After NCAA president Mark Emmert announced the severe sanctions the association imposed on Penn State Monday, the high school seniors who had verbally committed to join the Nittany Lions in 2013 were faced with a gut-wrenching choice:
Honor their pledge and join a program that won't be in a bowl game until their senior year at the earliest, or re-open their recruitment and choose another school.
Most of Penn State's 2013 recruiting class stayed silent Monday, absorbing the news and weighing their options. The sanctions include a four-year postseason ban, as well as severe scholarship reductions that could limit the program's ability to remain competitive.
Instead of the typical 85 scholarships, Penn State will be limited to a maximum of 65 scholarship players on the roster from 2014-17.
The Nittany Lions will only be able to offer 15 per year, rather than 25, from 2013-16.
Because of these restrictions, it could take until '20 for Penn State to once again have a full complement of 85 scholarship players.
Only one '13 commitment, Avon, Ohio, defensive back Ross Douglas, publicly revoked his verbal pledge Monday. Douglas' high school coach Mike Elder confirmed the decision, and said the sanctions forced Douglas to re-evaluate his college choice.
"He's just disappointed because he liked [Penn State] coach [Bill] O'Brien and his staff so much," Elder said. "But with all that just happened he decided to look at his other options."
Elder said Douglas was considering "nine or 10" other schools. He has offers from Pitt and West Virginia, among others.
Other Penn State commitments declined to comment on the situation. Belle Vernon offensive lineman Dorian Johnson remained committed to Penn State as of Monday, according to his coach Aaron Krepps, but would not comment on the sanctions.
Linebacker Brandon Bell and defensive end Curtis Cothran also remained committed, but did not comment.
Other Penn State commitments also took to Twitter to express their feelings about the sanctions.
"Today [stinks]," tweeted wide receiver Zach Bradshaw.
New Jersey defensive lineman Garrett Sickels simply tweeted the hashtag "#unfair."
There was, however, some positivity. Sickels said the amount of support he received on Twitter from alumni and fans was "amazing." His high school coach, Nick Giglio, said Sickels would remain committed to Penn State for the long haul.
"He chose Penn State for all the right reasons and those convictions ... they didn't get swayed today," Giglio said.
Four-star offensive lineman Brendan Mahon also seemed to indicate that he would be sticking with the Nittany Lions.
"Since when [are] bowl games more important [than] playing with a great group of kids and great [c]oaches," Mahon tweeted.
"O'Brien has my back I have his #PennState2013."
Still, Mike Farrell, a recruiting analyst for Rivals.com, said he believed O'Brien and his staff would suffer a rash of decommitments over the coming days and weeks.
"The kids aren't talking much and if they are, they're just taking it all in, but I have to think it's going to fall apart," Farrell said. "Figuring the four-year bowl ban, you're essentially telling these kids they're never going to play in a bowl game."
The one thing that could save this year's class, Farrell said, was a big name such as four-star tight end Adam Breneman or four-star quarterback Christian Hackenberg re-affirming their commitments and urging others to do the same.
"Those two guys, I think, are the most important," Farrell said.
Breneman did reconfirm his commitment to Penn State. "I did speak with coach O'Brien and his staff today as I remained committed to Penn State," he said late Monday night.
Farrell estimated that in a best-case scenario, it would take Penn State "seven or eight years" before it would be able to recruit like it did before the Jerry Sandusky scandal.
The sanctions Monday came as a major blow to a program and coaching staff that had been doing well on the recruiting trail to this point.
Penn State's '12 class was ranked 51st nationally by Rivals.com, but the in-progress '13 class was No. 18. That ranking is almost certain to fall after this news.
"The scandal itself didn't kill recruiting," Farrell said. "It hurt last year, yes, but this year was going along smoothly. Kids weren't not going to Penn State because of the scandal. It's the sanctions."





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.