FORK UNION, Va. -- Christian Hackenberg's shoulder aches, which makes sense. He threw something like 1,500 passes over three days at a prestigious camp. Later, he will soothe it with a packet of ice, but the comfort can wait. First, he wants to throw a few of his favorite routes.

With every pass he throws, the superlatives attached to him by recruiting websites begin making sense. Hackenberg, a 2013 prospect who has committed and reaffirmed his commitment to Penn State, is the object of national attention because, in addition to being built like a Michelangelo statue, he possesses qualities such as "rare arm strength" and "ideal mechanics." Those skills and many others are immeasurable. They are observed. The experts watch top prospects as many times as they can and make judgments based on experience.

"The evaluation science is an inexact science," said ESPN recruiting director Tom Luginbill.

Yet every year, ESPN and a host of sites like Rivals, Scout and 24-7 Sports, each evaluate 2,000 to 3,000 high school players and rank at least the top 100 of them in a very exact fashion on a list for the world to see.

Advertise with us

The market demands it. Because college football fans want to see an analysis of their team's future and compare it to the future of rival schools and, further, because they will pay for both of these things, Hackenberg has been assigned numerical rankings by several recruiting websites. His rankings vary greatly, perhaps more than any of the other top recruits for 2013.

Read ESPN, and Penn State is getting the No. 1 quarterback in the country, the 16th overall prospect. Read Rivals, and it is getting the No. 7 quarterback in the country, the 143rd overall prospect.

Neither group claims to predict athletic futures with the deftness of Nostradamus. Neither expects to.

"If you hit on roughly 60 percent of your class you've done a hell of a job," Luginbill said.

How they rank

Advertise with us

Hackenberg used to pay attention to the rankings as a middle-school student. He saw them as a goal to reach for when he grew older. About six months ago, he became one of those numbers, but the recruiting websites began tracking him much earlier.

He started at quarterback as a sophomore at Fork Union Military Academy. He threw for 11 touchdowns and more than 1,000 yards. Then, in April 2011, he was named top sophomore quarterback at a National Underclassmen Combine, and two months later the University of Virginia offered him a scholarship. Hackenberg began getting phone calls from recruiting services, many phone calls, sometimes two to three per day. He had been identified.

Though recruiting services learn of prospects via connections with high school coaches, college recruiting coordinators or, as Scout's Scott Kennedy said, "osmosis," a surefire way for a high school player to draw the attention of a Rivals or Scout is through an offer and especially a commitment. The commitment means they prioritize scouting that player over noncommitted players, but they don't give players more credit in their rankings for having an offer or commitment.

The differences between Scout, ESPN and Rivals are minimal. Their rankings are projections for the next level and the NFL. The evaluation staffs largely consist of men with a coaching, playing or recruiting background in football. They look for the same attributes. For quarterbacks like Hackenberg, specifically they look for "measurables," like size and speed, as well as unquantifiable traits like field vision, delivery, leadership, ability to freeze defenders and character.

Recruiting directors of the three companies discussed nearly identical evaluation strategies. Basically, they try to see players in person as much as possible, pore over videotape of a player's highlights and lowlights and pay little attention to high school statistics. They all belittle results from most camps and combines, but realize they must attend the best of them and even play host to them.

Advertise with us

The magic, the transformation of live, raw data to a list, happens three to five times a year, depending on the service. Each site's analysts congregate for the rankings, generally via conference call.

They decide why a 17-year-old cornerback is exactly three spots better than a 17-year-old defensive end. Discussions rarely get heated. They can spend multiple days hashing the rankings out, but the staffs respect each other's opinions.

The impossible does contain somewhat of a method. Certain positions, like quarterback, defensive line or offensive tackle are generally valued more than wide receivers, running backs or safeties.

The hard part, judging the "razor-thin" disparities, really comes down to individual eyes. Each service looks for and grades the same attributes, but they assign different values to them based on the collective experiences of the group.

"We're all looking at it objectively, but it's a subjective process," Kennedy said.

Advertise with us

The process has led to an inconsistent ranking for Hackenberg. ESPN has him as the No. 16 overall prospect, Rivals the No. 143, Scout the No. 57 and 24-7 Sports the No. 25.

