Days before a planned vote by Penn State University's board of trustees on governance reforms, members sought to explain anew their reasoning for actions taken Nov. 9 in the Jerry Sandusky child sex scandal.

But Monday's statement defending the firing of famed football coach Joe Paterno and trustees' acceptance of Penn State President Graham Spanier's resignation contained little new information. It was immediately criticized by the Paterno family and by some alumni as an effort to deflect attention from the board's own failings.

The statement, described as a "report" on Penn State's website, noted what trustees say were leadership failings by Mr. Paterno and Mr. Spanier.

It noted that a graduate assistant went to Mr. Paterno's home on March 2, 2002, and recounted seeing Mr. Sandusky, a former assistant football coach, "fondling or doing something of a sexual nature" to a young boy.

Advertise with us

"While Coach Paterno did his legal duty by reporting that information the next day ... to his immediate superior, the then Penn State Athletic Director Tim Curley, the board reasonably inferred that he did not call police," the statement read. "We determined that his decision to do his minimum legal duty and not to do more to follow up constituted a failure of leadership by Coach Paterno."

It said Mr. Spanier "failed to meet his leadership responsibilities to the board" and "took insufficient action" after learning of the 2002 incident.

"This failure of leadership included insufficiently informing the board about his knowledge of the 2002 incident. He also made or was involved in press announcements between Nov. 5-9 that were without authorization of the board or contrary to its instructions," the statement read.

Trustees said Mr. Spanier -- who they contend in May gave them an insufficient briefing on a grand jury investigation into Mr. Sandusky -- sought a board vote of confidence Nov. 9, five days after Mr. Sandusky's arrest. Instead, trustees "voted that evening unanimously to remove him as president and informed him of that decision."

Afterward, a joint statement by Penn State and Mr. Spanier said he had resigned by mutual agreement. He remains a tenured faculty member.

Advertise with us

Monday's statement comes four days before Friday's expected trustee vote in Hershey on board governance changes -- including new committees and more frequent meetings -- and a day before today's appearance by board chair Karen Peetz and vice chair Keith Masser before the Penn State Faculty Senate.

The Paternos are "surprised and saddened" that trustees felt it necessary to explain yet again their abrupt and unjustified firing of the coach, said a family statement issued by Washington, D.C., attorney Wick Sollers. Mr. Paterno died in January at age 85 of complications from lung cancer.

"Two months ago, as Joe Paterno was dying, the board conducted a series of media interviews condemning him for 'moral' failures. Now they are trying a different tack and accusing him of 'leadership' failures," the statement read. "When will the board step up and acknowledge that the ultimate responsibility for this crisis is theirs?"

Maribeth Schmidt, spokeswoman for the reform group Penn Staters for Responsible Stewardship, said the statement's suggestion that Mr. Paterno's firing was based largely on a grand jury presentment suggests the board "used a Cliff Notes version" of the facts rather than do a thorough investigation, saying presentments are biased toward prosecutors seeking an indictment.

"Franco Harris said it best: 'Do they think we're dumb?' " asked Antony Lubrano, a prominent donor seeking an alumni seat on Penn State's board. "This is an attempt to deflect criticism away from them."