UNIVERSITY PARK, Pa. -- As the charges, accusations and altercations pile up, the Penn State University football program's once-pristine image is suffering.

The Nittany Lions have taken multiple off-the-field hits since April 1, with the apparent low point coming during the past nine days.

In less than 48 hours from Oct. 5 through Oct. 7, there were five different incidents involving not only the players, but also the team's 80-year-old head coach, Joe Paterno. And on Friday, former starting tailback Austin Scott was charged with raping a female student at the Nittany Apartments complex.

Steve Garban, vice chairman of the university Board of Trustees and a former Nittany Lions football captain, said the incidents are troubling but should not be cause for overreaction.

Advertise with us

"I think it concerns everyone, any time you have these incidents," he said. "But it's happening at a lot of colleges. I don't think we're unique. I don't think it's any trend. I don't think anything's changed in the program."

Rarely, though, has Mr. Paterno faced so much turmoil in such a short time span during his 42 seasons as head coach.

Mr. Scott, a fifth-year senior who started two games this season, was arraigned Friday on felony charges of rape, sexual assault and two counts of aggravated indecent assault. He also faces misdemeanor charges of simple assault and indecent assault, according to university police.

He is free on $50,000 bail and has a preliminary hearing Wednesday. His attorney, Joseph Amendola, said Mr. Scott and the woman had consensual sex and "we intend to prove it.''

On Oct. 5, eight hours after the allegations were lodged against Mr. Scott, Mr. Paterno had a run-in with a female driver along Bigler Road, near the Food Science Building. The university employee, whose name has not been released, told police that a man, later identified as the coach, committed a traffic violation and acted in a disorderly manner toward her. Neither Mr. Paterno nor the woman was charged.

Advertise with us

Later that night, freshman tailback Joe Suhey, the son of former Penn State and Chicago Bears fullback Matt Suhey, was cited for underage drinking.

Another freshman, punter Ryan Breen, was issued a citation for the same offense shortly after 3 a.m. Oct. 7, a little over an hour after some of his teammates may have been involved in a fight at the HUB-Robeson Center. One person was treated for a bloody nose. Penn State police are investigating.

In mid-August, tight end Andrew Quarless and cornerback Willie Harriott were cited for underage drinking, and each sat out two games as punishment.

Trouble also occurred in the spring. University administrators disciplined 10 football players for their roles in a brawl on April 1 at an off-campus party. Two people were hurt and treated at a hospital.

Six Penn State players initially were charged in that incident, but charges were dismissed against four.

Advertise with us

Two players, safety Anthony Scirrotto and defensive tackle Chris Baker, are scheduled to stand trial in December.

Mr. Scirrotto is charged with a felony count of criminal trespass and a summary offense of harassment. Mr. Baker faces felony charges of burglary and criminal trespass, misdemeanor assault and summary harassment. Both remain on the team.

Mr. Paterno responded by ordering his players to clean up sections of Beaver Stadium the morning after each home game.

"It's obvious Joe has punished kids," said Mr. Garban, explaining that he believes the recent spate of off-field incidents should not reflect poorly on Mr. Paterno. "He's tried to instill values. It will run its course."

Neither Penn State President Graham Spanier nor athletic director Tim Curley responded to requests for interviews last week.

Advertise with us

But Gregg Garrity, who caught the winning touchdown pass in the Sugar Bowl that lifted Penn State to its first national championship in 1982, said he believes the current players must use better judgment.

"They need to realize their actions not only reflect on themselves, but on the school, their families and even the alumni," said Mr. Garrity, a North Allegheny High School graduate who now owns a construction company and lives in Bradford Woods.

"I'm not trying to put anyone down. We were all kids in college at one time and we all did stupid stuff. But when it gets to bordering on criminal actions, you have to do the time.''

Mr. Garrity said he believes Mr. Paterno has gotten "a little bit easier" on his players over the years.

"When I played, if you were late for a meeting, he would throw you out. You were gone. No questions asked. Now it seems like he gives guys second and third chances."

Advertise with us

Public scrutiny of the program has intensified during the past 28 years, however.

"The media is just so much more prevalent now than it was back in 1979, because everybody has a computer and the Internet and there's a lot more television coverage," Mr. Garrity said. "The minute something happens, everybody has it instantly."

Jim Meister, past president of the State College Quarterback Club, which supports the Penn State football program, said Mr. Paterno's team remains one to be proud of.

"I hate the fact that a few negative things detract from a program that has had success with honor. It's very upsetting," Mr. Meister said.

Mr. Paterno's relationship with the players remains strong, and he is accessible to them, said junior receiver Jordan Norwood.

Advertise with us

"It's as easy as calling the secretaries to see if he's in the office, or for a lot of guys, it's as easy as calling his home phone number or stopping by his house," Mr. Norwood said. "He's that type of coach, he's that type of person, really, who loves to communicate with his players and have that open relationship."

Jennifer DiNardo, a junior life science major who graduated from Center Area High School in Beaver County, said the recent string of incidents "is not good."

"But it's kind of a shame that we're focusing on all this negative stuff during football season," she said. "We should be focusing more on the team and the games and the spirit of Penn State.

"Coach Paterno's a legend. I'd be nervous to see what would happen if he wasn't here."

Paul Morrison, a 1966 Penn State graduate and former season ticket holder who lives in Strabane Township in Washington County, doesn't blame Mr. Paterno for the recent off-the-field incidents, but Mr. Morrison could do without the recurring problems.

"It's disappointing," Mr. Morrison said. "The kids are brought in with the expectation that their behavior will be in line. And when it's not, it tarnishes the university's image."