Luginbill and ESPN consider Hackenberg the nation's top quarterback for his size, arm strength, throwing velocity, deceptive athleticism and ability to throw off-balance under pressure. Rivals projects six quarterbacks ahead of Hackenberg, Scout five.

Scout commends Hackenberg's mechanics but perceives him as having trouble with reading defenses. Kennedy warns to not undervalue his site's opinion of Hackenberg. He said any of the top six or seven quarterbacks this year could be considered the best. Better yet, don't even expect any of those top six or seven guys to be the nation's best quarterback five years from now. No matter how much research, scouting and evaluating they do, they're going to miss. Everybody in football misses.

"With a small enough sample size, you can prove any point, including that if you want to find a Super Bowl quarterback you should go look in the grocery store," Kennedy said. "Half these guys aren't going to pan out."

The people who make the rankings realize their limitations and, to an extent, their insignificance. It's the people who read them that don't always understand.

Advertise with us

The trouble with rankings

Rivals national recruiting analyst Mike Farrell can't discuss who gave another analyst the veiled death threat -- "check under your car before you start it" -- or the lawsuits. "A legal issue," he said.

Recruiting rankings are meant to entertain fans and attract visitors to websites, but they can turn into a matter of contention for a public that cares too much about a number. The lawsuits and threats stem from parents. From fans, the analysts generally receive a batch of angry emails and tweets. A fan base complains their school's recruits are ranked too low, and the teams in their school's conference have players ranked too high. For them, generous rankings for their school's recruits mean more than accurate ones.

"I don't think they remember right and wrong as much as positive and negative," Kennedy said.

Even the athletes complain. Kennedy remembers when a lineman who hadn't played the previous season because of an injury approached him for a better ranking. Farrell has plenty of similar stories.

Advertise with us

"There are guys out there so focused on rankings they are going to be busts," Farrell said. "That type of prima-donna attitude is either going to be beaten out of them or they will sulk and transfer."

Farrell said Hackenberg and his parents, Nikki and Erick, had never complained about Rivals' ranking, even though it is significantly lower than on other sites. Christian even competed at a Rivals event this summer.

"Erick Hackenberg is a great guy," Farrell said. "He could easily hit me up and say, 'Yo, ESPN has us top 10.' He is not that way at all."

Christian Hackenberg isn't one to patrol the Internet, searching his name for the latest recruiting news. He first heard about his inclusion in the rankings from his dad. A strange mix of apathy, contentment and inspiration lit up Christian's face.

"He has a side to him that allows him to deal with things in control," Nikki says. "He doesn't let things like that elevate him to get cocky or get an ego. He's just like, 'that's nice,' and then he just rolls on."

Advertise with us

His devotion and attention have always centered on the game. Nikki and Erick coached volleyball and football, respectively, at Marian Catholic High School, their alma mater in Tamaqua, Pa. They lived across the street in a farmhouse rented to them by the school.

As early as he can remember, Christian would cross the street and poke his head into his father's drills. His parents wanted him to cling to that excitement and kept him away from organized football until years after his friends.

Everything has unfolded so quickly since then. The family moved to Virginia several years ago and later enrolled Christian in the Fork Union school. A 2010 state championship followed, the offer from Virginia, offers from Alabama, Tennessee, Penn State and others, and those rankings. His younger brother, Adam, suggested these developments have brought some pressure.

"No, it's cool," Christian Hackenberg said. "I really don't think it's pressure."

It's something else, something like awareness. The rankings attract scrutiny, the spotlight always shines, and he has learned to accept it.

Advertise with us

At The Opening, a camp featuring selected top prospects in early July, Hackenberg threw a couple of interceptions. He was frustrated. His thoughts weren't limited to himself for making the bad decision. He thought about the eyes that have been watching him for the past two years. They surely were looking at him during this camp.

All would see his mistake and mark it down in their notebooks. That ranking, the number that attempts to value the skill sets for thousands of high school players, could suffer.

"I just use it as motivation to prove if this guy doesn't evaluate me correctly, I'm going to prove him wrong," Hackenberg said. "Or, if this guy does, I'm going to prove him right."