UNIVERSITY PARK, Pa. — There’s an adage that football teams tend to show their greatest improvement between the first and second games.

If so, the Penn State squad that faces Pitt at 8 p.m. Saturday at Heinz Field might be significantly better than the one that eked out a 45-38 overtime victory against Appalachian State in the opener, if only because the Nittany Lions left so much room to upgrade their play.

“We have a lot of things that we need to get cleaned up and corrected before our next game,” coach James Franklin said.

Sure, Penn State had commendable focus and execution in the closing minutes of regulation and overtime, driving 48 yards for a tying score in the final minute of the fourth quarter, then clinching the victory with a Miles Sanders touchdown run and an Amani Oruwariye interception in overtime. But they needed such heroics because it yielded 28 points in the final quarter, the last 21 of those unanswered.

Advertise with us

Before the game, Nittany Lions coaches and players had embraced the mantra that the Mountaineers were a dangerous opponent, worthy of genuine respect and fully capable of winning.

And while Appalachian State’s performance spawned even more lavish praise afterward, many of Penn State’s problems were self-inflicted, the byproduct of sloppy execution or poor attention to detail.

There was the 100-yard kickoff return by Appalachian State’s Darrynton Evans after Penn State drove 75 yards for a touchdown on its first possession. A fourth-quarter onside kick the Nittany Lions failed to recover, and the offense sputtered through much of the first half. The Mountaineers offense shredded their defense for four touchdowns in the final 13-plus minutes of regulation.

If such issues go uncorrected, Penn State will be far more likely to finish the season competing in some mid-level bowl rather than the College Football Playoff.

The first red flag began flapping just over three minutes into the game, when Evans made his length-of-the-field dash.

Advertise with us

“I just started running,” he said. “I saw a hole and was like, ‘You’ve got to be kidding me.’”

Phil Galiano, Penn State’s first-year special-teams coach, presumably had a similar reaction, perhaps peppered with a few pungent modifiers.

Galiano likely uttered a couple of more in the fourth quarter when, after the Mountaineers had pulled to within a touchdown, they turbo-charged their momentum by recovering that onside kick.

Four plays later, Appalachian State tied the score.

A little more than four minutes after that, it grabbed the lead.

Advertise with us

But special-teams blunders were not solely responsible for Penn State’s near-death experience. There was subpar blocking, at times, by the offensive line, as well as the receivers, who also dropped several catchable balls.

And then there was the secondary that Appalachian State quarterback Zac Thomas, who began the day with 10 collegiate passes on his resume, dissected for 25 completions on 38 throws, good for 270 yards and two touchdowns.

“As the game went on, we realized we could really throw on this team,” Thomas said.

His passing helped the Mountaineers finish with a 451-434 edge in total yardage.

“There are … some things that we need to correct and work on as a defense,” Penn State linebacker Jan Johnson said.

Advertise with us

Franklin said after the game, “we’ll critique the heck out of” the game video, and some staff members might have been tempted to wash their eyes out with bleach after studying it.

“We definitely have a lot of film to watch to clean up,” Oruwariye said. “But it’s a learning process.”

Saturday night, the Nittany Lions will have a chance to show which lessons, if any, they’ve absorbed.

Dave Molinari: Dmolinari@Post-Gazette.com and Twitter @MolinariPG.