rathskeller:

Last weekend's game -- Michigan hangover? Or does the offense just stink?

Ray Fittipaldo: I have to believe the offense just stinks. The running game has been out of sync for two weeks in a row. That's what drives the rest of the offense. When you can't run the ball, it's more difficult to throw because defenses sit back and wait for it. Until the running game gets better, the defense is going to have to win games like it did on Saturday.

poz_s_posse: Have not seen much of Purdue this season, but are they like most Purdue teams -- can hang 40 on anyone, but can't play D?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: I have not seen much of Purdue. Only a little here and there on television, but not a full game. The passing statistics for Curtis Painter are very impressive, but he struggled last week against a good team. Purdue has not beaten a good team yet. Their two Big Ten victories came against Minnesota and Northwestern. I think the PSU defense has an edge in this game. It will be up to the offense to put up a touchdown or two.

Dwilliams1: From an unbiased view, who is the better QB: Tyler Palko or Anthony Morelli?

Ray Fittipaldo: Based on this season -- and that's the only fair way to do it since Palko is a three-year starter and this is Morelli's first year -- the nod has to go to Palko. He has picked up his play from last season and has put up some good numbers despite a suspect offensive line and running game. But Pitt is sort of like Penn State. The Panthers have not beaten a good team yet. Palko has not done as well versus Michigan State or Rutgers. Just like Morelli has not done well against Notre Dame, Ohio State and Michigan. Mid-term grades: I'd give Palko an A- and Morelli a B.

jdl148: Is it that the offense cant put a complete game together? Or that if its not one thing its another? i.e. if tony hunt is running well, then the WRs stink ... or if the blocking is there, then Morelli cant find anyone ... etc etc

Ray Fittipaldo: From what Paterno has said the past couple of weeks the biggest problem the Lions have is the offensive line. He has continually made sure to state that Morelli is not the problem and that he is playing well. He has praised Hunt all year and when asked about the WRs, he says mostly nice things. What does that leave? The O-line. When some teams don't have good offensive lines, they'll change and do some 3-step drops to take the pressure off the line. Or they'll scheme different ways to take the pressure off the line. PSU has not done that. They have kept with what they have done in the past and it seems to be costing them.

Advertise with us

pittmance30: Ray, shouldn't Penn State be concerned about more about the lack of development of Anthony Morelli? It seems as if the only passes he can complete are WR screens and dump passes. Also, what is your honest prediction this Saturday against Purdue?

Ray Fittipaldo: I actually think Morelli is doing OK. Not great, but OK. He does not have the time you need to complete passes down field. He is not a polished QB by any means. He misses open receivers and takes some sacks he should not, but I don't believe he is a big problem for this offense. If he was, I think you would have seen Daryll Clark more often. As for this week's game against Purdue, I will go with the home team. Penn State is not playing well, does not seem to play well on the road and struggles in early games. This one starts at 11:00 am so I'll say Purdue 17 Penn State 10.

jdl148: tougher game, Purdue or Wisc.?

Ray Fittipaldo: Definitely Wisconsin. The Badgers killed Purdue on its home field last week. Purdue is not a very good team. I just don't think Penn State is all that great at this point either.

poz_s_posse: Is this OLine developing though? I thought Ive read some good things about Shipley and Cadogen?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: It's regressing. The running game was posting some very good numbers through the first six games. They rushed for 130-some yards against No. 1 Ohio State, went up and down the field on them. The past two weeks have been atrocious. You might have heard some good things about Shipley, but I have not heard one good thing about Cadogan since August. He was supposed to be a good player, but he is now second-string.

TonyO: As the reputed No. 1 high school recruit in the country, why do you think D. Williams has been so disappointing?

Ray Fittipaldo: It seems to me that Williams is not as elusive in the open field this year compared to last year. I cannot remember him catching a pass and making someone miss. It just has not happened. The coaches point to the fact that he is being double-teamed on any occasions. But if that's the case, Deon Butler and Jordan Norwood should be having better years. So I don't know if I believe the double-team thing they like to talk about. He is working with a new QB who seems to like to throw to Butler and Jordan Norwood more often. And the O-line is not very good. Add it all up and you have a disappointing season. I might add that some people who cover Penn State feel that he was overrated coming out of high school. Maybe we're expecting too much from him.

flatiron: When I watch this young offense, it seems that every aspect of it had gotten better over the first few weeks -- blocking, Morelli, running ... has there been a regression that last two weeks? and WHERE are the WRs?

Ray Fittipaldo: Big-time regression as I stated earlier. It all goes back to the O-line. I hate to simplify it like that, but the way this offense is constructed the offense is going to struggle until the line comes around and plays better.

Advertise with us

TonyO: Wow Ray, you're sound really down today. With Poz, Levi, Hunt, Shaw, Johnson leaving after this season, is there any hope for the future?

Ray Fittipaldo: Just calling it like I see it. I don't think anyone who covers the team on a daily basis would have much good to say about the offense after the past two weeks. PSU does lose some very good players, but they'll have enough returning players to be near the top of the league standings next year if for no other reason that Michigan and Ohio State will not be as good. Yes, there is hope, but they have to start figuring some thigns out.

friend_of_the_devil: Still 8-4 then?

Ray Fittipaldo: Not if they lose out there. I'm starting to think 7-5. Lost to Purdue and Wisconsin and beat Temple and Michigan State. But I'd like to see 8-4 because that's what I predicted at the beginning of the year.

TonyO: Cheer up Ray. JoePa HAS to retire one of these years. Then we won't have to put up with this crap!

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: It looks like they're going to make him hang it up after next year, the final year of his contract, whether he wants to go or not. At least that's the word from people around the program. I'll believe it when I see it. I still think he coaches until he's 100.

GEORGE: Is Morelli as good as we thought during recruiting?

Ray Fittipaldo: Well, he has not lived up to the billing yet, but there are circumstances preventing him from reaching his potential like the O-line. I will remind you that there was quite a bit of negative talk about Morelli during the recruiting process about his ability to read defenses and his lack of playing time in a passing offense at Penn Hills.

Paterno4prez: Do you think holding the all time win record affects Paterno and Bowden's decision on retirement? How important is it to them?

Ray Fittipaldo: It looks like Bowden is going through something like Joe went through a few years ago. The boosters and trustees want him out and Bobby does not want to go. I would like to think that the record does not affect their decision-making, but I'm sure they both have big egos. Maybe they'll end up tied at the end of the year and they mutually decide to step down.

Advertise with us

poz_s_posse: Can we win on the road at all?

Ray Fittipaldo: Sure. PSU beat Minnesota in overtime at the Metrodome. They have played well at times. The Ohio State game was very well-played on both sides. The Buckeyes just made a few more plays in the fourth quarter.

Ray Fittipaldo: Thanks for the questions this week, guys. Check out my online Q&A tomorrow for more Penn State thoughts for the week. See you again next week.