guru:
I see that Joe dodged the question in his press conf. but this team is reminiscent of 2002 in that they can't get over the hump in the big games, i'd say the difference though is that team was all seniors, whereas this group is laying good groundwork for next season?
Ray Fittipaldo: Yeah, he did dodge my question this week. In 2002, Penn State lost to Ohio State, Michigan and Iowa, all in close games. It turned out that Ohio State was the national champions and Iowa played in a BCS bowl that year. Michigan, I believe, played in the Outback Bowl. Every one of those teams were really good. I think the same holds true this year with Notre Dame, michigan and Ohio State. That group was senior-dominated. This group is young, which bodes well for the future.
friend_of_the_devil: Tony Hunt or Mike Hart -- who won the RB battle in your opinion?
Ray Fittipaldo: Mike Hart won the game and had better statistics, but it's hard to judge Hunt against a defensive front like Michigan's. He had absolutely no help from his offensive line. If you put Hart behind that Lions' O-line and had him run against the Michigan defense the outcome would not have been a whole lot different. I think both players will play on Sundays. Hunt will be drafted fairly high. He is a very underrated back nationally.
JoeD: WIll Sean Lee be better than Poz?
Ray Fittipaldo: Sean Lee has received only rave reviews from everyone from the coaches to his peers, but it's too early in his career to make that kind of judgment. He just needs to keep playing the way he is and the accolades will come. That being said, Posluszny was so good last year, it's hard to imagine anyone ever equalling his level of play from 2005.
Rolled_Up_Pants: Given how weak the Big Ten has turned out to be this year, is Wisconsin the only team we have left with a prayer of beating us?
Ray Fittipaldo: I would hardly say the Big Ten is weak. Ohio State and Michigan are 1-2 this week and Wisconsin is No. 21. Iowa is good. Penn State is good. Wisconsin is the only remaining ranked team on the schedule, but beware of next week's game at Purdue. The Boilermakers can always play offense.
friend_of_the_devil: You see Hunt then as a Laurence Maroney type? Late 1st round?
Ray Fittipaldo: It's hard to say at this point, but I would definitely say he'll be drafted in the first three rounds. He is big, has good speed and is durable -- just what NFL teams are looking.
JoeD: So then you think Poz isn't even as good as Poz this year?
Ray Fittipaldo: I think that's been fairly obvious. I'm not convinced yet that it's because of his knee, but it very well could be. The coaches are asking him to do different things than last year. He's playing a new position. I still think he is very good, but he's not playing to his level of last season.
Nittanyfanman: How much cash do you think Poz cost himself by coming back for his senior year? He clearly isn't the same player he was last season. I'm guessing he has slipped to late second, early third round at this point. He may fall even further after the combines when the scouts see how much speed he has lost.
Ray Fittipaldo: I don't know that he had much choice. He was not going to be drafted in the first round with an iffy health situation. NFL teams would not have invested a high pick on him not knowing how the knee would hold up. He had to come back. It would be a shame if he has slipped out of the first round, but it could happen. I will be anxious to see what he does at the combine. His numbers in Indianapolis will determine where he is drafted, not his play this year. I think NFL people are smart enough to figure out that he's playing a new position this year and is rebounding from a knee injury.
traffic: I think PSU played better in the OSU loss than the UofM loss. What do you think?
Ray Fittipaldo: Yeah, I think so. The common denominator in both of those games was the defense played well and the offense could not produce. In the Ohio State game, they went up and down the field but just could not capitalize. It was much tougher to move the ball against Michigan. I think Michigan is better than Ohio State, but that game is in Columbus this year, which might be the difference.
guru: Were my eyes deceiving me, or did I see Lydell Sargent enter the game? And will we see more?
Ray Fittipaldo: You will see more of Sargeant and freshman AJ Wallace. The coaches like both players. It's not that starter Tony Davis is a bad player. He is solid, but he does not have the upside of a guy like Wallace, who could be a shutdown corner and high NFL draft pick someday.
tontos_demise: Did you almost laugh out loud when Joe insisted that last year's Illinois game was closer than it was? The Illini have a pulse this season, what should PSU be concerned about?
Ray Fittipaldo: Nothing. Illinois lost to Ohio U last week. If Penn State is focused this game should be over at halftime.
jdl148: 4-3 -- do these guys have a chance to win out? what is your projection? and which bowl? some place warm, I hope!
Ray Fittipaldo: They have a chance, yes, but I don't think it's likely. I think they'll win all of them except at Wisconsin. That would put them at 8-4 and would land them in either the Outback Bowl or Alamo Bowl if Michigan and Ohio State are in the BCS. I think this team is good, but they still have to prove it in a big game.
traffic: Morelli has a heckuva gun on his arm. I am worried about his accuracy, though. Do you see improvement in that area? I'd like to think that next year he is going to be really good, and it is just his inexperience that is hurting him.
