UNIVERSITY PARK, Pa. — Its game Saturday is what it looks like when every problem that Penn State had in a successful start to the season turns worse. There was a bad rushing offense, poor pass protection and a defense that didn't tackle as well as it has and couldn't deal with the lack of offense.
All the turmoil congealed into Penn State's first loss this season, 29-6 to Northwestern in a Big Ten Conference game on a beautiful homecoming day, dampening some of the goodwill and high expectations accrued in a 4-0 start.
"We weren't ready to play [Saturday]," Penn State coach James Franklin said.
Northwestern (2-2, 1-0) came into Saturday having lost nine of its past 11 games dating to last season. Its first victory this season was against Division I-AA Western Illinois. Yet from the beginning, Northwestern played with more precision and energy than Penn State (4-1, 1-1).
By the end of the first quarter, Northwestern led, 14-0. It would led, 14-3, at half and could have led by more had it settled for a field goal or succeeded on a failed fake field-goal attempt.
Still, as the fourth started with the score, 14-6, Penn State could at least take solace in the fact that it had been here before. The Nittany Lions trailed almost the entire game against Rutgers and came back from a late deficit against Central Florida.
"This game didn't turn out like Rutgers did," wide receiver DaeSean Hamilton said.
No it didn't. On the first play of the fourth, Penn State quarterback Christian Hackenberg attempted a short pass to receiver Geno Lewis near midfield. Northwestern's Anthony Walker intercepted it and returned the ball 49 yards for a touchdown.
On Penn State's next play, Northwestern's Xavier Washington sacked Hackenberg, who fumbled. Northwestern's Connor Mahoney recovered it, and a few plays later the Wildcats had a field goal.
Like that, it was 23-6, and Penn State's chances of coming back were all but stifled when, on its next drive, Bill Belton failed to pick up a conversion on fourth-and-1 from Penn State's 30. On the ensuing possession, Northwestern quarterback Trevor Siemian scored his third touchdown of the game -- all on 1-yard rushes.
Though opportunities abounded -- the fake field-goal stop, a 51-yard pass to Hamilton, a third-quarter interception of Siemian -- Franklin said Penn State never translated big plays into momentum.
Momentum is difficult to seize without a consistent offense. Penn State, like it has in all but one game this season, struggled to establish the running game and often failed to protect Hackenberg.
Penn State finished with 50 rushing yards on 25 carries. Hackenberg was sacked four times and tackled several other times. He also caused a scary collision on his own, lowering his shoulder and head into Northwestern defensive back Matthew Harris.
With Hackenberg facing constant pressure, the passing game folded, too. That big gain for Hamilton was about the only memorable play for a passing offense that has mostly been impressive all year.
The players made available for interviews after the game didn't agree with Franklin's assessment about a possible lack of preparation. They blamed the loss on failed execution.
"We're 4-1," Hackenberg said. "We didn't necessarily play our best football [Saturday]. We have a few more opportunities here coming up."
Franklin said he knew Penn State had plenty of issues to fix and hoped the team could get to the off week undefeated.
After Saturday, he'll just have to accept the time off and try correcting the issues with greater urgency.
"We've been able to get by with this by playing smart, playing hard, playing with tremendous effort and persevering," Franklin said. "Let's be honest. We haven't played pretty all year long, and it caught up to us."
Mark Dent: mdent@post-gazette.com, 412-439-3791 and Twitter @mdent05






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.