The first real test of legal strategy for Jerry Sandusky will come in two weeks when he and his attorney will have to choose whether to go ahead with a preliminary hearing on the 40 sexual abuse counts against him or waive the hearing to Centre County Common Pleas Court.

Criminal defense attorneys who specialize in sexual abuse cases and high-profile trials believe that it is absolutely necessary for the former Penn State University defensive coordinator to go through with next month's preliminary hearing. To do otherwise, they say, would be a tactical mistake.

"I'd postpone it, and [then] I'd prepare it like I was preparing for trial," said William Difenderfer, the attorney who successfully represented Robert J. Boyda Jr., an oral surgeon who was accused of molesting multiple patients while they were under sedation. "You get a practice swing at these guys."

The hearing, which had been scheduled for Dec. 7, on Tuesday was pushed back to Dec. 13. That announcement came the same day that the Administrative Office of Pennsylvania Courts reported that all of the judges in Centre County have recused themselves from the Sandusky case.

Advertise with us

The state office has now appointed McKean County Senior Judge John M. Cleland to the case. Until he can assume jurisdiction, the AOPC said that any miscellaneous petitions will be heard by Common Pleas Court President Judge Kathy A. Morrow, who sits on the bench of Perry and Juniata counties.

The purpose of the preliminary hearing is to determine whether there is enough evidence against a defendant for a judge or jury to rule in favor of the prosecution. Westmoreland County Senior Judge Robert E. Scott will preside over Mr. Sandusky's preliminary hearing.

Mr. Sandusky's attorney, Joseph Amendola, did not return a phone call seeking comment.

In a case like the one against Mr. Sandusky, which was laid out in a 23-page grand jury presentment, it is likely a preliminary hearing will include testimony from at least some of the eight people identified as victims by the state attorney general's office.

That, Mr. Difenderfer said, is essential to figuring out the defense of the case.

Advertise with us

"If they're going to be dynamite witnesses, I want to know now," he said. "If they're going to crumble, I want to know now."

The idea, Mr. Difenderfer continued, is to have full and thorough cross-examination and try to get the victims to say something inconsistent.

"I'd much rather them be under oath and screw up," he said. "Then we crush them. Even innocent mistakes are points in our favor."

Thomas Mesereau, a California attorney who represented Michael Jackson on child sex abuse charges in 2005, said often the defense team doesn't want to reveal its strategy to prosecutors that early in a case.

But sometimes, it's necessary.

Advertise with us

"Right now, it's the honeymoon period for prosecutors," Mr. Mesereau said. "None of this has been challenged. The defense hasn't yet been able to investigate the allegations of the victims."

Included among the issues the defense likely will raise -- in addition to inconsistencies -- Mr. Difenderfer said, is the prospect of civil litigation being filed by the named victims against Mr. Sandusky and Penn State.

"There are going to be more kids coming out of the woodwork, and they're going to be looking for money," he said.

That, too, can work in favor of the defense by showing a hidden motive in reporting the crime.

Every little bit done to undermine the prosecution case could lead to a negotiated plea, Mr. Difenderfer said.

Advertise with us

There can be benefits to waiving a preliminary hearing in a criminal case. They can include an agreement between the prosecution and defense to get discovery turned over more quickly than is legally required; or possibly having an agreement for a bail reduction, and occasionally, the prosecution may even withdraw serious counts in a case when a defendant agrees to forgo the preliminary hearing.

But those offers are unlikely in a case like this, said Chris Capozzi, a former prosecutor with both the Allegheny County district attorney's office and the state attorney general's office.

He thinks it's likely the prosecution in the Sandusky case will welcome having the preliminary hearing.

"Some of the truly, truly gory details that aren't part of the grand jury presentment will be [made] part of the public record and will make it even more difficult for Mr. Sandusky to defend the charges," Mr. Capozzi said.

It may be difficult for the alleged victims to testify, but he doesn't think that will impede the case.

Advertise with us

"This is a case where witnesses have been interviewed, been prepared to testify at grand jury and [will be] prepared to testify [at the preliminary hearing,]" Mr. Capozzi said. "I wouldn't think they'd be surprised."

Mr. Difenderfer acknowledges that getting more detail out about the alleged crime could hurt the defense. But, he said, it's too late to worry about that.

"How does it get worse for this Penn State guy? It's all already out there," Mr. Difenderfer said.