UNIVERSITY PARK, Pa. -- Another game had ended with an offense making big plays at the most important occasions, and Penn State linebacker Glenn Carson took his time to answer the question. He seemed legitimately puzzled.
Why has the Penn State defense, otherwise acceptable and at times very good, struggled so much with third downs?
"I'm not exactly sure what went wrong," he said. "Third-down situations are just really hard to work on."
After two games, Penn State's opponents have converted 22 of 36 third downs. That's a success rate of about 61 percent and places Penn State 120th of 124 Division I-A teams. In second halves, the Nittany Lions are worse, allowing opponents to convert 18 of 21 times.
Virginia's final drive of the game Saturday illustrated Penn State's weakness. The Cavaliers faced a third-and-5, a third-and-16, a third-and-11, and a third-and-goal from the 6. They converted all of them.
On the third-and-16, Virginia quarterback Michael Rocco completed a 44-yard pass to tight end Jake McGee. He caught the ball despite a pass interference penalty on Penn State.
Ohio dominated in similar fashion. It converted 11 of 12 third-down opportunities in the second half of the season opener. On its final, game-sealing scoring drive it succeeded on four third downs.
The struggles mark a significant decline for Penn State. From 2008-10, Penn State ranked among Division I-A's top 15 teams at stopping teams on third downs, when its opponents converted an average of 32 percent. Last year, the Lions ranked 56th and allowed conversions at a rate of 40 percent.
Coach Bill O'Brien said Virginia attacked Penn State's vulnerability by throwing long passes, particularly over the middle.
"They made the play," O'Brien said. "I don't think it had anything to do with the scheme. I think it's just us going up and making the play."
In practice, there is little a team can do to directly address third downs. Carson discussed viewing film of all the third down plays. In doing so, the defense can look for the play-calling tendencies of offenses against them, as well as their own tendencies.
But nothing can actually duplicate the feel of a third down during a game. O'Brien said that success on third downs will come with more experience.
"It's just overall awareness," he said. "And our guys are going to get better at that. And it's a new system. It's a new year. Everything is new."
But there is some good news for Penn State. Although only four Division I-A teams have worse third-down defenses, one of them is Navy, Saturday's opponent.
•
NOTES --O'Brien said running backs Derek Day and Bill Belton were day to day with injuries. Day had started in Belton's absence Saturday but left the game in the second half with a shoulder injury. Belton injured his ankle against Ohio. O'Brien said Curtis Dukes would start if both were out Saturday. Dukes had 10 carries for 31 yards against Virginia.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.