A year ago, Lavon Chisley spent his time preparing for an upcoming NFL tryout, an opportunity that never came.

Lavon Chisley in 2003.

Click photo for larger image.

This week, the former Penn State football player is being held in the Centre County Correctional Facility on first- and third-degree homicide charges, preparing a fight to demonstrate his innocence.

Advertise with us

Mr. Chisley, 23, was arrested Tuesday by order of Centre County district attorney Michael Madeira, who believes evidence compiled during a seven-month investigation ties the ex-player to the killing of Langston Carraway, stabbed 93 times in early June.

The arraignment two days ago -- during which Mr. Chisley sobbed in the presence of his mother -- provided the latest and most serious low point for the former defensive end.

Both DNA evidence and Mr. Chisley's erratic behavior around and after the time of Mr. Carraway's death prompted the charges, which Mr. Chisley's attorney, Karen Muir, had long anticipated. (Police in July began calling Mr. Chisley, of Waldorf, Md., a "person of interest" in the case.)

Although most key evidence developed over the summer, the investigation required seven months, Mr. Madeira said, because "there were other pieces of evidence we wanted to follow up on -- to make sure there either wasn't someone else involved, or something that would point us in another direction."

According to the police affidavit, investigators on June 5 found Mr. Carraway's body on the couch of his own residence. He was dead from blood loss. He'd last been reported seen alive on June 3, by one of his brothers, who lived with Mr. Chisley.

Advertise with us

At the scene, police found a "thick, bloody, black, shiny rubber glove" a few feet from Mr. Carraway, 26, a Penn State senior. Later analysis indicated two things: Blood on the outside of the glove belonged to Mr. Carraway. And, DNA on the inside of the glove matched that of Mr. Chisley.

Mr. Chisley, who'd been dropped from the football team for academic reasons before his senior season, never attended Mr. Carraway's funeral or contacted his family.

Instead, according to the affidavit, he planned a June 4 trip to Baltimore with a female friend -- one that he decided to move forward by two hours. (Police believe Mr. Carraway died late on June 3 or early June 4.) Mr. Chisley had a "sense of urgency," to leave town, his friend, Kerry Onaka, told police. While they were packing, Ms. Onaka found a pair of rubber gloves in Mr. Chisley's jacket, matching what was found at the crime scene.

At the end of June, Mr. Chisley asked Ms. Onaka to tell police he'd stayed with her on the night of June 3.

Mr. Chisley believes he is innocent of the charges, Ms. Muir said yesterday. That in part explains why on Monday night he voluntarily drove to Centre County from New Jersey, where he'd been living, to meet the likely charges.

Advertise with us

"It's a demonstration of his innocence," Ms. Muir said. "Most guilty people would flee."

In mid-March 2006, Mr. Chisley, despite missing the most recent football season, attended a workout to display his skills for NFL scouts. Though he'd been a backup in 2004, his speed and athleticism attracted some interest. Still, he was never drafted.

The following months provided a litany of problems, including several drug possession charges. Mr. Chisley's financial debt provided what Mr. Madeira identifies as the motive for the homicide. When seen on June 3 at a liquor store, Mr. Carraway carried a large wad of cash and wore an expensive watch.

Mr. Chisley, according to the affidavit, owed thousands of dollars to, among others, an unnamed sports agent, a tattoo artist and a dog breeder.

A preliminary hearing is scheduled for Jan. 26.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.