quizzically about this question and I think realizes LSU should be higher than Georgia. The gang for whatever reason is very bullish on Georgia — see answer to question No. 9 below. I will say our family is not a fan of Alabama, so I think everyone is hopeful Georgia can beat them. We would be thrilled as well if LSU can do that.)

Advertise with us

8. What team do the voters find the most overrated? Underrated?

Unanimous: Clemson is overrated. “Have not played anybody.”

Underrated: Florida, Cincinnati, Oregon.

9. OK, prediction time: Which teams will make the College Football Playoff? And which will win it all? Why?

The consensus picks: Ohio State, Notre Dame, Georgia, and Alabama will make the playoff. Everyone thinks Ohio State will win the title.

Advertise with us

William: “Ohio State seems to play the best.”

Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @fugimaster24. 

Do you appreciate good journalism? If you do, consider subscribing.

Support journalism. Subscribe today.