UNIVERSITY PARK Pa. — So apparently there is a gray area meriting discussion.
Despite what Penn State coach James Franklin said after the 49-10 loss Saturday against Michigan, in which redshirt junior linebacker Brandon Smith was ejected early in the second quarter for targeting, the Big Ten Conference released a statement Wednesday saying the replay official made the wrong decision.
“We do not find fault with the flag that was thrown by the on-field officials, as they are instructed to prioritize player safety when making calls,” the statement read. “Targeting occurs when a player takes aim at an opponent, whether the crown of the helmet is used to make forcible contact to the head or neck area of a defenseless opponent, or whether there is forcible contact to the head or neck area of a defenseless opponent that goes beyond making a legal tackle, a legal block or playing the ball. In this particular play, the defender was making a legitimate attempt to get to the ball and, upon full review, the call of targeting should have been reversed by the replay official.
“Prior to the 2016 season, the NCAA granted additional authority to replay officials when reviewing on-field targeting calls by changing the standard of review,” the statement continued. “As a result, the replay official now has the authority to re-officiate and review all aspects of the on-field targeting call, and in the absence of specific indicators identified by NCAA targeting standards, the replay official can reverse the on-field call. Additionally, replay officials have the ability, and responsibility, to independently review potential targeting plays that are egregious and not seen, or called, on the field.”
Franklin had said after the game at Michigan that the ejection was “the right call” because if there is “helmet-to-helmet contact with a defenseless player, there’s no gray area, no intent.” Franklin said his argument in the game was that Smith was trying for the interception and had the right to do that.
But as far as submitting the play for conference review, Franklin had said, “The only time you submit something is if it’s something you watch on film that you think is different than what the rule states,” adding, “There’s nothing to really discuss” because the review would just look for the helmet contact and be done.
After practice Wednesday, Franklin wouldn’t confirm if he submitted the play for review or not, citing his worries about being fined.
“I can’t say a whole lot about any of these types of things,” Franklin said. “I was told one thing during the game, so I reinforced that in the press conference, what I was told. And then, obviously, we’ve been in conversations since then with the Big Ten. … That was kind of a unique situation. So I think that’s one of the reasons why the Big Ten came out with a statement, to make sure everybody’s clear because it’s a little bit of gray area. But there’s clearly … a clause for if you’re going for the ball.”
Junior safety Marcus Allen said it is “hard to talk about” the targeting call.
“I wish it could have went the other way,” Allen said. “But I think we’ve just got to play with what cards are dealt to us.”
Smith will be available to play at 3:30 p.m. Saturday at Beaver Stadium against Minnesota, which should be a bit of a relief for the injury-riddled linebacker group.
Megan Ryan: mryan@post-gazette.com and Twitter @theothermegryan.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.