Ray Fittipaldo: He is getting better every week. I've said all along that he just needs to play. The accuracy will come. The chemistry with his receivers will come. The big plays will come. Now that the toughest part of the schedule is out of the way, I would not be surprised if you saw big improvement over the final five weeks if he is healthy.
Nittanyfanman: Ray, I think you generally try to avoid being a homer but enough with the "Penn State has played three top 5 teams" and "Penn State has played the toughest schedule" stuff. It is ridiculous to keep mentioning that Notre Dame was ranked in the Top 5 at the beginning of the season. Those rankings mean squat! Clearly Notre Dame is not a top 5 team. As for the toughest schedule, Michigan State has played the same teams Penn State has plus a really tough Pitt squad. Just about every team in the SEC has a tougher schedule than PSU. Let's be realistic here. We're lucky this season that the Big 10 is down a little even though it's still probably the third or fourth best conference behind the SEC, Big East and maybe the Pac 10.
Ray Fittipaldo: Notre Dame might not be in the top 5 but the Irish are in the top 10. There's no getting around how tough the schedule has been. I would not be doing my job if I didn't point it out. I realize the SEC is tough, but Ohio State and Michigan, regardless of what happens the rest of the season, very well may be the two best teams in the country. And you're absolutely nuts if you believe the Big East is better than the Big Ten. The Big East has rallied, but Pitt and Rutgers would be under .500 if they played in the Big Ten.
JoeD: I hate to look past this game, but I see Purdue and Wisconsin as being the only real remaining challenges on the slate. What do you know about those teams?
Ray Fittipaldo: I know Purdue has a very good offense and I know Wisconsin's only loss was to Michigan. Bret Bielema has done a wonderful job in his first season after taking for Barry Alvarez. I would say of the two games, the Badgers will be the tougher opponent.
Nittanyfanman: Hey Ray. My question is why are so many Lions fans satisfied with mediocrity? Like Sean Lee said, we should have a team that beats good teams, not one that is satisfied to "play with them". Enough with these moral victories! We're one bad call (in our favor) away from being 3-4. This all falls back on the coach. We need some fresh, young blood to revitalize this program and Joe must go! To borrow a line from Dick Vitale, Joepa is not exactly a Diaper Dandy anymore.
Ray Fittipaldo: In talking to about 6 or 8 players this week I don't think any of them are satisfied with mediocrity. They all talked about being frustrated and needing to win a big game. I thought Lee's remarks summed up the way most of his teammates feel. It's not good enough to come close against these top-ranked teams. Sooner or later, they're going to have to rise up and beat someone with a pedigree to be recognized.
jeffers17: After PSU plays at Temple next year, will the lions try to have eight home games every other year? I love the home and home series against other marquee schools but the rest of the non-conference schedule are just moneymakers. What is holding back the PSU-pitt rivalry? I know JoePa is bitter but he is smarter than that. Couldn't PSU just play Pitt at home when they are playing Syracuse away? There would be some scheduling conflicts but Penn State still would end up with seven home games.
Ray Fittipaldo: Yes, the athletic department would love to have eight home games every year. They need 8 games to balance the budget. That's probably the biggest sticking point in playing Pitt. They need an eighth home game to generate more revenue. The way it is set up now, Penn State has only one marquee non-conference game every year. That makes sense. If you want to have national championship aspirations, you need to set yourself up for a run and you don't do that by playing a tough non-conference schedule.
Nittanyfanman: OK Ray, now I have to retract my previous statement. Pitt and Rutgers would completely destroy Indiana, Illinois (Rutgers already has), Northwestern, Minnesota, Purdue, and Iowa (who was vastly overrated). They would beat Penn State 7 or 8 times out of ten and Wisconsin probably 5 out of 10. Michigan State would beat them at the beginning of the year like they always do and lose to them at the end of the year like they always do. OSU and Michigan would beat them. So overall, Pitt and Rutgers would be around 8-3 or 7-4 against Big 10 teams this season. How is that under .500 again?
Ray Fittipaldo: You're dreaming.
jdl148: With the fierce rush Mich. was throwin', how come no short routes to the TE?
Ray Fittipaldo: I thought they need to throw to the tight end more and more screen passes. The problems is their best tight end is a freshman and he may not be up to speed with his knowledge of the offense and the passing game. I don't know why Hall did not try more screens, though. Michigan was charging hard and they needed to stem that a little bit.
Ray Fittipaldo: Guys, thanks for the questions this week. We'll see you same time next week. Look for my online Q&A tomorrow.
Log in and chat with Ray Fittipaldo about Penn State football on Thursdays at 1 p.m.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.