BELLEFONTE, Pa. -- The defense attorney for former Penn State football coach Jerry Sandusky argued in court this afternoon that if the prosecution cannot present additional evidence in the cases of alleged Victims Nos. 2, 6 and 8, then those charges should not be taken before a jury.
Mr. Sandusky is charged with sexual assaults on 10 boys that prosecutors say occurred over a 15-year period. The alleged victims have been identified by numbers.
"We're faced with very heavy charges," argued Mr. Sandusky's attorney, Joe Amendola. "The more charges presented to the jury, the more likely they'll be to think something happened."
McKean County Senior Judge John M. Cleland did not issue a decision on the matter, but did ask the defense if those decisions aren't best left for the jury to decide.
Today's proceeding was the last scheduled pre-trial hearing before jury selection begins Tuesday in Centre County Common Pleas Court.
The judge earlier today denied a motion by defense Mr. Amendola to delay the scheduled start of Mr. Sandusky's criminal trial.
"While June 5th does present its problems," Judge Cleland wrote in his four-page order, "on balance and considering all the interests involved ... no date will necessarily present a better alternative."
Judge Cleland said he held an "in camera," or closed hearing, Tuesday afternoon on Mr. Amendola's motion to delay the start of the trial, one of many unsuccessful motions Mr. Amendola has filed.
Today's 30-minute hearing focused solely on a petition for a writ of habeas corpus filed by the defense months ago. Judge Cleland has reserved judgment on both that and another motion to dismiss regarding the rest of the other alleged victims in the case. Mr. Sandusky argues that the charges are so vague that they are impossible to defend and should not stand.
Specifically this afternoon, Mr. Amendola spoke about alleged Victim No. 8, who has never been identified by the attorney general's office.
In that case, a janitor at the Lasch football building on Penn State's campus reported to his co-workers that in the fall of 2000, he saw Mr. Sandusky performing oral sex on a young boy, who was pinned up against the walls of the shower.
Jim Calhoun, the janitor, reported the incident to his supervisor, but it was never reported to police. Mr. Calhoun, according to the grand jury presentment, has dementia and is unable to testify.
"The commonwealth hasn't indicated it has any evidence other than what custodian, Mr. Calhoun, said," Mr. Amendola argued. "There's no corroborative evidence to show a crime has occurred."
The defense requested a hearing to make the prosecution present evidence showing they have enough to move forward with those charges.
But Deputy Attorney General Frank Fina argued that the comments made by Mr. Calhoun to his coworkers was an "excited utterance" and therefore, an exception to the hearsay rule, and sufficient to move the charge forward.
"Hearsay evidence can be sufficient for evidence beyond a reasonable doubt," he said.
Judge Cleland responded, "There has to be evidence of a crime other than the excited utterance."
He then asked Mr. Fina if that was the case.
"Yes, your honor," Mr. Fina replied.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.