UNIVERSITY PARK, Pa. — Rutgers coach Kyle Flood won't mention Penn State by name this week. He's calling it "the team from Pennsylvania" or "the neighbors to the west."

The tactic has been employed for ages. It's the cool thing to do for coaches trying to rile up and impress their fan base before rivalry games. And the Rutgers-Penn State game Saturday, the inaugural Big Ten game for the Scarlet Knights, has all the makings of a rivalry, from geography to history to the Big Ten's insistence on expanding into the New York City television market.

The shared history between the schools is surprisingly rich. Greg Schiano, who sparked Rutgers' resurgence in the first decade of this century, coached at Penn State in the mid-1990s. The last Rutgers coach to defeat Penn State, Dick Anderson, graduated from Penn State and coached there as an assistant before and after his tenure at Rutgers. He had six assistants on his Rutgers staff with ties to Penn State.

Anderson's victory against Penn State in 1988 was legendary. So close were the Penn State-Rutgers ties that Sue Paterno interrupted Anderson's postgame news conference to offer a congratulatory kiss.

Advertise with us

"I think there's always been a rivalry," said Michael J. Pellowski, a Rutgers player from the late 1960s and author of the book, "Rutgers Football: A Gridiron Tradition in Scarlet."

" ... They're treating it like it's the first time they've ever bumped heads. That's not true."

Of course, outside of that 1988 game, Penn State has beaten Rutgers every time since 1918. Concerning wins and losses, it hasn't been much of a rivalry. The spirit always has been there, though.

Rutgers faced Penn State from 1950-52 as heavy underdogs, but managed to frighten Penn State, losing by single digits each year. The 1950 game at Beaver Field was enough of a thriller that students tore down the goal posts afterward, according to an article from The Daily Collegian. Such a celebration had last occurred in 1939, against top rival Pitt.

Penn State pulled away from 1953-55, beating Rutgers by an average of 24 points. That massive gulf in success largely defined the series in the coming years. Playing every season from 1977-87, Rutgers lost every game and came within seven points only twice. Rutgers has had 1988 and little else. Success was fleeting or unnoticed.

Advertise with us

Schiano, whose team defeated No. 3 Louisville in 2006, capturing national attention, lost the next week to Cincinnati and never reached a level so high in the coming years. An undefeated season in 1976 famously culminated in an invitation to play McNeese State in the second-tier Independence Bowl (Rutgers declined).

You couldn't really blame fans around the nation for not caring about Rutgers. It was hard enough for people to notice in New Jersey. Thomas Frusciano, Rutgers archivist and author of "Rutgers University Football Vault," grew up in New Jersey around the time of the 1976 undefeated season and remembers following Michigan, the Southeastern Conference and pro football more than Rutgers.

"There's so much going on in this part of the country with the Giants, Jets and Eagles, so college football has never been a top draw for people," Frusciano said.

While Rutgers made it on TV for the rare occasion like the 100th anniversary of its game against Princeton in 1969, Penn State was always on TV. While Rutgers was getting invited to second-tier bowl games even after undefeated seasons, Penn State was playing in well-regarded bowls nearly every year.

Penn State also dominated Rutgers in recruiting. Anderson, for instance, couldn't even get his own son to play for Rutgers when he coached there. Though Anderson insisted back then that he didn't want his son to have to make a choice regarding family, Rutgers fans didn't take it too well when the highly regarded Jeff Anderson left New Brunswick, N.J., for Penn State.

Advertise with us

His move was all too common. In the 1980s, Penn State had at least 15 players from New Jersey on its roster every year and as many as 26. In what correlated with Schiano's tenure, Penn State started taking fewer players from New Jersey. In the 2000s, the Nittany Lions were averaging closer to 10 New Jersey players on their rosters. As recently as 2012, Penn State had seven.

Rutgers' move to the Big Ten is supposed to elevate its status and help the program challenge its western neighbor (as Flood would call Penn State). So far, Penn State is winning. It has 15 players from New Jersey on the current roster, including top wide receiver Saeed Blacknall, who flipped his commitment from Rutgers to Penn State.

Players like Penn State center and New Jersey native Angelo Mangiro insist Saturday is just another game. Don't be fooled. Everyone wants this rivalry to begin anew -- from the suits at the Big Ten pining for East Coast exposure, to Pennsylvanians wanting to maintain their football superiority, to fans in New Jersey wanting college football to increase in importance.

"Nothing is going to rival this Penn State-Rutgers rivalry," Pellowski said of the Rutgers mindset. "This is going to eclipse 150 years of football games and start a new tradition, in my opinion."

Mark Dent: mdent@post-gazette.com, 412-439-3791 and Twitter @mdent05.